Sixteen States Renew Legal Efforts to Stop Health Care Worker Vaccine Mandate
Sixteen state attorneys general filed a complaint against the Biden administration
in yet another attempt to block the federal vaccine mandate for health care workers.
The suit filed on Feb. 4 in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Louisiana
asserts that the Delta variant has gone, and that vaccines aren’t as effective
against the Omicron variant. Therefore, “simply put, the situation has changed,”
the lawsuit says. “And that reveals
a fundamental, structural defect in the rule—its one-size-fits-all approach
doesn’t account for developing data and circumstances.”
The lawsuit asks the district court to issue an injunction
and to stay compliance deadlines pending judicial review.
While the Supreme Court upheld the Centers for Medicare &
Medicaid (CMS) health care worker vaccine mandate, it struck down the Occupational Safety
and Health Administration's (OSHA) vaccine mandate for businesses with 100
or more employees on the basis that the rule was overly broad and took a “one-size-fits-all”
approach. The Court determined that OSHA’s mandate should have been more narrowly
tailored to the various industries impacted by its vaccine mandate. It appears
that the rationale used in this new lawsuit tries to mirror the rationale used by the Court in the OSHA ruling.
The 16 states represented in the lawsuit are Louisiana, Montana,
Arizona, Alabama, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Mississippi, Ohio, Oklahoma,
South Carolina, Tennessee, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia. Fourteen of the 16
were plaintiffs in the January 2022 Supreme Court case that upheld the CMS vaccine
mandate for health care workers whose facilities participated in the Medicare and Medicaid programs.
Health care workers in 14 of the 16 states in the lawsuit must
receive their first dose by Feb. 14 and their second dose by March 15. Health
care workers in in Tennessee and Virginia had a first-dose deadline of Jan. 27
with a full vaccination deadline of Feb. 28.