FACT CHECK French Ambassador did not leave Kabul, contrary to Peston tweet
As the Taliban advanced towards Kabul on Sunday, the French ambassador in Afghanistan David Martinon tweeted a video of himself in a helicopter saying he was leaving the Afghan capital’s former “green zone”, which houses a number of embassies.
But journalist Robert Peston and an article in the MailOnline claimed that the ambassador had left Kabul entirely. This is false.
We asked the French embassy in the UK if Mr Martinon was still in Kabul. A spokesperson directed us towards a tweet sent by Mr Martinon on Monday, saying the embassy had just relocated to Kabul airport.
At the time this newsletter was sent, Mr Peston had not clarified or deleted his tweet.
Friend, our press must do better to give us good information when we need it most.
For independent fact checkers like us, it’s your support that keeps us able to scrutinise what’s been said online, and make sure there is the evidence to back it up.
When public debate is angry and divided, bad reporting affects us all. Supporters this year have helped us scrutinise and challenge hundreds of false headlines and reports, to make sure millions of people can access the truth.
But in order to make sure our press gives us the accuracy we deserve, we need a lot more people to join our fight against bad information.
Can you make a real difference and support independent fact checking today? It only takes 2 minutes.
“DEADLY BUG Coronavirus lockdown could last 18 MONTHS as government says 260,000 would die without drastic measures,” read one early Sun headline, published in March 2020.
“Britain's death toll 'could hit 85,000 in second Covid wave,” claimed the Telegraph months later in October.
Faced with an overwhelming amount of new information, not to mention the very real anxieties generated by a global pandemic, it’s not a surprise that scientific modelling on death tolls, infection rates and vaccination benefits all became the subject of intense scrutiny and speculation.
As the outputs of these models became public we started to see headlines that relayed them in extremely precise terms, in a similar way to the presentation of weather forecasts.
But what exactly are models, and how has the reporting of these incredibly complicated calculations affected the way we understand the pandemic?
We spoke to some of the nation’s leading experts to hear what they had to say.
We all deserve information we can trust, especially when making important decisions about our health.
For pregnant women and their families, this has been an especially worrying time. Vaccine uptake among pregnant women has been lower than other groups and the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists highlight that there has recently been a rise in the number of pregnant women hospitalised with Covid-19.
Pregnant Then Screwed, a charity which campaigns for the rights of pregnant women and mothers, recently ran a survey which highlighted the fear and confusion arising from misinformation and conflicting health advice.
That’s why Full Fact and Pregnant Then Screwed are working together on a new WhatsApp helpline service. From today, pregnant women and their families will be able to request fact checks directly from Full Fact.
An article on the Conservative Woman website reports on “five key Covid truths” sourced to a Texas-based cardiologist. It asserts “he has all the necessary scientific back-up to support his claims.” But he doesn’t.
Dr Peter McCullough, the cardiologist in question, claims the virus is not spread asymptomatically, and can only be spread by sick people. But the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies notes that asymptomatic individuals can transmit the virus, albeit to a lesser extent than people who have symptoms.
Dr McCullough’s statement also doesn’t acknowledge the role pre-symptomatic people play in transmission. That is, people who are not “sick” at the time, but are infected and do go on to develop symptoms in the future.
A meta-analysis on the topic last year estimated that between 46% and 69% of ‘symptomatic’ cases were transmitted by people who were pre-symptomatic at the time.
The other four “key Covid truths” are also false or misleading. We’ve fact checked them all.
