Hello from 2020!
A proposed bill that allows the sale of used cars with unfixed but disclosed recalls lands on a legislator’s desk in Tennessee.
For reporters, and Tennessee residents, such a bill probably warrants a look. But with fewer journalists covering statehouses across the country, the odds that it gets the scrutiny it deserves are low.
But what if a similar bill with nearly the exact same language concurrently lands on legislators’ desks in California, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania and Virginia?
The knowledge that the bill likely wasn’t written by a local politician, and instead came from someone with pockets deep enough to extend to 11 states, elevates the story to something more important. Who is pushing this and why?
A model legislation tracking tool called “Copy, Paste, Legislate” from the Center for Public Integrity seeks to make it easy to locate widespread lobbying efforts across the United States so that journalists and citizens can solve the latter for themselves.
The tool regularly pulls in new legislation from across the country and parses the text for similar language, making it easy to identify model legislation fast enough when it’s still being debated, said Pratheek Rebala, news developer at CPI, in an interview with Poynter. Once the tool determines that a bill is model legislation, reporters can dig in to find the bill’s source with shoe-leather reporting.
In the case of the recalled cars, CPI (along with USA Today and the Arizona Republic) leveraged the tool to discover that the bills were written by Automotive Trade Association Executives, a group that represents regional auto dealer associations. With deeper reporting, they found that the group was pushing a “cynical ploy” to require a bare minimum of responsibility from dealers of recalled cars while purposefully leaving out a requirement to fix them.
“This tool is not a silver bullet and not going to do the work for you,” Rebala said. “But it can enrich traditional reporting.”
|