Viewpoint: Business dispute docket helps all Wisconsinites
by Patrick McIlheran
Jim Morrison, a circuit court judge in Marinette County, explains the stakes of certain cases by relating a story about a colleague, a judge in Appleton.
One Fox Valley hospital sued another hospital in a January dispute concerning emergency staffing. The judge got the case on a Friday. He ignored media pressure to decide it instantly and instead used a restraining order to get the hospitals to reach a deal satisfactory to the law and to the staffers caught in the middle.
The matter was resolved the following Monday.
In between, Morrison got a text from the judge, who was stuck in weekend traffic jammed up by a crash. A medevac helicopter coming to the rescue of the crash victims bore the name of one of the disputing hospitals – a reminder, says Morrison, of how urgent and important such disputes can be.
“I’m glad that helicopter was in the sky that day,” says Morrison, and it was in the sky in part because a colleague with sufficient background in arcane business disputes kept such a dispute from tying up two hospitals and hindering the work they do.
Resolving businesses’ legal fights swiftly is clearly good for businesses themselves. But proponents of Wisconsin’s relatively new Commercial Docket Pilot Project – the state’s effort to develop swifter, better-informed resolutions of specified business-vs.-business disputes – say it is also a public good.
Not everyone agrees.
Continue reading the Viewpoint.
|