A Lonely 'No'
It turns out I broke the comity of the Senate this week.* Apparently we'd passed every bill so far this session unanimously. Then I was the lone ‘no’ vote on a civics education bill.
I'm actually a big fan of civics education. The bill was a tough vote because I liked almost everything in it. Alaska students need more civics. And the curriculum includes Alaska Native Tribal ways of governing. Still, I voted ‘no’ because the bill makes the test a graduation requirement.
I worked at the Department of Education & Early Development when Alaska started implementing high school graduation tests at the end of the 1990s. That policy was an educational and financial failure. We’ve since rolled it back and mailed a lot of young people diplomas after the fact.
While this new bill is put together very differently than the old high-stakes exit exam, I wasn’t going to vote to sidle back in the direction of graduation tests.
*Comity actually survived. But I did get a fair bit of good-natured razzing about it.