With a focus on data and reproducibility, Trevor Lane presents a case on falsification of data by co-authors, with reference to COPE guidance...
View this email in your browser ([link removed])
COPE Digest
OCTOBER 2019, Vol 7
Issue 10: Data & Reproducibility
Dear Digest Readers,
The last week in September was a very busy one for COPE. We began our week of meetings in Leiden with the European Seminar and had 84 members in attendance. The theme on daily realities and future challenges was just that. We focused on a number of daily realities for our members.
Highlights included an excellent presentation on text recycling by Cary Moskovitz, David Hansen and Michael Pemberton, a session on retractions which included an update on COPE’s newly revised retraction guidelines from Council member Howard Browman, a presentation on the Scientometrics of retractions from Thed van Leeuwen, and a presentation from a publisher’s perspective on retraction by Catriona Fennell. I did a presentation on predatory publishing. I want to thank everyone for their feedback on my session and have sent out my powerpoint to everyone who requested the slides. Deborah Kahn presented an overview of the study we completed this past year on our members in the Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences. An unusual treat for attendees was a presentation by Frank van Koffschooten, a journalist, who shared his 25 year experience as a journalist working on publication ethics violations.
For more, including links to the seminar presentations...
READ MORE ([link removed]) >
COPE Chair Deborah Poff
DATA FABRICATION IN A REJECTED MANUSCRIPT
A journal rejected two manuscripts because of data fabrication, as confirmed by an inspection of the original patient data. Without the lead author knowing, the co-authors had fabricated the dataset after recruiting only a few patients. The lead author was cleared of misconduct in an institutional investigation but later published one of the manuscripts and other suspicious manuscripts in other journals.
In this case discussion Trevor Lane shares advice given by the COPE Forum, adds to the discussion with further analysis and links to guidance relevant to all disciplines.
READ MORE > ([link removed])
[link removed]
UPDATED AUTHORSHIP DISCUSSION DOCUMENT
COPE's Authorship Discussion Document provides practical advice on addressing the most common issues around authorship with specific guidance where there seems to be consensus and asking for further comments from COPE members in some areas.
READ DISCUSSION DOCUMENT > ([link removed])
THANK YOU AND FAREWELL
We say a fond farewell to six of our Council Members who have reached the end of their term with COPE and thank them for all the work they have done over the years.
Thank you Vivienne Bachelet, Mirjam Curno, Jason Hu, Iria del Río, Behrooz Astaneh and Alison Taylor.
READ MORE > ([link removed])
A new training programme to help researchers avoid predatory publishers, mixed levels of tolerance to text recycling amongst editors in North America, and a portable peer review platform due to launch this winter.
READ FULL NEWS SUMMARY > ([link removed])
Predatory Publishing
The US National Science Foundation has awarded researchers at Texas Tech University a grant to develop a training program for researchers to learn to identify and avoid predatory publishers. The goal is for the program to be free and online.
READ MORE > ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
Research Misconduct
Interviews with journal editors in North America show a wide-range of tolerance for Text Recycling, from tolerance to absolute intolerance. The authors surmise in the abstract that the editors at times have trouble aligning their beliefs and practices.
READ MORE > ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
Peer Review
In December 2019, Review Commons will be launched where authors can post their work prior to submission to a traditional journal and it will undergo "high-quality and in-depth peer review". The reviews, through bioRxiv, can be transferred to participating journals. www.reviewcommons.org
READ MORE > ([link removed])
READ FULL NEWS SUMMARY > ([link removed])
NOVEMBER FORUM: SUBMIT A CASE
MONDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2019: WEBINAR
4 - 5.30pm GMT
(COPE Members Only)
The November Forum will follow the usual format where we have a discussion topic, followed by members' cases presented for discussion and advice from all those participating in the Forum. The discussion topic for the Forum in November: Artificial Intelligence (AI) in decision making.
#C0PEForum
[link removed]
COPE WORKSHOP CHILE
COPE hosted a workshop at the IV Scientific Editor’s Forum at the Universidad de Los Lagos, in Santiago, Chile, facilitated by Vivienne C. Bachelet (editor-in-chief of Medwave ([link removed]) and Associate professor of Universidad de Santiago de Chile) and Iria del Río (editor of Revista Española de Cardiología ([link removed]) ).
READ MORE > ([link removed])
COPE WORKSHOP NORWAY
26 NOVEMBER 2019
In the run up to the Munin conference on scholarly publishing, COPE is holding a pre-conference workshop on peer review for editors, expertly run by COPE Council members Howard Browman and Mirjam Curno. The workshop is at University of Tromsø, The Arctic University of Norway, campus Breivika.
READ MORE ([link removed]) >
COPE speakers
JAPAN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY AGENCY (JST) and INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STM PUBLISHERS
21 October 2019
TOKYO, JAPAN
Trevor Lane, COPE Council, will speak on behalf of COPE at this event themed, "The transformation in scholarly publishing: Research integrity and publication ethics."
MORE INFORMATION > ([link removed])
CHARLESTON CONFERENCE
4 - 8 November 2019
CHARLESTON, USA
COPE will be speaking about publication ethics challenges in arts, humanities, and social sciences and what this means for librarians. Also in this session, giving different perspectives on the issues, are Jennie McMillan, Taylor and Francis, and Claire Sewell, Cambridge University Library.
MORE INFORMATION ([link removed]) >
Other Events
MEDICAL JOURNAL EDITORS SHORT COURSE
13 - 15 November 2019
OXFORD, UK
This international workshop is designed to help editors ensure their journals achieve the maximum impact with the best research.
MORE INFORMATION ([link removed]) >
** COPE Digest Editors:
------------------------------------------------------------
Deborah Kahn, Publishing Director, Taylor & Francis
Nancy C Chescheir, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Obstetrics and Gynecology
============================================================
COPE - Promoting Integrity in Research and it's Publication
** facebook.com/publicationethics ([link removed])
** facebook.com/publicationethics ([link removed])
** @C0PE ([link removed])
** @C0PE ([link removed])
** LinkedIn ([link removed])
** LinkedIn ([link removed])
** Publicationethics.org ([link removed])
Copyright ©2019 COPE,
All rights reserved.
Registered charity No 1123023. Registered in England and Wales, Company No 6389120
Registered office: New Kings Court, Tollgate, Chandler's Ford, Eastleigh, Hampshire, SO53 3LG, UK
You are receiving this email because you or your journal is a member of COPE or you have subscribed to COPE emails.
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.
