This week there was a huge victory for the West Midlands 3 and the Sikh community. Piara Singh Gill, Amritivir Singh Wahiwala and Gursharanvir Singh Wahiwala, three men all from the West Midlands, were accused by the Indian authorities of being involved in a high-profile 2009 murder plot. In 2011 this was investigated by West Midlands Police investigation who found absolutely no evidence to support this. Yet in December 2020, the Home Office certified an extradition request from
the Indian authorities which, according to Edward Fitzgerald QC, was "made on the basis of wholly unsubstantiated allegations”. On Wednesday, the three British Sikhs, were in court to decide whether their extradition to India would go ahead, despite the Indian Government having dropped all charges. While the Crown Prosecution Service dropped the case, it has led to many questions being raised on the decisions made by the Home Secretary, Priti Patel MP, to allow the extradition to go ahead, despite poor-quality evidence against them. According to the highly respected human rights lawyer Gareth Peirce, not only had the Indian authorities brought a case without evidence, but the
prosecution had failed to tell the court that there had already been trials of other men in India in the same case and all had been acquitted. The prosecution had tried to reuse evidence that had already been judged in such cases to have been fabricated, as witnesses had been coerced I am extremely concerned that an extradition request for these innocent men has been certified by the Home Office despite multiple previous investigations and no credible new evidence having been brought forward. It raises serious questions about how a campaign against three British citizens has been allowed to drag on so long, costing the British taxpayer thousands of pounds, and putting the accused, their families and community through a
harrowing ordeal in the bid to clear their names. In my capacity as Chair of the APPG for British Sikhs, I have written to the Home Secretary to ask four important questions: 1) What process did the Home Office follow to lead it to certify the request to extradite the West Midlands Three to India? 2) Was the Home Secretary aware of the previous investigations into the allegations made against these three men? 3) Why has thousands of pounds of British taxpayers' money been spent on a case based on already discredited evidence? 4) What discussions will the Home Secretary have with the Foreign Secretary and counterparts in the Indian authorities to raise
concerns about the troubling implications of this case and ensure that further baseless and discredited charges cannot be repeatedly brought against British nationals by a foreign power? |