Read about removing colonial legacies in statue form. Received this from a friend? SUBSCRIBE [[link removed]] CRITICAL STATE Your weekly foreign policy fix. If you read just one thing …

… read about removing colonial legacies in statue form.

For 57 years, a statue of Curt von François stood outside the municipal offices of Windhoek, Namibia’s capital. François, a German colonial officer, was credited with the founding of Windhoek in 1890, though Jonker Afrikaner of the Nama people first built a settlement in the same area in 1840. The erection of the François statue in 1965, 34 years after his death, is about a second colonial legacy, that of apartheid colonialism in the country. The statue was removed in October 2022, after two years of protest and action. In June 2020, protestors carried signs, some of which explicitly connected von François to the 1893 massacre of the Nama people he led. Writes [[link removed]] Heike Becker, “When protesters climbed right on top of the von François memorial in June 2020, this was the first time that young Namibians of varied ethnic backgrounds came out in a public demonstration for the eradication of colonial symbols in the public space.” This was a marked break from other projects of decolonizing public space, which were driven by the government first, and focused on populating public space with new monuments. By casting off the bronze-cast monuments to past colonizers, the Namibian street had built a protest movement capable of winning its own victories and writing its own history into physical space.

POWER FLOWS

Kenya is, in many ways, already a success story for renewable energy, with 92% of the country’s electricity derived that way and fully renewable generation pledged by 2030. But, writes April Zhu [[link removed]], that monumental progress echoes colonial practices, with foreign funders and state power displacing Indigenous people from sites marked for green development.

The power produced by the Lake Turkana wind farm “is sold to the national power distributor Kenya Power and Lighting Company, while the people who live near the turbines are not even connected to the national grid,” writes Zhu.

Renewable power generation is an achievement, but it is one whose benefits are extended unevenly, where displaced Indigenous groups are left out.

FORWARD TO A FRIEND [[link removed]] Profane Intrusions

The United Kingdom, under over a decade of Tory rule, has adopted a series of policies of explicit hostility to migrants and refugees. This week, The Independent reports [[link removed]] a series of intrusions by the Home Office into temples, mosques, gurdwaras, and churches, all designed to drive undocumented migrants and failed asylum seekers out of the country.

“In at least three instances last year, officials carried out immigration enforcement visits at places of worship that resulted in taking people directly to an airport,” writes Nicola Kelly.

The actions came to light as part of a Freedom of Information Act request and highlight the length and durability of policies meant to target vulnerable people when they were seeking comfort and sanctuary.

FORWARD TO A FRIEND [[link removed]] DEEP DIVE State Reformation: Part I

“The Irish Unification of 2024” is a one-off reference from a 1990 episode of Star Trek. But eight years before the Good Friday Accords, the episode’s acknowledgment of terrorism as a path to such a political settlement prevented it from being aired on the BBC for 17 years. In late 2022, the question is: What might happen should Ireland and Northern Ireland fall under one government again? This issue is now less science fiction and more plausible policy.

In “ Irish Unity: Lessons from Germany? [[link removed]],” Tobias Lock examines the textbook example of national unification in the modern era.

Following World War II, Germany’s Nazi government was driven from power, and the country was divided by the occupying forces of France, the United Kingdom, the United States, and the Soviet Union. This division followed in miniature in Berlin, which was otherwise surrounded by the Soviet Zone. The Soviet Zone became the German Democratic Republic, or East Germany, while the three other areas became the Federal Republic of Germany or West Germany. This division lasted from 1945 until 1990 when a series of changes began in 1989 and led the last government elected in East Germany to vote for accession to West Germany. The two countries have been one ever since, though many divisions from nearly half a century apart still run deep.

“The German and Irish contexts differ, however, as far as the subjects of unification are concerned: whereas the GDR was a sovereign state and ceased to exist as such on 3 October 1990, Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom, which would continue to exist as a state after Irish unification,” writes Lock. “In other words, whereas German unification consisted in the absorption of one state in another, Irish unification would technically be a transfer of sovereignty over territory by one state to another.”

What unification would share is a continued international place for Ireland, which would maintain its relations as it absorbed transferred territory. If such a transfer should occur, Northern Ireland would once again be a party to the European Union, which the United Kingdom left under the policy of Brexit.

One major structural difference is that, whereas East Germany’s parliament was able to unilaterally vote for accession, the existing “Good Friday/Belfast Agreement stipulates that Irish unification requires ‘consent, freely and concurrently given, North and South,’ i.e. two concurrent expressions of consent,” writes Lock.

In structuring such expressions of consent, negotiators could strive to accommodate the hard-won — and already-negotiated — terms of the agreement. One way such a unification could improve upon German reunification would be ensuring that the burdens of constitutional change are not shifted entirely onto the ascending territory.

“Constitutional reform confirmed by a subsequent referendum would have given Germans East and West a greater degree of agency over reunification, which by and large was an event that was happening to them rather than one they were actively able to shape; and it might have demanded that West Germans adapt to at least some changes to their status quo, which — in stark contrast to their East German compatriots — they did not have to grapple with,” writes Lock.

LEARN MORE [[link removed]]

FORWARD TO A FRIEND [[link removed]] SHOW US THE RECEIPTS

Durrie Bouscaren visited [[link removed]] with Russian refugees in Almaty, Kazakhstan. In a shelter set up by the Anti-War Committee of Russia, men who fled the war and the draft took advantage of a Kazakhstan policy allowing Russian citizens to enter the country with just a national ID for a stay of 90 days. “I didn’t want to kill anyone. I didn’t want to support Putin. The choice is to shoot yourself, move to another country or go to jail,” Vyacheslav, an activist from Moscow, told Bouscaren. For now, the refugees are waiting to see if Kazakhstan or another country will permanently accept them.

Jonathan Ellis Allen and Jordan Cohen implored [[link removed]] the United States to stop selling weapons to Saudi Arabia in hopes of pressuring the Kingdom to stop its war in Yemen. “The more [weapons] Washington sends, the more innocent civilians Saudi Arabia can kill. This creates a vicious cycle in which Washington becomes increasingly entangled in these human rights abuses, attempting to solve the problems created by weapons sales to the Saudis with more weapons sales to the Saudis,” they write. Cutting off arms sales would reduce harm; increased aid provided would provide real relief.

Halima Gikandi reported [[link removed]] on a ceasefire between Ethiopia’s federal government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front. The two factions had fought a civil war in the country, conducted largely in the Tigray region and nearby provinces. "We have treated children, and a number of innocent civilians in the hospital after drone attacks, after artillery shellings," a health worker in the Tigrayan capital of Mekelle told Gikandi. Should the ceasefire hold, it will allow more aid and humanitarian supplies to flow into the region, letting people begin the long work of healing from war.

FORWARD TO A FRIEND [[link removed]] WELL PLAYED

Nothing beside remains round the decay of once-shared memory [[link removed]].

I’m calling this meme a Bayeaux travesty [[link removed]].

Che Guevara, last known diary entry [[link removed]].

When you call out an electoral system for putting fascists in charge, that’s body politic shaming [[link removed]].

You’ve encountered a structural problem [[link removed]]. Have you considered accessing what means you have for building power to overcome it [[link removed]]?

Francis Fukuyama goes to the theater [[link removed]].

The macros above the newsfeed [[link removed]] were tuned to the color of a dying platform [[link removed]].

FORWARD TO A FRIEND [[link removed]] Follow The World: DONATE TO THE WORLD [[link removed]] Follow Inkstick: DONATE TO INKSTICK [[link removed]]

Critical State is written by Kelsey D. Atherton with Inkstick Media.

The World is a weekday public radio show and podcast on global issues, news and insights from PRX and GBH.

With an online magazine and podcast featuring a diversity of expert voices, Inkstick Media is “foreign policy for the rest of us.”

Critical State is made possible in part by the Carnegie Corporation of New York.

Preferences [link removed] | Web Version [link removed] Unsubscribe [link removed]