Dear Friend, Yesterday the U.S. Supreme Court
issued a big win for parents! While it’s not the long-awaited abortion
decision in the Dobbs case which we are anticipating this week, it is
a big win for parents, for school choice, and for religious
freedom!
The State of Maine offers a tuition assistance program
to parents who live in a remote part of the state in school districts
that are too small to have a high school. Under that program, parents
designate the high school they would like their child to attend, and
the school district transmits payments to that school to help defray
the costs of tuition. Maine has limited tuition assistance payments to
“nonsectarian” schools. Parents who sought tuition assistance to send
their children to two different Christian schools sued the State of
Maine because the ban on religious schools violated the Free Exercise
clause and the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The lower
courts ruled against the parents.
Yesterday, the U.S.
Supreme Court reversed the lower courts and agreed with
parents.
The Court ruled that disqualifying certain
private schools from public funding “solely because they are
religious” is indeed a violation of the First Amendment. The Court
ruled:
“Maine’s ‘nonsectarian’
requirement for its otherwise generally available tuition assistance
payments violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.
Regardless of how the benefit and restriction are described, the
program operates to identify and exclude otherwise eligible schools on
the basis of their religious exercise.”
Our sister organization, the Institute for Faith &
Freedom filed an Amicus Brief in the Carson v.
Makin case last September, because we
understood that a ruling for religious freedom and school choice in
the Maine case would have an impact on North Carolina’s school choice
programs. In the brief we argued:
“Individuals are free
to believe religious doctrine, but increasingly coerced not to act on
those beliefs in public life. ‘Even today . . . people of faith are
made to choose between receiving the protection of the State and
living lives true to their religious convictions.’ Such censorship
cuts against the Constitution’s guarantee of the right ‘not just . . .
to be a religious person, holding beliefs inwardly and secretly’ but
‘the right to act on those beliefs outwardly and publicly.’”
North Carolina is embroiled in yet a third lawsuit filed by
anti-school-choice and LGBT groups challenging our Opportunity
Scholarship program. This time, the issue their lawsuit focuses on is
the fact that Opportunity Scholarships, which are funded by taxpayer
dollars, are given to parents, some of whom choose to use the
scholarship dollars at private religious schools that follow Christian
principles about sex, gender, and marriage.
This is but one
way that we constantly represent you before government bodies every
day. By filing Amicus Briefs on issues affecting North Carolina, we
represent you before the U.S. Supreme Court. Last year we filed ten
Amicus Briefs, and we’ve already filed three this year. All of this
has been made possible by your support of efforts like ours to amplify
the coalition's voice across the branches and boundaries of your
government.
Friend, if you haven’t given
yet this quarter to the work of the NC Values Coalition, I urge you to make your
donation today. If you’ve given already this year,
we hope you would consider also making
a donation to IFFNC in gratitude for their hard
work making us 'friends of the court' by writing, filing, and filing
dozens of amicus
briefs.
Gratefully,Tami
Fitzgerald North Carolina Values Coalition
|