Good morning!

Closing out 2021, I reflect on the importance of a taxpayer victory achieved in 2021 that was made possible only by activists having stayed long in the fight. 

But first, today's Texas Minute looks at the top two stories of 2021 as determined by our readers.

– Michael Quinn Sullivan 

Friday, December 31, 2021
Update/change your subscription.

• Join Brandon Waltens and me on The Headline at 11 a.m. today as we talk about the biggest stories of 2021! The podcast and video archive will be available a little later in the day.

Recapping The Stories So Far

• #10 was children forced to undergo gender transitions…
   
• #9 parents waking up to public schools’ woke agendas…
   
• #8 election integrity fights (and losses)…
    
• #7 Democrats going unpunished after breaking the constitutional quorum…
    
• #6 legislators refusing to rein in executive and local mandate powers…
   
• #5 Gov. Abbott ignoring calls for a special session to address vaccine mandates…
   
• #4 ongoing border crisis…
   
• #3 failure of the Texas Legislature to advance GOP priorities…

#2: Passage of the Heartbeat Act

• Texas lawmakers took a new approach to abortion law in 2021, with passage of Senate Bill 8, known at the time as the “Heartbeat Law.” The measure has already withstood several early court challenges and is credited with significantly reducing the number of abortions in Texas. Jacob Asmussen recounts the story.
   
• The law states that a “physician may not knowingly perform or induce an abortion” once “a fetal heartbeat” has been detected. Rather than center enforcement on government officials, the law empowers citizens to sue abortion facilities and anyone who assists in executing a heartbeat-detected child.
   
• President Joe Biden called the Heartbeat Act “un-American” and promised a “whole-of-government effort” to retaliate.
   
• Yet in December the U.S. Supreme Court rejected pro-abortionists’ calls to stop the enforcement of the Heartbeat Act. Although limited challenges to the law continue to work their way through the courts, Texans are currently empowered by the law to sue abortionists who kill a heartbeat-detected baby.

#1: Winter Storm Blackout

• In February 2021 Texans suffered for days under freezing cold temperatures and power outages, making a mockery of the Lone Star State’s reputation for energy production. Robert Montoya has the details.
   
• Half of the state’s wind turbines were frozen solid in February and wind generation “bottomed out,” as the Texas Public Policy Foundation’s Jason Isaac described it. “Because of this massive gap in wind production and ERCOT’s delay, what should have been a series of brief rolling blackouts—inconvenient but manageable—instead turned into 4 million Texans left in the cold and without answers.”
   
• Mismanagement of ERCOT – the Energy Reliability Council of Texas – was quickly recognized as the linchpin in the catastrophic failures that included an over-reliance on unreliable “green” energy sources.
   
• While Texas suffered no further statewide blackouts in 2021, only time will tell if state officials have done enough to secure the power grid.

Friday Reflection: Committed to the Fight

On TV, a murder is solved within two commercial breaks. At the movies, a galaxy-spanning war can be resolved in under an hour. Even when we read real accounts of great movements, everything is neatly contained between two covers and around 500 pages.

Yet when visiting the great cathedrals of Europe, I have always been struck by the sheer number of years involved in building them – entire generations came and went in the work of creating a place of worshipful beauty.  The work itself, spread over a millennia, is an act of worship.

It’s easy to forget that great things take time. And, often, that those who prepare the soil don’t get to reap the harvest.

It has taken decades, but earlier this year – with almost no fanfare – the Texas Legislature finally passed a strict limitation on the growth of state government spending. This didn’t happen overnight.

In the 1970s, there was a move led by a former California governor named Ronald Reagan to limit the growth of government – to control the leviathan of the state by controlling its diet. Texas lawmakers, eager to capitalize on a national trend that wasn’t disco pants, did what Texas lawmakers almost always do: the absolute minimum. The spending limit enshrined in the Texas Constitution had the words without the substance, limiting nothing. In fact, lawmakers completely ignored what token limitation it provided for the next decade and a half.

That’s when a firebrand lawmaker named Talmadge Heflin, a Republican from Houston, took the state to court to enforce the application of the limit. As meaningless as the limit was, Heflin’s action put the tool on the radar of grassroots activists. Over the next twenty years, conservative activists made using, and then strengthening, the state’s spending limit a top priority.

Not only did conservative activists push the issue from the outside, but the Republican Party of Texas adopted it as a key plank in their fiscal policy platforms each biennium.

Legislative efforts driven by citizen activism toiled on, reaching fruition in 2021 when legislation putting a tight lid on future state spending was adopted. Of course, it doesn’t actually take effect until the 2024-2025 state budget that will be adopted in 2023.

But the story of limiting government spending doesn’t actually end there. 

Since the effort began in the 1970s, a nagging question has been what to do with the surplus money – that delta between what government gets in taxable revenue and how much of it they can spend. The easiest answer, give the money back to the taxpayers, now has practical application.

The spending limit will generate massive surpluses, all of which can be used to reduce Texas’ massive property tax burden. The spending limit is a key component in a plan that would see public school property tax burdens eliminated a decade from now.

In fact, eliminating property taxes can only happen by reducing the growth of government. That’s because tax problems are symptoms of spending problems. Your taxes are burdensome only because government spends so much.

Many of the well-intentioned activists of the 1970s who pushed originally for a spending limit weren’t around to see it made whole, but their work cleared a path. Those who fought to make the weak limit strong have since retired or moved on, but they built a strong foundation. And those who were around for the limit to be made real won’t necessarily reap the benefits of its actual implementation.

In the great works of life, none of us are actually called to be successful – we are called, however, to be faithful. Part of that faithfulness is in working toward a greater goal which might not be completed in our lifetimes.

As activists, we must be committed to the long fight – to a willingness to fight for a better tomorrow we might not ourselves see. The cause of liberty is advanced not in giant leaps, but in persistent and consistent steps forward.

Pushing onward together we can build a culture of life and liberty more beautiful than any cathedral.