What Nicholas Meriwether’s recent legal victory means for academic freedom
[link removed]
CounterCurrent:
A Victory Worth Celebrating
What Nicholas Meriwether’s recent legal victory means for academic freedom
CounterCurrent is the National Association of Scholars’ weekly newsletter, bringing you the biggest issues in academia and our responses to them.
[link removed]
Category: Academic Freedom; Reading Time: ~2 minutes
------------------------------------------------------------
** Featured Article - Victory: Shawnee State Agrees Professors Can’t Be Forced to Speak Contrary to Their Beliefs by the Alliance Defending Freedom ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
In January 2018, Dr. Nicholas Meriwether ([link removed]) found himself facing a philosophical dilemma. A professor of philosophy at Shawnee State University, Dr. Meriwether was well-accustomed to thinking through philosophical questions, and he was known for encouraging students ([link removed]) to think through both sides of the argument on any given issue. When confronted after class by a male student who identified as a transgender woman and insisted that he be referred to by female pronouns, Dr. Meriwether knew that his Christian beliefs obligated him to use language that reflected the student’s God-given sex rather than his chosen gender identity.
Instead of indulging the student’s request, Dr. Meriwether offered a compromise: he would refer to the student by his chosen name and avoid the use of pronouns altogether. But that wasn’t enough for the student, who became aggressive and hurled expletives at Dr. Meriwether. The student told Dr. Meriwether that he would get him fired—and immediately filed a complaint with the university.
The student’s campaign was nearly successful. The university formally charged Dr. Meriwether for “creating a hostile environment” and issued a written warning that threatened “further corrective actions” if he did not start using the student’s chosen pronouns.
At this point, you may wonder why I’m bringing this story up. Four years have passed since Dr. Meriwether’s encounter with the student, who has likely graduated by now (and has certainly left Dr. Meriwether’s classroom).
Believe it or not, I actually have good news to share. After four long years battling with the university in court, Dr. Meriwether has at last reached a favorable settlement ([link removed]) with Shawnee State University. The university has not only agreed to remove the discipline from Dr. Meriwether’s file and to pay him $400,000 in damages and attorney’s fees—it has agreed that Dr. Meriwether has the right to “choose when to use, or avoid using, titles or pronouns when referring to or addressing students.” The settlement is a huge victory for Dr. Meriwether, for his legal team at the Alliance Defending Freedom, and for free speech as a whole.
The settlement follows the Sixth Circuit Court’s decision ([link removed]) in March 2021, which reversed the lower court’s decision to dismiss the case. The decision declared: “If professors lacked free-speech protections when teaching, a university would wield alarming power to compel ideological conformity. A university president could require a pacifist to declare that war is just, a civil rights icon to condemn the Freedom Riders, a believer to deny the existence of God, or a Soviet émigré to address his students as ‘comrades.’ That cannot be.”
The National Association of Scholars agrees wholeheartedly with the Sixth Circuit Court’s statement in defense of academic freedom. As we stated in our amicus brief ([link removed]) for the case:
Higher education is, or ought to be, always open to debate, and those who wish to dispute the fundamental biological fact that humanity has now and has always had only two sexes are welcome to make their case. Likewise, those who dispute the essential complementarity of the sexes ought to have the freedom to argue whatever facts they can muster…
A university can hold the door wide open to those who are eager to declare such beliefs. But permitting individuals or groups to declare and advocate for those beliefs does not erase a university’s obligation to uphold the rights of others who stick with biological facts or standard usages. Nor does a willingness to entertain new “gender” theories dispose of the institutional obligation to respect and protect the teacher’s intellectual and academic freedom to speak in his own voice and according to his own understanding of anthropological realities.
With top-down attempts to enforce progressive gender ideology on college campuses ([link removed]) on the rise, it is encouraging to see our justice system uphold the rights of a professor who refuses to surrender to the new orthodoxy. Dr. Meriwether’s case shows that federal courts still provide a defense against universities that disregard the First Amendment. It’s a victory worth celebrating.
Until next week.
Marina Ziemnick
Communications Associate
National Association of Scholars
P. S. The NAS Affiliate in Wisconsin has been up to quite a bit these past few months. Their recent membership drive increased membership by around 10%, and they are working on completing a website that will make it easier to see what their members are up to throughout Wisconsin. Next month, on May 5th, they will be hosting NAS President Peter Wood for a lecture titled “Conformity, Resentment, and Trivialization: Higher Education in the Age of Woke.” Anyone who is interested in attending the event can register online here ([link removed]) .
In addition to their work to grow their membership, the NAS Wisconsin Affiliate is keeping an eye on recent developments surrounding free speech at the University of Wisconsin. At the beginning of April, UW-Whitewater’s Interim Chancellor, James P. Henderson, chose to resign ([link removed]) rather than implement a survey ([link removed]) to UW students about their perceptions of free speech, viewpoint diversity, and self-censorship on campus. Needless to say, the resignation suggests that at least some members of the UW administration were not keen to hear what students think about the state of free speech (or the lack thereof) at UW.
Read More ([link removed])
For more on gender ideology and academic freedom:
[link removed]
January 20, 2022
** An Initial Victory for UNT Professor Timothy Jackson ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
David Randall
Persecuted music professor Timothy Jackson has won an early battle in the courts. Every scholar who seeks redress against academic persecution should take heart..
[link removed]
October 05, 2021
** NAS Statement on Gender Ideology in Higher Education ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
National Association of Scholars
The National Association of Scholars opposes the proliferation of gender ideology in American higher education.
[link removed]
June 22, 2021
** ED Celebrates Pride Month with New Interpretation of Title IX ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
David Acevedo
The Biden administration is on a dangerous path with Title IX, one that will only lead to rampant injustice for students, professors, and administrators alike.
[link removed]
May 27, 2021
** Oklahoma Universities Are Teaching Students to Lie ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
David Randall
Regents should never hire as a university president anyone who does not publicly condemn the lies of “gender expression” and affirm the basic truth that men and women exist.
** About the NAS
------------------------------------------------------------
The National Association of Scholars, founded in 1987, emboldens reasoned scholarship and propels civil debate. We’re the leading organization of scholars and citizens committed to higher education as the catalyst of American freedom.
============================================================
Follow NAS on social media.
** Facebook ([link removed])
** Twitter ([link removed])
** YouTube ([link removed])
** Website ([link removed])
** Donate ([link removed])
| ** Join ([link removed])
| ** Renew ([link removed])
| ** Bookstore ([link removed])
Copyright © 2022 National Association of Scholars, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you opted in via our website, membership or donation forms, contact forms at events, or by signing open letters.
Our mailing address is:
National Association of Scholars
420 Madison Avenue
7th Floor
New York, NY 10017-2418
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.
