Changes coming to Supreme Courts in Alaska and Maine
Every state—and the District of Columbia—has at least one supreme court that issues final and binding rulings about cases involving state law. Oklahoma and Texas both have two such courts—one for civil appeals and one for criminal appeals. All told, there are 344 state supreme court judges nationwide. Here’s a quick rundown of two upcoming state Supreme Court changes in Alaska and Maine.
Alaska
Alaska Supreme Court Justice Craig Stowers announced Jan. 7 he would retire from the bench effective June 1, 2020. Gov. Sean Parnell (R) appointed Justice Stowers to the court in 2009, and voters retained him for a 10-year term in 2014. He served as chief justice of the court from June 2015 to July 2018. Stowers’ replacement will be Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s (R) first nominee to the five-member Supreme court.
Selection of state Supreme Court justices in Alaska occurs through assisted appointment. The Alaska Judicial Council forwards a list of nominees to the governor, who must then choose a name from the list within 45 days to fill any vacancy. Justices serve 10-year terms, but newly appointed justices are subject to a retention election at the state’s first general election that is more than three years after their appointment. After that, each justice is subject to a retention election every 10 years.
The Alaska Supreme Court is the court of last resort in Alaska. Four of the court’s current justices were appointed by Republican governors, and one—Justice Susan Carney—was appointed by independent Gov. Bill Walker. Carney faces a retention election in November 2020.
Maine
The Maine Supreme Judicial Court gained two new members after Governor Janet Mills (D) appointed appellate attorney Catherine Connors and Maine Superior Court Justice Andrew Horton to the court. Connors and Horton were Mills’ first and second nominees to the seven-member court. Pending confirmation from the state Senate, they will succeed Justices Jeffrey Hjelm and Donald Alexander. Former Maine Gov. Paul LePage (R) appointed Hjelm, while former Gov. Angus King (I) appointed Alexander.
Connors is an appellate lawyer with Pierce Atwood, where she handles civil and criminal litigation matters in federal and state courts.
Horton is a superior court justice for the Cumberland County Superior Court in Maine. Gov. John Baldacci (D) first appointed him to this court in January 2007. Horton was a judge on the Maine District Courts from 1999 to 2007.
In Maine, governors appoint justices, who must they be approved by the Senate. Whether newly appointed or reappointed, judges serve seven-year terms. Appointed judges must be reappointed if they wish to serve additional terms. If Mills' nominees are approved, the court will have five Democrat-appointed members and two Republican-appointed members.
In 2020, there have been four supreme court vacancies in four of the 29 states where replacement justices are appointed instead of elected. All four vacancies were caused by retirements. In 2019, there were 22 supreme court vacancies across 14 states. Fourteen of those vacancies resulted from retirements.
|