[ Democracy Now interviews director Santiago Mitre about
“Argentina, 1985,” his dramatization of the Trial of the Juntas,
when a civilian court prosecuted Argentina’s former military leaders
for brutal crimes committed during the U.S.-backed right-wing military
dictatorship from 1976 to 1983. The film just won a Golden Globe for
Best Motion Picture in a Non-English Language and is also shortlisted
for an Oscar for best international film. ]
[[link removed]]

PORTSIDE CULTURE

“ARGENTINA, 1985”: OSCAR-SHORTLISTED FILM DEPICTS HISTORIC WAR
CRIMES TRIAL OF U.S.-BACKED GENERALS  
[[link removed]]


 

Democracy Now
January 13, 2023
Democracy Now
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ Democracy Now interviews director Santiago Mitre about
“Argentina, 1985,” his dramatization of the Trial of the Juntas,
when a civilian court prosecuted Argentina’s former military leaders
for brutal crimes committed during the U.S.-backed right-wing military
dictatorship from 1976 to 1983. The film just won a Golden Globe for
Best Motion Picture in a Non-English Language and is also shortlisted
for an Oscar for best international film. _

"Argentina, 1985", Slant Magazine

 

Democracy Now  speaks with director Santiago Mitre about
“Argentina, 1985,” his dramatization of the Trial of the Juntas,
when a civilian court prosecuted Argentina’s former military leaders
for brutal crimes committed during the U.S.-backed right-wing military
dictatorship from 1976 to 1983. The film just won a Golden Globe for
Best Motion Picture in a Non-English Language and is also shortlisted
for an Oscar for best international film. Mitre talks about following
the landmark trial in Argentina as a boy, just a short time after the
end of the dictatorship, and why he felt compelled to tell the story
as a filmmaker. “The decision of the government to do this trial was
very brave and very important, and it founded the basis of the new
democracy,” says Mitre.

AMY GOODMAN: We begin today’s show looking at the new
film _Argentina, 1985_ about the Trial of the Juntas, the civilian
court that prosecuted Argentina’s former military leaders for brutal
crimes committed during the U.S.-backed right-wing military
dictatorship from 1976 to '83. The film is based in part on the story
of Julio Strassera and Luis Moreno Ocampo, who prosecuted the
Argentine generals. Ocampo later became the first prosecutor of the
International Criminal Court. He'll join us later in the show.

_Argentina, 1985_ has been shortlisted for an Oscar and just won a
Golden Globe for Best Motion Picture in a Non-English Language. This
is a part of the film director Santiago Mitre’s acceptance speech at
the Golden Globes.

SANTIAGO MITRE: I want to share this with all the people who, since
the dictatorship, have been fighting to build a better democracy in
Argentina, and they keep on fighting. And, well, I think democracy is
something that we need to — well, we need to keep on fighting for.

AMY GOODMAN: Santiago Mitre, director of _Argentina, 1985_. The
film was also just awarded the NBR Freedom of Expression Award from
the National Board of Review. Other winners of the awards included the
famed director Steven Spielberg and the film _Top Gun: Maverick_. In
a moment, we’ll be joined by Santiago Mitre, but first let’s turn
to the trailer of _Argentina, 1985_.

RUSO: [played by Norman Briski] [translated] You will be the
prosecutor in the most important trial in Argentine history.

ABDUCTEE: [translated] I was abducted from my home. They kept me a
prisoner for months.

TEXT: Since the Nuremberg trials.

LUIS MORENO OCAMPO: [played by Peter Lanzani] [translated] The
responsibility of command lies with the juntas. We must prove they
knew about it.

TEXT: No country has dared to prosecute a dictatorship.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [played by Ricardo Darín] [translated]
This is our opportunity.

RUSO: [translated] Be careful, Julio. Be careful.

TEXT: Until Argentina, 1985.

JAVIER: [played by Santiago Armas Estevarena] [translated] You’re
sending Videla to jail?

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] All of those responsible.

UNIDENTIFIED: [translated] There is little time. You won’t pull
this alone.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] How many trials have you
worked?

LUIS MORENO OCAMPO: [translated] None.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] Ninety percent of the
judiciary staff does not want to get involved.

LUIS MORENO OCAMPO: [translated] Ninety-nine percent. I think we
need to look elsewhere.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] Where? Kids?

LUIS MORENO OCAMPO: [translated] Yes. If the seniors won’t do
it…

SOMI: [played by Claudio Da Passano] [translated] Then, we bring the
juniors in.

TEXT: Inspired by a true story.

LUIS MORENO OCAMPO: [translated] We need to prove it was a
systematic plan, that it was across the country, during the
governments of all the commanders. They disappeared people,
everywhere. They are responsible.

UNIDENTIFIED: [translated] This is about what the country needs.

TEXT: This fall.

SILVIA: [played by Alejandra Flechner] [translated] What are you
afraid of?

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] Everything! Of this being a
trap! Of something happening to any of you.

TEXT: True courage.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] They broke into our home, and
the trial is in an hour.

TEXT: Cannot be intimidated.

POLICE OFFICER: [translated] Police! Open the door!

MARÍA KUBIK: [played by Natalia Olabe] [translated] Your honor, all
I want to know is if my daughter is dead or alive.

JULIO CÉSAR STRASSERA: [translated] Slowly, so that we wouldn’t
notice, a machinery of horror unleashed its iniquity over the unaware
and the innocent.

History was not made by guys like me.

AMY GOODMAN: That’s the trailer for _Argentina, 1985_.

Well, on Thursday, _Democracy Now!_'s Nermeen Shaikh and I spoke to
the film's director, Santiago Mitre, just after he had won the Golden
Globe. I began by asking him what it means at an international level
for _Argentina, 1985_ to win that award on the way to the Oscars.

SANTIAGO MITRE: Well, it was an amazing and huge honor, of course.
The Golden Globe award and the honor of being shortlisted in the Oscar
amplifies the reach out of the film, which is an incredible thing, not
only because it means that many people across the globe are going to
watch it, but because these people, especially young generations, who
are the ones we are trying to reach the most, like the movie does
itself, will be able to have conversations about the impact of the
film, about its relevance, about the situation of democracy, and about
the fragility of democracy nowadays, which I think is one of the
things that we need to care about a lot.

NERMEEN SHAIKH: Santiago Mitre, you were, yourself, just a young boy
when this trial was taking place in 1985. Explain why you wanted to
make a film on it, how you decided to do that, and then how you went
about conducting the research. This was one of the most significant
events in Argentines’ political history, Argentina’s political
history.

SANTIAGO MITRE: Yeah, it’s a — I mean, I had a lot of
admiration of the trial — for the trial. It’s a major event,
because of the context it was done. It was done only one year after
the dictatorship ended, and the militaries were still very powerful
and very frightening. All the region was still governed by military
dictatorships. So the decision of the government to do this trial was
very brave and very important, and it formed the basis of the new
democracy. The prosecutors, the judges were brave on doing this,
because it’s something — it was something risky. They didn’t
know where it was going to end.

And among all the witnesses who survived to the concentration camps,
and the families that fight and tried to bring truth during the
dictatorship and tried to ask for where their relatives were, and sat
down and gave testimony, while most of the people who ran the
repressive system were still free — well, I think the trial had so
many layers and so many things worthy of being told nowadays to the
Argentinian audiences, who were starting to forget about this event,
and to the audiences around the world, who could be interested on the
subjects that the film was bringing — could bring justice,
democracy, is something that — one of the topics that I think we
need to be discussing the most nowadays, well, because of what’s
happening all over the world — the war in Ukraine, what just
happened one week before in Brazil with the attempted coup d’état
to Lula, well, the January 6 here, and so many places where too many
anti-democratic speeches are growing all over the world.

NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Santiago Mitre, for people who don’t know,
you know, the history of this period, the period of the successive
military juntas from 1976 to 1983, and what exactly happened during
the so-called Dirty War, could you just give us some background of
what was happening then?

SANTIAGO MITRE: Yeah, well, it was part of the late Cold War,
let’s say. Argentina had 100 years of a history of alternation
between one democratic government, who would not be ended, to a
military government. This military government was the most terrible
one that happened in history, because it shot, killed and disappeared
as a system to all the citizens who were against them politically, or
being suspected of being against them. They disappeared over 3,000
people during those years and killed some more. Well, it was an awful
dictatorship and awful moment to live in that country and very
frightening.

AMY GOODMAN: Santiago, you have said, “I’m convinced of
fiction’s capacity to transmit reality.” You decided to make this
not a documentary, though you did use verbatim the testimony of the
victims, the heartrending, utterly painful testimony of the victims at
the trial. But you — for example, Ricardo Darín, one of the most
famous Argentine actors, plays Julio Strassera, becomes him, in a
sense, even though they don’t actually look alike. Talk about that
choice to make this dramatic feature film.

SANTIAGO MITRE: I believe that fiction is probably the best vehicle
to tell the truth. And I did a very long research. For many years, I
tried to spoke to most of the people who did the trial or who
participated in the trial, journalists who were covering the trial for
newspapers, witnesses, families of witnesses, all the prosecutorial
team, Luis Moreno Ocampo himself, the judges, people from the
government. I read everything.

The testimonies could not — I don’t know why. I think it was — I
think that I have my ethics as a filmmaker. I couldn’t change a word
from what was said during the hearings. The importance that this film
transmitted so much truth, I think it was one of my goals. So,
luckily, we were able to shoot in the real courtroom where the trial
happened. For so many years, we were not — when we wanted to watch
images of the Trial of the Juntas, we were not being able to watch the
faces of the people who were giving testimony. And, for me, the
possibility of recreating this gave me that, like, OK, we can see the
faces, and we can try to imagine the pain, the anger, what they were
feeling at the moment they were giving testimony.

NERMEEN SHAIKH: Santiago, at the time, do you remember, what was —
or, from what you’ve heard, obviously — as you said, you were a
child when the trials actually occurred. And your mother was involved
in justice, so, obviously, you were more familiar with it than most.
What was the impact that this trial had, the trial which was publicly
accessible? And, of course, there was a large public that saw the —
that was there, present at the trial. What was the impact on society
at large, people who knew very little of what had been happening? What
was the response?

SANTIAGO MITRE: Yeah, it’s very interesting, because everybody —
the president, Alfonsín, won because he said he wanted to do the
trial. And he promised something, and then he did it, which was
something that not many politicians do. But at the same time, society
were afraid of the trial, in a way. They wanted a trial, but they were
afraid. They were afraid that a coup d’état could happen. So it was
like a tense situation.

It was a big box of amplification, this trial, that made the people
conscious of what they had done and about how important it was that we
all, as a society, fight for the democracy. Actually, some months
after the trial ended, some rebellions in military _cuarteles_ — I
don’t know the word in English, like forts or military places
— all of the country started, and the people massively went out to
the streets to protect this democracy.

AMY GOODMAN: Tell us, Santiago, about the extras in this film. I
mean, you used the verbatim testimony, but, of course, actors and
actresses, of the victims. In one of your showings here in New York,
you talked in the Q&A about the woman who was forced to give birth
alone. Tell us her story and the reaction of the extras behind.

SANTIAGO MITRE: Yeah, it’s one of the probably more — the
testimonies that has more pain in it. It’s terrible. It was a
physician, who was called Adriana Calvo de Laborde, who was forced to
give birth handcuffed — handcuffs, _se dice_ [inaudible]
— handcuffed in the back of a police car. And they didn’t let her
grab his daughter who was just born. Well, and we were doing that
testimony, that, for me, it was one of the main testimonies during
that sequence. And I worked a lot with the actress to get the right
tone, similar to the real Adriana but with her own deepness. And we
cut her hair. Her clothes were exactly the same, because we were
mixing this footage with — our footage with the original footage
from the trial. And we did scene like — we were all crying because
of being there listening to that testimony in the same courtroom, it
was like super powerful. And in the first takes, we were — since the
first takes, we were all crying. It was impossible not to cry. But
then, cinema, it’s difficult, and sometimes directors will get too
obsessed with silly stuff, and we were repeating the scene many times
and with different angles.

There was one person in the audience that was crying since the first
shot and kept on crying after the midday, and we keep shooting, and he
was keep on crying. And we didn’t understand what was going on with
this man. So, at some point we did a pause, and the actress went out
the set, and this man approached her and told her he used to study
with the real Adriana Calvo de Laborde in the university, and he
thanked her for letting him watch her or see his friend again. Of
course, the actress started to cry again, like massively. And she told
me, and I was, “Oh, [bleep], this film is going to be very
intense.” And I was crying again, too. And during the film, we have,
like, many situations like that, because it’s very difficult that
someone in my country does not have a relation to someone or who
suffered one of these horrors that this dictatorship did to the
country.

AMY GOODMAN: Santiago, there’s a moment in the film, in the
courtroom, where the prosecutors go up to the Mothers of the
Disappeared, who were there with their famous white kerchiefs, and
they had been told by the judge, by the defense team for the generals,
that these women must take off their kerchiefs because they’re seen
as banners, everyone knows what they mean. Very touching moment. Can
you talk about the role of the grassroots movements, these women who
marched in the Plaza de Mayo week after week to dramatize the stories
of the disappeared, their children, their grandchildren, and the Truth
Commission of Argentina?

SANTIAGO MITRE: Yes, Madres de Plaza de Mayo were one of the main
institutions and one of the true heroes of the fighting for democracy
during the dictatorship. They risked theirselves fighting and asking
for where their children were. Also the families of the kidnapped
were.

But the mothers and the _abuelas_, the grandmothers, they keep doing
an enormous social work in terms of memory, but with a huge impact in
the present. Just 10 days ago, they could rescue one boy who was
kidnapped during the dictatorship. And they find his identity, and he
could recover his identity and understand who his father were. But,
man, it’s their 150 case, or something like that. I don’t remember
the exact number. And there’s many more, many, many, many babies
that were born during the kidnaps. And they were — during the
kidnaps of their father, and then they were kidnapped by fake
families, and related to the military sometimes, or even militaries.
And it’s a fight that the _abuelas_ keep on doing massively. So,
we are — I mean, I love them so much, and I think they’re such an
important emblem for our country.

NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Santiago Mitre, finally, what do you hope
audiences around the world will learn from this film?

SANTIAGO MITRE: That you never have to take democracy for granted,
and justice is the best way to consolidate democracy. And then, we
all, as citizens, need to get involved. Get involved, it’s not
necessarily to fight, but at least to discuss and to see that
there’s a problem growing all over the world. I mean, for me, that I
do political films, one of the best things that can happen with a
film, I think it’s like that people, after watching the film, they
don’t discuss only the film, that they try to watch — and they
try to watch and try to think about the problems on their own
societies.

AMY GOODMAN: Santiago Mitre, director of the new film _Argentina,
1985_, streaming on Amazon Prime. It’s been shortlisted for an
Oscar, just won a Golden Globe for Best Motion Picture in a
Non-English Language. The film is based in part on Luis Moreno Ocampo,
who prosecuted the Argentine generals. He’ll join us in a moment.

Related story: 

Legendary Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo on “Argentina, 1985” and
Why Democracy Is at Risk Today
[[link removed]]

DEMOCRACY NOW! IS A 501(C)3 NON-PROFIT NEWS ORGANIZATION. WE DO NOT
ACCEPT FUNDING FROM ADVERTISING, UNDERWRITING OR GOVERNMENT AGENCIES.
WE RELY ON CONTRIBUTIONS FROM OUR VIEWERS AND LISTENERS TO DO OUR
WORK. PLEASE DO YOUR PART TODAY.  DONATE
[[link removed]]

 

* Film
[[link removed]]
* Argentina - 1985
[[link removed]]
* Golden Globe Winner
[[link removed]]
* Argentina
[[link removed]]
* Santiago Mitre
[[link removed]]
* Julio Strassera and Luis Moreno Ocampo
[[link removed]]
* Trial of the Juntas
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]

Manage subscription
[[link removed]]

Visit portside.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 



########################################################################

[link removed]

To unsubscribe from the xxxxxx list, click the following link:
[link removed]