Here is the Heritage Take on the top issues today.
Please reply to this email to arrange an interview.
America Deserves Answers on Botched Afghanistan Withdrawal – Americans want to know whether the U.S. should have blown up all the military equipment rather than have it be captured by the Taliban? What about the decision to abandon the military prison at Bagram Airfield containing thousands of the worst terrorists in Afghanistan? To Americans accustomed to seeing their military succeed, none of what they see on TV makes sense. These questions—and others like them—concerning the actions of the U.S. military are all legitimate. In the coming days, for Americans to fully understand the answers that will hopefully be forthcoming, we also need to understand the associated timing and authorities under which the U.S. military was operating. In military operations, the timing of decisions is crucial: Options that are available early in a campaign become increasingly difficult or impossible to execute as time passes. Time and enemy action impose a tyranny that is difficult, if not impossible, to overcome. Heritage expert: Tom Spoehr
Biden Must Avoid Another Fiasco With Iran After Afghanistan Debacle – Iran is one of the biggest winners of the Taliban’s triumph in Afghanistan. Although Tehran has clashed in the past with the Sunni extremist Taliban, which abhors the Shiite interpretation of Islam practiced in Iran and by some of Iran’s Afghan allies, both Islamist movements violently oppose the U.S. and Western influence. The chaotic U.S. retreat from Afghanistan and the planned drawdown of U.S. troops in Iraq has alarmed U.S. allies in the Middle East threatened by Iran. The American debacle in Afghanistan also is likely to be interpreted by Tehran as a sign of the Biden administration’s diminishing determination to protect American security interests in the region. The Biden administration should not compound these adverse trends by reviving the Iran nuclear agreement, which was a Faustian bargain that rewarded Tehran with long-term sanctions relief in exchange for short-term restrictions on its nuclear program. Key aspects of the agreement have already started to expire. The U.N. lifted its arms embargo last October despite Iran’s repeated violations of its import restrictions and export prohibitions. Heritage expert: Jim Phillips
Texas G.O.P. Passes Election Bill – Texas has passed a bill that enfranchises voters and protects their ballots, and any claims that Texas is making it harder to vote are complete nonsense. The state now gives voters the ability to correct defects in their absentee ballots to avoid rejection. It improves security by extending the state’s in-person ID requirement to absentee ballots but makes it extremely easy to comply with. Information on citizenship from jury verification and other state databases will now be available to protect the ballots of Texas voters. Heritage expert: Hans von Spakovsky
CDC Should Revise Its Guidance Mandating Masks at School – Like its erstwhile guidance on spacing desks in classrooms, the CDC’s ill-founded edict on student mask mandates complicates school openings. Parents who assume the agency’s guidance is well-grounded in science clash with those who object to mandates. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention created this controversy. It should help quell it. Accurately reporting its own finding that there is no statistically significant difference between voluntary and mandatory masking of schoolchildren would be a good start. The CDC should communicate this point clearly and emphatically and revise its guidance accordingly. Some parents still may insist that their children attend only schools that require students to wear masks. But more honest communication by the CDC would clarify that this is a clash over parental preferences, not over science. States should honor these preferences by allowing parents to exercise school choice options if they disagree with their local public school’s policies on masks, finding them to be either too lax or too rigid. Following the lead of states such as Florida and Arizona, parents should be able to take their child’s share of per-pupil funding to a learning environment that reflects their health and education needs. Heritage expert: Doug Badger