No images? Click here [link removed]

Afghans gather on a roadside near the military part of the airport in Kabul on August 20, 2021, hoping to flee from the country after the Taliban's military takeover of Afghanistan. (Wakil Kohsar/AFP via Getty Images)

The U.S. military's abrupt withdrawal from Afghanistan has produced one of the gravest humanitarian and geostrategic catastrophes in the history of American foreign policy.

This is a gift not only to the Taliban, but to America's strategic adversaries and terrorist organizations like al-Qaeda. Beyond the immediate crisis as thousands of Americans and Afghan partners struggle to escape the country, how will the Taliban's takeover and likely reestablishment of Afghanistan as a terrorist safe haven impact global security?

Hudson experts have been sounding the alarm on the devastating ramifications of the Taliban takeover, including former National Security Adviser and Lieutenant General (ret) H.R. McMaster [[link removed]], Pakistan's former Ambassador to the U.S. Husain Haqqani [[link removed]], former Treasury Assistant Secretary Marshall Billingslea [[link removed]], and Ravenel B. Curry III Distinguished Fellow in Strategy and Statesmanship Walter Russell Mead [[link removed]].

Read key quotes below, and join us next week for a discussion [[link removed]] with Lt. Gen. McMaster, Robert Greenway, Ambassador Haqqani, and former Deputy National Security Adviser Dr. Nadia Schadlow [[link removed]] on how the U.S. can prevent further calamity in Afghanistan and repair the strategic damage that has been done.

Hudson Experts Weigh In on Afghanistan

1. Afghanistan's Humanitarian Catastrophe Will Embolden Terrorists and US Adversaries:

H.R. McMaster in the Wall Street Journal: In Washington, leaders described the jihadist threat as having moved on from Afghanistan. But the Afghanistan-Pakistan region remains an epicenter for terrorism. More than 20 U.S.-designated terrorist organizations call the region home, and many remain determined to murder Americans and our allies.

Self-styled strategists still rationalize the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan as necessary to focus on China and great-power competition. But the refusal to provide the Afghan people the support necessary to stem a humanitarian catastrophe emboldens China, Russia and other adversaries eager to proclaim the U.S. an unreliable partner and a declining power.

Read More [[link removed]]

2. Pakistan's Support of the Taliban Remains Misunderstood by US Policymakers:

Husain Haqqani in the Wall Street Journal: Pakistan’s military dictator, Gen. Pervez Musharraf, helped to arrest many al-Qaeda figures, but as he later admitted, he also continued to support the Taliban, to hedge against Indian influence in Afghanistan after an eventual U.S. withdrawal. Musharraf expected the U.S. to leave within a couple of years and was instrumental in helping the Taliban attack foreign forces in Afghanistan to expedite their departure. By 2006, American officials started speaking of a Pakistani “double game” and tried using aid and diplomatic bullying to end it, but they never recognized that Pakistan’s policy was shaped by its insecurities about India, and thus was unmoved by those strategies.

Read More [[link removed]]

3. America's Indo-Pacific Alliances Are at Risk:

Walter Russell Mead in the Wall Street Journal: Nothing is more vain than the hope that somehow this debacle will help the U.S. in the Indo-Pacific.

For more than 70 years India, whose massive population and economy make it a linchpin of any American strategy in Asia, has seen the world through the lens of its competition with Pakistan. Now, as Islamabad cements its ties with Beijing, the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan hands Pakistan a strategic victory and strengthens the most radical anti-Indian and anti-Western forces in its government. Few in New Delhi will perceive this catastrophe as a sign of Washington’s competence or reliability. If a third-tier country like Pakistan can tie the U.S. in knots, Indians will ask: What chance does Washington have against China?

Read More [[link removed]]

4. Chinese Influence in Pakistan Will Increase:

Husain Haqqani in Foreign Affairs: Pakistani officials have, over the years, chosen to flatly deny Pakistani actions in Afghanistan [supporting the Taliban] or to explain them away. This has led to charges of double-dealing from the Americans, spurring further mistrust in the bilateral relationship.

Relations with India and the rest of the world have also suffered, and Pakistan has come to depend excessively on China. Of its $90 billion in external debt, Pakistan owes 27 percent—or more than $24 billion—to Beijing. It has also been forced to rely on lower-quality Chinese military technology after losing U.S. military assistance.

Read More [[link removed]]

5. Future Generations Will Pay for Biden's Strategic Blunder:

Senior Fellow Marshall Billingslea on Hudson's podcast Making a Killing: The abdication of responsibility in Afghanistan by the Biden-Harris administration has led to the establishment of an Islamic emirate that is the size of Texas, has as many resources as ISIS had at its at its height, and has the potential to greatly expand its ability to export Islamic jihadism around the world.

The recalibration [to Asia] cannot happen in full as we'll now have to continue investing far greater resources into the counterterrorism fight. We're entering a phase where we will see a resurgence of al-Qaeda and their ability to conduct worldwide terror attacks. We're entering a very, very, dark period. Our children and likely now our grandchildren will be coping with this.

Listen to the Podcast [[link removed]]

Quotes have been edited for length and clarity.

Go Deeper

Counterbalance | Ep. 24: Afghanistan, What Just Happened? [[link removed]]

Dr. Thomas Lynch, a distinguished research fellow at the National Defense University and a retired army officer with extensive experience in Afghanistan, joined Mike Doran [[link removed]] and Marshall Kosloff [[link removed]] on Counterbalance [[link removed]] to discuss the chaotic American withdrawal from that country and the swift return of the Taliban. Dr. Lynch attributes the disaster to a number of multilayered mistakes made over the course of many years.

Listen [[link removed]]

A Taliban Victory Is Not Going To Be a Local Matter [[link removed]]

There is little doubt that the precipitous withdrawal of American forces from Afghanistan has enabled a terrorist safe haven to reemerge. In an interview with CNN' [[link removed]]s Christiane Amanpour, Husain Haqqani [[link removed]] outlined the Taliban's enduring ties to al-Qaeda and the growing risks of a global jihadist movement based in Afghanistan.

Watch [[link removed]]

The Taliban Takeover of Afghanistan Should Not Have Come as a Surprise [[link removed]]

Wars don't end when only one party disengages, argues H. R. McMaster [[link removed]] in an interview with Savannah Guthrie on The Today Show [[link removed]]. While the last few administrations have focused on a military drawdown in Afghanistan, U.S. presidents should have communicated to the public the worthy aim of denying jihadist terrorists a safe haven and base to conduct attacks on the scale of 9/11.

Watch [[link removed]] [[link removed]] Share [link removed] Tweet [link removed] Forward [link removed] Hudson Institute

1201 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Fourth Floor

Washington, D.C. 20004 Preferences [link removed] | Unsubscribe [link removed]