Your weekly source for analysis and insight from experts at the Brennan Center for Justice
The Briefing
Who wrote the Constitution?
That’s obvious, we think: it was crafted by 55 men in powdered wigs who met in Philadelphia over the summer of 1787 with the charge of “establishing in these states a firm national government.” But more than 40 percent of the Constitution was actually written after 1787 in a series of 27 amendments adopted over the course of two centuries amid some of the most colorful, contested, and controversial battles in American life. While the Framers get all the credit for the nation’s charter, the American people deserve to share the byline.
Today, with the publication of The People’s Constitution by the Brennan Center’s own John Kowal and Wilfred Codrington, this history comes vividly to life in a book Publishers Weekly calls “a fresh and invigorating take on the history of American democracy.”
The book tells the 233-year story of how the American people have taken an imperfect Constitution — a document both profoundly visionary and fundamentally flawed — and made it more democratic, more inclusive, and more suited to the needs of a changing country through the Article V amending process. Some of these additions have wrought profound changes to America’s fundamental law: safeguarding individual liberties, ending slavery, expanding access to the ballot, upholding equality. Others are best described as technical fixes.
But when we consider the 27 amendments as a whole, it is no exaggeration to say that much of what we consider the very heart of our national charter — from its protections for free speech and religion to its guarantees of due process and equal protection of the laws — come from these periodic upgrades to the Framers’ beta version of our national charter.
This lively and accessible history explores an intriguing pattern. In recurring cycles, Americans have added several new amendments in the span of a few years’ time, prodded by powerful social movements. Just as predictably, these periods of ferment are followed by decades-long dry spells. In this way, our Constitution has been revitalized and its promise renewed in four distinct waves of Constitutional change.
Twelve Founding Era amendments (1789–1804) fixed glitches and omissions in the original text, including the lack of comprehensive protection for individual rights.
Three Reconstruction amendments (1865–1870) promised a “second founding” after the cataclysm of the Civil War, guaranteeing equal citizenship and voting rights to newly freed African-American men while imposing significant new limits on state governments, particularly in the South.
Four Progressive Era amendments (1909–1920) embodied the modernizing zeal of the age: authorizing the income tax, providing for the popular election of senators, extending the franchise to women, and launching the misguided experiment of Prohibition.
And four Civil Rights Era amendments (1960–1971) further expanded voting rights while updating presidential succession amid the doomsday fears of the nuclear age.
In these polarized times, it may seem impossible to imagine forging the broad consensus needed to amend the Constitution anytime soon. And yet, as Kowal and Codrington explore, when our Constitution seems unable to adapt to changing times, when political gridlock and a retrograde Supreme Court stand in the way of needed reforms, the next wave of constitutional change may already be building.
Which reforms will rise to the top of the agenda? Will we finally abolish the Electoral College and provide meaningful protection for every citizen’s right to vote? Will far-right activists succeed in summoning a new constitutional convention to radically restrict the size and power of the federal government?
For more on this rigorous yet intimate history, check out New Press’s website. You won’t be sorry.

 

Democracy
The Protecting Our Democracy Act
This morning, the Protecting our Democracy Act was introduced in the House. It’s critical legislation that would strengthen ethics regulations against the abuse of presidential power. The reforms include tightening protections against political interference by the White House in law enforcement matters and increasing transparency around controversial pardons. It would also protect the independence of inspectors general and guard against presidential abuse of emergency powers. “The bill contains provisions that would prevent further erosion of longstanding practices that helped safeguard the rule of law but have been under attack,” Martha Kinsella writes. // Read More
What’s in the Freedom to Vote Act
Last week, a group of key Democratic senators led by Sens. Joe Manchin (D-WV) and Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) introduced the Freedom to Vote Act, a comprehensive and historic package of election reforms that addresses many of the biggest problems facing American democracy. From banning dark money and partisan gerrymandering to establishing guardrails against election interference and voter suppression, a new Brennan Center resource breaks down the bill’s key provisions. // READ MORE

 

Constitution
The Costs of Post-9/11 Surveillance
Expansive domestic surveillance has become the norm in America, as fear of terrorism and loosened guidelines led to rampant data collection and intelligence agencies spying on Americans without proper cause. This drastic growth in our surveillance infrastructure has paved the way for racial, ethnic, and religious profiling and the suppression of political dissent, writes Faiza Patel. “As we mark two decades since these changes became part of the legal landscape, it is time to rethink whether the nation is well served by a domestic intelligence system that can so easily be diverted from legitimate purposes.” // JUST SECURITY

 

Justice
Federal Sentencing Reform
As Congress moves forward with a package of bipartisan criminal justice reform bills that work to reduce the racial disparities caused by federal drug sentencing laws, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) has taken to spreading misinformation on past reforms and current imprisonment conditions. Ames Grawert and Lauren-Brooke Eisen respond to misleading and misguided arguments and speak to the potential of this crucial moment for reform. “We know that our nation’s justice system fails to live up to the American ideals of equality, fairness, and redemption. Let’s not let Cotton’s calls for extreme and ineffective policies get in the way of fixing it,” they write. // READ MORE

 

Coming Up
  • Thursday, September 23 // 12–1 p.m. ET
    Twenty years after 9/11 and in the wake of the U.S. exit from Afghanistan, learn what’s lost, what’s won, and what threatens us now. As America comes to terms with new domestic political realities and a changed geopolitical landscape, how do we strengthen and protect our civil liberties while fighting terrorism and maintaining a peaceful international order? What are the most pressing threats we face, both domestically and internationally, and how can the U.S. government deal with them without eroding our freedoms even more than the “war on terror” already has? RSVP today
    Produced in partnership with the National Parks of New York Harbor Conservancy at Federal Hall and New York University's John Brademas Center
  • Wednesday, October 6 // 7–8 p.m. ET, 6–7 p.m. CT
    Join Keisha N. Blain in conversation with Donna Brazile for the launch of Blain’s new book, Until I Am Free: Fannie Lou Hamer's Enduring Message to America.
    Hamer, who came to political activism in mid-life after a forced sterilization, was a relentless advocate for voting rights for Black Americans and against white supremacy. Award-winning historian and New York Times bestselling author Blain shines a light on Hamer’s life, ideas, and political strategies, situating her as a key political thinker of the civil rights movement, alongside Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, John Lewis, and Rosa Parks. RSVP today
    Produced in partnership with the National Civil Rights Museum

 

News
  • Michael Li on new state congressional map proposals // WASHINGTON POST
  • Faiza Patel on post-9/11 surveillance of Muslim Americans // PBS NEWSHOUR
  • Michael Waldman on the Freedom to Vote Act // ABC NEWS