A few days ago, the Broadcasting Minister Willie
Jackson came before the EDSI Committee to outline his reasoning
for the Aotearoa New Zealand Public Media Bill. In short, what he did
instead was criticize TVNZ for not being on board with his bizarre
plans to spend $370million. The committee received more than 900
submissions on the Minister’s plans with many expressing serious
concerns over his proposals. Many are concerned at the impact the new
Public Media Entity monolith may have on the future of commercial
media in our country.
Recently, I’ve been putting concerns to the Minister himself in the
House.
I suggest you watch for yourself. His answers are a joke and it’s
clear he’s dropping the ball for the future of our media
landscape.
Question
Time 27 September 2022
Question
Time 28 September 2022
Question
Time 29 September 2022
Some have expressed dismay at the thought of hundreds of millions
being spent to establish this new Entity and then to keep it afloat
for the years ahead without value to the taxpayer. This massive cost
could instead clear the cancer patient waiting list funding
desperately needed medications with more left over to tackle the worst
surgical wait list in the past decade affecting tens of thousands of
New Zealanders in need.
Others still are concerned at the potential loss of independence
for the new Entity, being established as an Autonomous Crown Entity
that must have regard to the policies of the Government of the day, as
opposed to the limitations set on RNZ and TVNZ at present. In the
words of Dr Gavin Ellis and Sir Peter Gluckman, the merger legislation
“is
so incomplete and raises so many issues that it would be unsafe to
enact it in its present form”. It is vital the Minister
understands these plans are simply not fit for purpose and he needs to
go back to the drawing board. RNZ and TVNZ, are cherished institutions
for many New Zealanders. They both have some faults that need to be
addressed but the solution is not throwing good money after bad while
debt borrowing levels continue to rise in our country.
The future of New Zealand’s media landscape is being put at severe
risk by the Minister’s plans because they will reduce plurality in the
market. New Zealand on Air have confirmed they’ll be handing
over a lion’s share of their funding to the new Entity leaving a
much lesser amount of funding available for programme makers to vie
for.
New Zealand needs to have a serious conversation about the future
of our media landscape. We need to have a frank, open and honest
conversation about what, if any, public media platforms we should have
in New Zealand. We need to discuss how much the state should be
involved in content funding and decision-making and above all, we need
to have this conversation openly with full public transparency rather
than millions spent on businesses cases, Ministerial working groups,
and secretive reviews. Whether intended or not the Public
Interest Journalism Fund has been an unmitigated disaster for
perception of media trust in New Zealand and the implications of a
giant publicly owned media entity that could end up succeeding it’s
mandate will only further diminish that trust. With the new Entity we
have next to no details as to what the entity is, how it will operate,
who will run it and what the real costs will be long term.
Bluntly, New Zealanders cannot be expected to support the new
Entity on a ‘wing and a prayer’. We need to see real reasons and real
facts to decide. We don’t need high level talking points and wishful
thinking when media sector jobs in New Zealand and trust in the fourth
estate are on the line, let alone $370million and counting in wasteful
spending.
It’s time the Government took a step back and pauses their plans
for the future of the New Zealand media.
Who’s with me?