Plus, Friday is Earth Day and we have some polls that show it matters to your viewers, readers and listeners, and what they care about most. Email not displaying correctly?
View it in your browser ([link removed]) .
[link removed]
[link removed]


** A federal judge overturned the public transport mask mandate. What happens now?
------------------------------------------------------------
Travelers wearing face masks arrive at the Los Angeles International Airport in Los Angeles, Wednesday, Dec. 22, 2021. AP Photo/Ringo H.W. Chiu)

U.S. District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle ([link removed]) of the Middle District of Florida ruled Monday that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention does not have the authority to enforce a mask mandate that is currently set to expire May 3. (Read the ruling here ([link removed]) .)
(Monday’s ruling by Judge Mizelle)

On Monday night, news organizations quoted “a Biden administration official” as saying the Transportation Security Administration would not enforce the CDC’s mandate as government agencies review potential next steps, including an appeal that could include a halt on the judge’s ruling. The official, who spoke on background, said the White House is trying to balance the unpopular mandate with a rise of new COVID-19 cases.

White House press secretary Jen Psaki said the White House’s view is still that people should wear masks on airplanes and that the ruling was “disappointing.”

Delta Air Lines said it would continue to enforce the mask requirement until it hears directly from the TSA that the rule is no longer enforceable.

The mandate has been in effect since February 2021, a couple of weeks after President Joe Biden took office, and has been under fire from many sides. 21 states have sued to end the mask requirement and all 50 states have ended their indoor mask mandates.

10 airlines, including the biggest ones (Delta, United, American), sent a letter to President Biden ([link removed]) asking him to sunset the mandate as spring travel sends 2 million fliers a day to the boarding gates.

The Health Freedom Defense Fund ([link removed]) filed the lawsuit, which argued that the mandate violated the Administrative Procedures Act. The other plaintiffs included Ana Carolina Daza, who said she suffered from anxiety that is aggravated by wearing masks.

This is the third significant ruling against Biden-era COVID-19 directives that would have required employers to test or require vaccinations for employees, shut down the cruise ship industry and prohibited landlords from evicting non-paying tenants. In those cases and in this one, the courts ruled that the CDC exceeded its authority and, if Congress wants the CDC to have that power, it should pass specific legislation saying so.

This is the section of the Public Health Services Act of 1944 that the CDC relies on to enforce all of its mandates:
(Public Health Services Act 1944)

Judge Mizelle dissected it, as other judges must reason whether it allows the CDC to require masks, prohibit evictions and so on.

The judge’s ruling focuses on the second sentence and finds that the CDC may enforce regulations for inspection, fumigation, disinfection, sanitation, pest extermination, destruction of animals or articles found to be so infected or contaminated as to be sources of dangerous infection to human beings and other measures. The judge reads that to mean the only “other measures” that the CDC may take must have to do with fumigation, disinfection and other actions mentioned in that sentence.

The government said its mask mandate power comes from a word in the second sentence: “sanitation.” But the judge said the 1944 understanding of sanitation would have to do with cleansing, which would not apply in this case. “Wearing a mask cleans nothing. At most, it traps virus droplets. But it neither ‘sanitizes’ the person wearing the mask nor ‘sanitizes’ the conveyance,” Judge Mizelle ruled.

More importantly, the judge said, sanitation is a word that refers to “property,” not individuals.

The judge did say the CDC has the authority to “directly regulate” people who are “reasonably believed to be infected with a communicable disease in a qualifying stage.”

Usually, the Administrative Procedures Act requires the government to set aside time for public comment, but the Biden administration said in a pandemic there was no time for that, and it could be “contrary to public health.” The judge wrote that the CDC should have provided evidence that there was an urgency behind its order. She pointed out that at the time the CDC began the order, the pandemic had been unfolding for more than a year and cases, for the moment, were declining.

BuzzFeed News points out ([link removed]) these details about the judge:

Mizelle was 33 when she became the youngest person successfully appointed by former president Donald Trump to the federal bench ([link removed]) in November 2020. The American Bar Association had advised that she was "not qualified" ([link removed]) for the lifetime appointment. She is married to Chad Mizelle ([link removed]) , who served as acting general counsel for the Department of Homeland Security under Trump, as well as associate counsel at the Trump White House.


** Friday is Earth Day. Your viewers, readers and listeners care.
------------------------------------------------------------
In this Sept. 27, 2020, file photo, an air tanker drops retardant on the Glass Fire burning in Calistoga, Calif. (AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)

When I was in college in the ’70s, Earth Day was a day when only the most socially aware people would talk about “saving the environment” and skeptics called them tree-huggers and extremists. Compare that to this recent quote: ([link removed])

“Climate change is the single greatest health threat to humanity,” said Jeffrey Duchin, a health officer for Seattle and King County. “And I’ve been preoccupied with Covid over the last two years.”

Remember this 1991 ad that ran in newspapers nationwide along with radio ads and targeted ads on talk radio?
(The Information Council for the Environment)

It came from the Information Council for the Environment ([link removed]) , which was sponsored by coal companies and electric companies ([link removed]) that used coal. The group aimed to convince people that climate change was merely a theory, not a scientific fact. It also claimed that proof that carbon dioxide was the primary cause of climate change was “nonexistent.”

Today, the Pew Research Center finds, “Most Americans say climate change affects their local community, including 70% living near coast ([link removed]) .”
[link removed]
(Pew Research Center)

And, “67% of Americans perceive a rise in extreme weather, but partisans differ over government efforts to address it ([link removed]) .”

Gallup polling asks Americans whether our collective understanding of the seriousness of global warming is generally exaggerated, underestimated or correct. The number of Americans who say it is exaggerated and the number who say it is understated are almost equal. But go back a decade and notice how those numbers have changed.
[link removed]
(Gallup)

Gallup has been tracking American attitudes toward environmental issues for decades and one trend is clear: When the economy begins to waver, economic matters take center stage and environmental concerns move to the back burner.
[link removed]
(Gallup)

We saw what happened this month when President Biden was faced with rising gasoline prices. He approved the summertime use of E-15 ethanol ([link removed]) , which is associated with increased summer air pollution. The rule change will produce a 10-cent per gallon savings for parts of the country that have access to the higher ethanol fuel.

A CBS story opens this way ([link removed]) :

If climate change were a disaster film, it would likely be accused of being too over-the-top: wildfires reducing entire towns to ashes ([link removed]) , hurricanes swamping cities ([link removed]) , droughts draining lakes ([link removed]) and withering fields ([link removed]) , and raging oceans redrawing the very maps of our coasts ([link removed]) . And now, many cities and states are asking, who's going to pay for all of this?

"This is real; we're on the front line of climate change right here in Charleston," said John Tecklenburg, the mayor of Charleston, South Carolina. The city's been battered by an endless parade of floods due to sea level rise. Some desperate homeowners have resorted to raising their homes by several feet.

Charleston and more than two dozen cities, counties and states are suing ExxonMobil, Shell, Chevron, BP, ConocoPhillips and other fossil fuel companies to cover the costs of climate change.
[link removed]
(CBS News)

Yale’s Program on Climate Change Communication ([link removed]) recently published interactive maps and graphics that let you drill in on public opinion about climate change at a very local level in every state ([link removed]) . This is the big picture ([link removed]) :
[link removed]
(Yale Program on Climate Change Communication)

When the Yale project asks people what global warming means to them personally, it is interesting that most Americans say it will affect people in other places but do not yet see how it will affect them.
[link removed]
(Yale Program on Climate Change Communication)

Gallup recently asked Americans ([link removed]) what the Biden administration should do to respond to climate change. By a wide margin, respondents said yes to incentives for installing solar and wind power and buying electric cars. Americans told Gallup they support hiking fuel efficiency requirements for new vehicles and that the country should spend more federal dollars to install electric vehicle charging stations.
[link removed]
(Gallup)

A few recent climate-related stories from the past week:
* Military installations affected by climate change,Military Times ([link removed])
* New data ([link removed]) shows climate change made hurricanes stronger and wetter, The Weather Channel ([link removed])
* Wind Power Overtook Coal, Nuclear for First Time in U.S. on March 29 ([link removed]) , The Hill
* Expanding Drought Leaves Western US Scrambling for Water ([link removed]) , The Associated Press
* How tech is/can address climate change,Recode ([link removed]) /Vox
* Long after the pandemic eases, climate change will disrupt supply chains, Yale Environment 360 ([link removed])
* Climate change is and will affect commercial fishing, WHYY ([link removed]) /Rutgers
* Backed-Up Pipes, Stinky Yards: Climate Change Is Wrecking Septic Tanks ([link removed]) , The Washington Post
* Biden Plans to Open More Public Land to Drilling, ([link removed]) The New York Times
* Fight Brewing Over Calif. Ballot Measure to Reduce Single-Use Plastics ([link removed]) , Los Angeles Times

Other interesting angles:

One 2016 study ([link removed]) examined the link between weather and crime in Baltimore. That study found, “Maximum daily temperature is the most important weather factor associated with violence and trauma in our study period and location.” That study even suggested that hospitals keep temperature increases in mind when they forecast staffing needs. Another study said ([link removed]) , “We find that there is 1% increase in the assault rate for every degree increase in the maximum daily temperature.”

A study by the Medical Society Consortium on Climate and Health, the Natural Resources Defense Council and Wisconsin Health Professional for Climate Action found that climate change and associated air pollution cost Americans $800 billion a year, counting premature deaths, medical costs, lost jobs and mental health harms.

Politico notes ([link removed]) :

Some of these factors are more directly measurable than others, but even those are hard to quantify. For instance, hundreds of Americans died last summer from heat stroke ([link removed]) causing cardiac arrest, brain damage and other organ failure. Still moredied from drowning ([link removed]) as they attempted to cool off. Emergency workers and hospital staff were stretched thin between the heat emergency and coronavirus cases.

These are the “cascading” impacts of climate change-related health issues, as Duchin and other public health experts refer to as the domino-like health and equity challenges springing up.

“Our health care system was already stressed from Covid-19, and then you have the added burden of a climate-induced weather event that adds additional stress both to our emergency medical services and to our health care delivery system,” he said. “We really need to pay more attention to bolstering the resilience of our health care system to deal with these multiple threats.”

A new Harris poll ([link removed]) finds 84% of teenagers believe climate change left unchecked will trigger global political instability and render parts of the planet uninhabitable. The young people told pollsters that they believe companies and legislators aren’t doing enough.

We have come a long way from the first Earth Day on April 22, 1970. It was first proposed in 1969 by Wisconsin Sen. Gaylord Nelson, right around the time that the Cuyahoga River in Cleveland caught on fire.

In 1970, President Richard Nixon won a fight to establish the Environmental Protection Agency and then passed the Clean Air Act. The fight began against pollution and litter but, over time, journalists investigated the effect of environmental toxins and shrinking green spaces.

One year after the first Earth Day, 25% ([link removed]) of Americans believed it to be important to protect the environment. Today, 43% percent of Americans worry “a great deal” about climate change ([link removed]) , and another 22% worry “a fair amount” about it.

We’ll be back tomorrow with a new edition of Covering COVID-19. Are you subscribed? Sign up here ([link removed]) to get it delivered right to your inbox.
[link removed]
I want more fresh story ideas during the COVID-19 pandemic. ([link removed])
GIVE NOW ([link removed])

[link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] mailto:[email protected]?subject=Feedback%20for%20Poynter
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
© All rights reserved Poynter Institute 2022
801 Third Street South, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
If you don't want to receive email updates from Poynter, we understand.
You can update your subscription preferences here ([link removed]) or unsubscribe ([link removed]) .