Dear Supporter,
Labour's conference announcements costly for taxpayers
The theme of the weekend's Labour Party conference: borrow and
spend.
Finance Minister Grant Robertson has abandoned his party's
pre-election "Budget Responsibility Rules" and signaled
he is ready to borrow billions more for infrastructure
projects.
Let's be clear: there is nothing wrong with spending money on
infrastructure.
However, this doesn't need to be funded by borrowing. A
responsible Finance Minister would identify and cut wasteful spending
before lumping future taxpayers with debt.
And secondly, any infrastructure spending should be targeted toward
areas of greatest need.
Money sprayed at schools regardless of need
The keynote spending announcement from the weekend was $396
million divided up between almost every school in the country.
Taxpayers employ 1,785 officials at the Ministry of
Education. We pay these officials to work out things like how to
target education spending.
Yet for the latest spend-up, the Government didn't bother asking
these officials which schools actually need it. The Prime Minister
just divvied the funds up so she could announce "money for all
schools".
This means gleaming new schools will receive new funds at the
expense of schools that are falling apart.
This is not how taxpayer money should be spent. This is
lazy, wasteful, and frankly embarrassing for a party with all the
resources of government.
Next Wednesday, I will be attending the Government's half-year
fiscal update, where the Grant Robertson is expected to make further
spending announcements. We can't say we're optimistic about their
value.
Yet another tax hike
The days of the Government's promises of 'no new taxes' are long
gone, with Eugenie Sage announcing plans
to lift landfill levies from the current $10 per tonne to $60 per
tonne by 2023. If it brings in the forecast $220 million,
that’s a tax hike of $120 per Kiwi household, per year. And that's on
average – a disproportionate cost will fall on large households in the
country’s poorest suburbs. Earlier this year, the Tax Working
Group pointed out that increasing the rubbish tax would
cause a spike in illegal dumping. Even the Green Party should agree
that it’s better for old mattresses to end up in the tip than dumped
on the road or riverside.
Skin care company, Southland manufacturers
disgracefully accept corporate welfare
Last week was busy on the corporate welfare front, with Shane Jones
announcing taxpayer handouts for a
Manawatu skin care company, plus a number of Southland
engineering businesses.
'The Herb Farm' is
supposedly ‘a globally successful skin-care brand’ with growing
demand. So why does it need $261,000 from taxpayers? It
appears to be accepting unnecessary corporate welfare just because
Shane Jones has offered it. This is disgraceful.
The same goes
for the likes of boat manufacturer Stabicraft, which received
$225,000. This isn't just wasteful, it's unfair to these companies'
competitors, who operate without special favours.
A secretive start for new Christchurch City
Council CEO
New Christchurch City Council CEO Dawn Baxendale received a
$30,000 allowance for her relocation from the United Kingdom – but she
refuses to disclose how the money was
spent. Just a couple of weeks ago, the Council was slammed
by the Chief Ombudsman for manipulating reports and obscuring bad news
from the public. This is clearly an organisation in desperate need of
transparency from the top down, but Ms Baxendale has failed at one of
her first tests.
Ratepayers are funding Baxendale's salary of nearly half a million
dollars per year. It’s not unreasonable to ask whether the extra
$30,000 for relocating was actually used for that, or whether it’s an
excuse for another cash perk.
Taxpayer-funded charities should be subject to official
information laws
A damning
report has revealed blowouts on travel and dining at
the taxpayer-funded Hepatitis Foundation by its board chair,
Chris Cunningham.
We were lucky to see
Charities Services investigate this case, but we cannot always rely on
the regulator. Taxpayers deserve to discover for themselves if their
earnings are being blown on fine dining and extended overseas
junkets.
One way to achieve this would be to open up charities
to the Official Information Act if they receive a certain proportion
of their funding (say, two thirds) from taxpayers. If that was the
case at the Hepatitis Foundation, we could have
monitored its spending directly, and potentially saved taxpayers a
costly investigation by Charities Services.
We're currently pursuing a tip-off related to serious financial
mismanagement at another taxpayer-funded charity, so watch this
space.
Should 'full time' councillors have full time side gigs?
You might have read about Wellington City Councillors voting for a
28 per cent increase
in their base salaries, up to $111,000 a year.
Well, for some councillors this apparently still isn't enough.
The
Herald reports on the case of councillors double-dipping with
second jobs.
The Herald's coverage comes as a result of us
highlighting the case of Iona Pannett. She’s paid by ratepayers for
the full-time job of being a City Councillor, while also collecting a
second sizeable salary as CEO of Birthright NZ.
Ratepayers forking out for Cr Pannett’s full-time salary
should expect her to be engaged in the role, not moonlighting for 30
hours a week running a nationwide NGO. To make things
worse, Birthright is largely taxpayer-funded, meaning Cr Pannett
drinks from two public gravy pots at once.
Parliament's $500,000 slide
When it was revealed that the new slide on the lawn of Parliament
cost taxpayers $500,000, our mascott, Porky the Waste-hater, decided
to visit and get his money's worth.
And who's that eating sushi in the background? None other than
Deputy Speaker Anne Tolley and Speaker Trevor Mallard – the
masterminds behind the project!
Here's a shot of Trevor trying to avoid eye contact with
Porky...
Have a great week,
|
Louis
Houlbrooke Communications Officer New Zealand
Taxpayers' Union
|
|