From Amb. Mark Green | Wilson Center <[email protected]>
Subject Stubborn Things: UNHRC, the App Store in China, and African Displacement
Date November 3, 2021 4:26 PM
  Links have been removed from this email. Learn more in the FAQ.
  Links have been removed from this email. Learn more in the FAQ.
Having trouble? View this email in your browser. [[link removed]]

[link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]]


[link removed] [[link removed]]


[link removed] [[link removed]]


The United Nations Human Rights Council has condemned Israel 95 times, and China not once.
Since its inception, the Human Rights Council, or UNHRC, has passed 95 resolutions condemning Israel, more than all other countries combined [[link removed]] . Bashar al Assad’s Syria, which has subjected its own people to barrel bombs, chlorine gas, and starvation to preserve his autocracy, has garnered a mere 36 condemnations from UNHRC. North Korea has been condemned only 14 times. China, in the midst of a genocide against its Muslim Uighur citizens, has accumulated a grand total of zero condemnations.
UNHRC is the second iteration of this council. The first, the UN Commission on Human Rights, or UNCHR, was established in 1946, and eventually lost credibility not only for its vitriolic criticism of Israel, but its membership made up of a “ rogues’ gallery [[link removed]] of human rights abusers.” In 2004 the United States walked out [[link removed]] following the uncontested election to the Commission of Sudan, which was then ethnically cleansing the Darfur region.
The 2006 establishment of UNHRC was intended to refresh the legitimacy of the UN’s human rights body. The Council’s founding charter [[link removed]] provides that elected members “shall uphold the highest standards in the promotion and protection of human rights…and be reviewed…during their terms of membership.” And yet, its current membership includes China, Russia, Cuba, and Venezuela.
Three years after the Trump Administration withdrew from UNHRC over its anti-Israel bias, the U.S. is rejoining the body following its “election” on October 14. The Biden Administration argues that UNHRC can only be reformed or fixed from within. Given the UNHRC’s lack of action on obvious topics like the genocide in China’s Xinjiang Province and its willingness to include in its membership countries like Venezuela, the question is, “where do you begin?”


[link removed] [[link removed]]


Each and every day, millions of people around the world turn to the apps, “Quran Majeed” and “Bible App by Olive Tree.” At the Xi government’s request, Apple is removing them from its China App Store.
According to BBC reporting [[link removed]] , both apps had run afoul of Chinese regulators and Apple’s policy is to comply with local laws, even those from authoritarian regimes, which according to Apple means that “at times there are complex issues about which we may disagree with governments.”
Of course, in the case of Quran Majeed, the “complex issue” might be the Chinese Communist Party’s genocide of China’s Muslim Uighur minority through torture [[link removed]] , internment [[link removed]] , and forced sterilization [[link removed]] . According to the Chinese government’s own Statistical Yearbook, sterilizations nationwide fell by more than 60% between 2015 and 2018; but in the province of Xinjiang, home to the Uighurs, sterilizations increased [[link removed]] by 500%.
Another “complexity” might be the money Apple makes in part thanks to China. With approximately 13% of global smartphone sales, Apple accounts for a dominating 75% of all profits [[link removed]] from these sales. This is partly because of the high price Apple can charge for its premium brand, and partly due to the persistent low cost of production in China. Interestingly, despite U.S. sanctions, Apple has become more dependent on Chinese manufacturers in recent years, with China now accounting [[link removed]] for nearly half of all Apple suppliers. “Chinese suppliers win orders by offering very low prices to Apple that non-China suppliers find hard to imagine,” an Apple supply chain manager told Nikkei Asia [[link removed]] .
Since 2017 [[link removed]] , Apple has complied with CCP requests to remove items from its App Store some 55,000 times.


[link removed] [[link removed]]


A record 32 million Africans are forcibly displaced today because of conflict and repression.
According to figures compiled from the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM), a record number [[link removed]] of Africans are now displaced from their homes. Three quarters of the total are displaced within their own countries (“IDPs”), and the balance are hosted primarily in neighboring countries. The Democratic Republic of Congo alone accounts for more than 6 million displaced people.
Eight out of ten displacement source countries in Africa are authoritarian or semi-authoritarian, which isn’t a surprise because the link between autocracy and instability [[link removed]] is strong. According to analysis by the Africa Center for Strategic Studies, 56% of all autocracies on the continent are in conflict, compared to a quarter of democratizers and zero full democracies. In Ethiopia, where recent progress in democratization has now badly backslid [[link removed]] with troubled elections, increasing repression and an intensifying interethnic war, conflict and instability are causing famine — and even more humanity in motion [[link removed]] .


AuthorAmbassador Mark Green Ambassador Mark Green [[link removed]]
President, Director, & CEO, Wilson Center

Explore More
[[link removed]]

[link removed] [[link removed]] Wilson Quarterly Logo [[link removed]]
Fall 2021Humanity in Motion
Scenes from the Global Displacement Crisis
READ THE ISSUE [[link removed]]


Missed a previous post?
Read all of the past Stubborn Things posts on our website.
READ PAST POSTS [[link removed]]


[link removed] [[link removed]]One Woodrow Wilson Plaza Follow the Wilson Center
1300 Pennsylvania Ave. NW [link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]] [link removed] [[link removed]]
Washington, DC 20004-3027 Was this email forwarded? Subscribe now [[link removed]]
Phone: (202) 691-4000 [tel:(202) 691-4000]

© 2021 The Wilson Center. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy [[link removed]] unsubscribe: [link removed]
Screenshot of the email generated on import

Message Analysis