From landmark legislation on guns to harrowing testimony at the Jan. 6 hearing to an historic ruling on abortion, it’s been an especially newsworthy 48-hour period, to say the least. Topline readers’ opinions on these issues may vary, but in each case, the value of democracy has been thrown into stark relief. First, our voices matter. With Roe v. Wade no longer the law of the land, states will once again determine the particulars as to the legality of abortion. As President Biden remarked today, the issue will literally be on the ballot in November. Vote. Second, when done right, democracy accomplishes positive things. Bipartisan work on gun safety legislation is proof that it’s still possible to shun extremism and build consensus around issues that matter deeply to Americans. Kudos. Third, it all depends on whether honorable people are leading the way. As the Jan. 6 committee reveals more about the plot to overturn the 2020 presidential election results, it’s clear that the best defense of democracy is people who put principle above party. Always. —Melissa Amour, Managing Editor
Roe v. Wade is no moreThe Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade this morning, eliminating the federal constitutional right to an abortion that has stood for nearly 50 years. As one of the most politically divisive issues in America, the decision immediately sparked protests and celebrations across the country. The vote was 5-3-1, with Justices Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan, and Sonia Sotomayor dissenting “with sorrow.” Chief Justice John Roberts did not join the majority, writing in a concurring opinion that he would not have overturned Roe but would have only upheld Mississippi's law banning abortions after 15 weeks. Going forward, abortion rights will be determined by the states, unless Congress takes federal action. —CNN
MORE: Read the Supreme Court opinion overturning Roe v. Wade —Politico A criminal conspiracy comes to lightThe Jan. 6 committee hearings are confirming what most of us already knew: Donald Trump and his inner circle conspired to overturn the 2020 election; a handful of people stopped the conspiracy from going forward; and a few key figures could have stopped the mob from storming the Capitol—but did nothing. What’s shocking is the amount of evidence the panel has gathered, the number of people involved, and the sheer brazenness of the attempt. Top officials’ testimonies and private emails and texts reveal they were actively aware of the crimes they were engaged in and closer than we feared to success. Ultimately, these hearings could be a catalyst for criminal accountability. —Democracy Brief
MORE: Nearly 6 in 10 Americans want Trump charged for insurrection —HuffPost Hayden, Clapper, McChrystal, Lute & Hertling: Join us in defending democracy“Written by Americans who are deeply committed to the health of our democracy, [the Safe and Fair Elections Pledge by Team Democracy] asks all Americans to come together on an important piece of common ground—a safe place where regardless of political persuasion, we can agree to embrace the most fundamental cornerstones of our democracy by committing ourselves to elections that are both secure and accessible; and assuring the peaceful transition of power according to the rule of law.” —Gen. Michael Hayden, Lt. Gen. James Clapper, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, Lt. Gen. Douglas Lute & Lt. Gen Mark Hertling in USA Today Gen. Michael Hayden (U.S. Air Force, ret.) is chair of Team Democracy, the former director of the CIA and NSA, and the former principal deputy director of National Intelligence. Lt. Gen. James Clapper (U.S. Air Force, ret.) served as director of National Intelligence and the Defense Intelligence Agency. Gen. Stanley McChrystal (U.S. Army, ret.) served as commander of Joint Special Operations Command. Lt. Gen. Douglas Lute (U.S. Army, ret.) served as the U.S. ambassador to NATO and deputy national security adviser. Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling, (U.S. Army, ret.) served as the commanding general of the U.S. Army Europe and the Seventh Army. MORE: Texas GOP's new platform says Biden didn't really win the 2020 election —NPR Gun legislation passes CongressAfter 30 years of relative inaction on gun safety, Congress has passed the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act. The legislation enhances background checks for potential gun buyers under the age of 21, provides funding for states to implement red flag laws, strengthens laws against straw purchasing and trafficking of guns, shores up mental health programs, toughens school security, and tightens a federal ban on domestic abusers buying firearms. A deal on the compromise bill was struck in the Senate earlier in the week by Sens. Chris Murphy, Kyrsten Sinema, John Cornyn, and Thom Tillis. Fifteen Republicans then voted to end a filibuster and allow the legislation to pass the upper chamber. In the House, 14 Republicans joined all Democrats to pass the bill. The measure now heads to President Biden, who is expected to sign it. —The New York Times MORE: Supreme Court allows the carrying of firearms in public in major victory for gun-rights groups —NBC News Bump: Democracy requires honor“Protection of the American election system depends on having a hierarchy of individual actors willing to defend that system. Trump tried hard—cajoling, threatening, condemning—to get enough individuals in enough places to weaken the system so that he could retain power. He failed, but he’s been pointed in his endorsements this year that candidates who pledge to put party (or, ideally, Trump) first are the people he thinks should serve in office.” —Philip Bump in The Washington Post Philip Bump is a correspondent at The Washington Post. MORE: Center-right pushes back against election deniers —The Fulcrum Schmidt: There is hope amid the partisan doom loop“Over the last decade there has been a broad, national trend toward an increasing share of political independents. The percentage of Americans who no longer identify with either political party is rising.” —Lynn Schmidt in St. Louis Post-Dispatch Lynn Schmidt is a Renew America Movement Fellow. MORE: Will Hurd: The crucial role of political centrists —Common Ground Committee What a bizarre state of hypocrisy. SCOTUS says on one hand states cannot decide their own gun laws, but they can decide their own abortion laws. Judicial confusion and hypocrisy can only mean one thing: SCOTUS decisions based on political ideology and theology, not on the law nor the Constitution. A prediction of what comes next… 1. A slew of 1st, 4th, and 13th Amendment lawsuits challenging state laws restricting abortion from the moment of conception. 2. An exodus of educated and wealthy people from red states, where abortion laws are the most restrictive. 3. A resultant increase in infant and expectant mother mortality rates in red states with the most restrictive abortion laws. The opposite of pro-life. 4. Large corporate employers will exit red states with the most restrictive abortion laws. 5. Economic downturns in red states with the most restrictive abortion laws. 6. Resultant increased reliance on federal support, welfare, and Medicaid in economically suffering red states. 7. An ultimate blue wave in now-red states as the poor and youth in those states begin to see the error of their elders' ways. 8. A push to expand the court to 13 members and add DC and Puerto Rico to the list of official states, with two senators each. Nothing stays the same. —Ken G., Colorado The views expressed in "What's Your Take?" are submitted by readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial staff, the Renew America Movement, or the Renew America Foundation. Did you like this post from The Topline? Why not share it? Got feedback about The Topline? Send it to Melissa Amour, Managing Editor, at [email protected]. |