POSTCARD FROM PENNSYLVANIA
By Lisa Desjardins,
@LisaDNews
Correspondent
Lush green farmlands and gorgeous rocky overlooks greeted us as the (rented) PBS NewsHour election minivan barnstormed the great Commonwealth of Pennsylvania for three days at the end of last week.
The state votes today, with key primary races up and down the ballot. But we came away with a few notes we thought worth jotting down and sending to you.
(You can also view the Pennsylvania primary results
here.)
1. No Republican Senate candidate had a clear large group of wildly enthusiastic fans.
The race between television host Mehmet Oz, or Dr. Oz, businessman David McCormick and commentator Kathy Barnette has been a
head-scratcher for Republican strategists, trying to determine who might galvanize a sizable group of voters.
Crossing the state, we found just one steadfast Oz voter, a woman in suburban Philadelphia who liked his demeanor and trusts him. The doctor did not hold any events while we were there – and hasn’t since – making it even harder to assess the enthusiasm of his voters. Or who they are.
In contrast, McCormick has been assertively
out in public, including at an event with Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, which we attended. However, most of the voters there told us they were there to see Cruz. While some of them planned to vote for McCormick, one mixed him up with a candidate in another race – Doug Mastriano. Overall, we found little full-throated enthusiasm for McCormick in the state, including at his campaign event.
No doubt, Barnette has risen fast and has very enthusiastic supporters. They see her as authentic after her years as an anti-abortion activist. But, she was not well-known until Oz and McCormick’s two-man brawl left mutual destruction in its wake. Barnette came through the primary with few bruises, BUT, her late surge also means she is not well vetted. She participated in the Jan. 6 pro-Trump rally in 2021, but it’s not clear if she went into the U.S. Capitol. She has a history of
taking anti-gay and
anti-Muslim stances.
2. Democrats face an "electability" question.
Democratic voters in Pennsylvania are chewing on an important debate: What does “electability” mean in the post-Trump era? Their top choices are contrasts: U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, known for his moderate cross-party appeal, professional approach and campaign trail energy, and Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, a burly progressive who prefers hoodie sweatshirts and projects a kind of Pennsylvania grit.
What we found on the ground was decided passion for Fetterman. Lamb fans applaud and admire him, but largely support him out of the belief that a moderate is needed to win in November.
Fetterman voters disagree. They think what’s needed is a bold candidate with clear ideas and an approach that is far from cookie-cutter.
And that seems to be winning in polls. However, over the weekend, Fetterman’s campaign announced he was diagnosed with a minor stroke. The campaign insisted he will recover with no problems. Today, we learned he is also having a
new pacemaker installed to try to alleviate the underlying cause of the stroke.
For Democrats, within a single U.S. Senate seat of losing the chamber, it is a health concern they are watching closely.
3. Besides Donald Trump, this one name kept coming up.
In our travels, covering two Pennsylvania races and some 11 candidates closely, the name that came up the most in our political conversations with voters was one 1,000 miles away: Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis.
Republican voters across the spectrum repeatedly raised him as a figure they like and hope will run for president. (We often asked, “Who do you like in the party right now?”)
Interestingly, this included Donald Trump fans who told us different versions of a single thought: They still admire what Trump did as president but they see him as too turbulent and, in one voter’s word, “messy.” Another voter said it might be time for Trump to step aside, keep his social media platform and let another Republican take up his mantle.
For those in the Republican Party who have opposed the former president, the prospect of moving around or pushing aside Trump has proven impossible and politically dangerous.
But what we heard on the ground in Pennsylvania made us think that support for DeSantis is there, and members of either party should keep an eye on what he does next.
‘WE CANNOT REMAIN SILENT’