Death for "Blasphemers" in Pakistan
by Raymond Ibrahim • July 17, 2022 at 5:00 am
"Muhammad Irfan came to my shop for wheel balancing for his motorbike. I balanced the wheel and demanded my amount of labour as settled between us. Muhammad Irfan refused to give me money and said, 'I am a follower of Peer Fakhir [a Muslim ascetic] and don't ask for money from me.'" — Ashfaq Masih, Christian falsely accused of "blasphemy" and sentenced to death by hanging, chuchinchains.ie, July 7, 2022.
"They both made conspiracy against me and lodged a false FIR [First Incident Report] against me. I told the real story to a police officer but he did not record my version but conducted investigation ex-parte. I neither uttered any derogatory word against Prophet Muhammad nor can think about it." -- Ashfaq Masih, chuchinchains.ie, July 7, 2022.
The Muslim judge, Khalid Wazir, presiding over the case, went so far as to state that "it could not be believed that a Muslim will spin a story in this regard," while simultaneously describing the evidence presented by Masih's defense team as "not believable. "
"I don't remember any case where the lower court decided to grant bail or freed anyone accused of the blasphemy law. The judges are aware that such cases are made to punish and settle personal grudges with the opponents, especially against the Christians.... Masih's case was very clear—the shop owner wanted him out and Naveed was a business rival who implicated him in a false blasphemy case. He is innocent and has already spent five years in prison for a crime he never committed." — Nasir Saeed, Director of the Centre for Legal Aid Assistance and Settlement, claas.org.uk, July 7, 2002.
Masih's case is now at least the third death sentencing of its kind since the start of this year.
In February 2022, Zafar Bhatti, 58 — another Christian man who had been serving a life sentence under a false accusation of blaspheming Muhammad in a text — was given a death sentence.
In January 2022, Aneeqa Atteeq, a Muslim woman, was sentenced to death after a Pakistani court pronounced her guilty of insulting Muhammad in text messages she had sent to a man via WhatsApp. She had offered a more plausible if not prosaic explanation: the man who reported her was getting "revenge" on her because she had refused his advances.
Horrific as it is to be accused of blasphemy in a Pakistani courtroom, it is even far worse to fall into the hands of a Pakistani mob. A decade-old report found that in Pakistan, between just 1990 and 2012 alone, "fifty-two people have been extra-judicially murdered on charges of blasphemy."
"Anyone Who Touches the Prophet, No Punishment—Just Kill!" — Yello Babo, Muslim cleric in Nigeria, Persecution.org, May 16, 2022.
On July 4, 2022, a Christian mechanic who had been imprisoned for the last five years, awaiting trial under a false accusation of "blasphemy" for allegedly insulting the Muslim prophet Muhammad, was sentenced to death by hanging in a Pakistani court.
Five years earlier, on June 5, 2017, Ashfaq Masih, 34, had gotten into a quarrel with Muhammad Naveen, a rival who had established a mechanics' workshop near Masih's. According to Masih's not guilty plea, Muhammad "was jealous because my business was running better," and, after their altercation, "threatened me with dire consequences." On the following day, June 6, according to Masih: