March 30, 2021
Dear Boston Elections Commission,
Your commission is entrusted with the indispensable purpose of ensuring electoral integrity. You have no higher responsibility than guaranteeing that the voice of each Boston voter is heard.
I am writing concerning a grave circumstance that has transpired on your watch. In an unfathomable way, the votes of 84.8% of Boston voters were not counted. Specifically, 224 of 264 Boston voters were disenfranchised. Nothing like this should happen in America, never mind in the birthplace of our democracy.
As established by the just-completed recount, at the time of the March 3, 2020, election for Republican State Committee Woman in the Second Suffolk District, each of 264 Boston voters exercised their right to cast a write-in or sticker vote for the candidate of their choice. Appallingly, only 40 of those votes would be counted. The magnitude of the failure of the City of Boston in such regard cannot be overstated; because of the disenfranchisement of 84.8 percent of those voters, none of the candidates would receive enough votes to make the ballot.
Notably, the City originally certified that, in addition to the 40 votes for the candidates, there had been 217 votes for "all others," as well as 646 blanks. The number of uncounted votes in that election - 224 - thus exceeded the number of votes for "all others."
There is no reason to conclude that the City did any better counting write-in votes in September, 2020, than it had in March, 2020. In the September election, write-in candidate Rayla Campbell obtained more than ten times the number of votes in Boston as did her opponent. Ms. Campbell would be certified as receiving 1,202 votes total in the district, purportedly finishing 898 votes short of the 2,000 needed to gain a spot on the general election ballot.
As noted, in the March election 217 votes were certified as being cast for "all others," whereas a number greater than that had been cast for the candidates. In the September election, 1,279 Boston votes were certified as being cast for all others. Even if only that number had been cast for the candidates and even if Ms. Campbell received only 90% of those votes (of the Boston votes that were certified, Ms. Campbell would receive 568 of 618, or 91.9%), she would have finished with 1,151 more votes than the 1,202 which were certified, easily making the ballot.
Hence, had the disenfranchisement of March, 2020, remained unmitigated in September, it would have cost Rayla Campbell a place on the general election ballot. That manner of result is exactly what this commission exists to prevent.
Among the first casualties of compromise of election integrity is the impairment of faith in our system. It is your job to restore that faith. It is also your job to find the truth. In both such regards, the ballots from both the March and September, 2020, elections should be preserved so as to facilitate analysis as to the above-described voter disenfranchisement. As Chairman of the Massachusetts Republican Party, I respectfully demand that you do so.
Very Truly Yours,
