Investigative journalism can right wrongs, unearth information and expose corruption. In the latest project from a collaboration of newsrooms and organizations, it also reveals broken systems.
Last week, the Indigenous Investigative Collective published an investigation that shed light on what we know and don’t know about the number of Indigenous people who’ve died because of the coronavirus. They report:
In an effort to come up with a more reliable fatality count, reporters with the Indigenous Investigative Collective (IIC) made multiple public-records requests for death records held by state medical examiners of Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona and Utah. Those requests focused on the counties on or adjacent to the Navajo Nation where many Navajo families live. The states rejected those requests, citing privacy concerns, preventing independent analysis of those records to determine death rates. Experts also cite pervasive misidentification of race and ethnicity of victims at critical data collection points, making the true toll of the pandemic on the Navajo Nation impossible to ever know.
The Native American Journalists Association created the IIC to help amplify the coverage, voices and work of Native American journalists. “A broken system” includes work from journalists at High Country News, Indian Country Today, National Native News and Searchlight New Mexico, in partnership with MuckRock.
The work of accounting for fatalities started in individual newsrooms, where reporters were asking similar questions, said Christine Trudeau, a contributing editor at High Country News.
“Interviews just didn’t match up with what was reported a lot of the time,” she said.
Sunnie Clahchischiligi, an investigative reporter with Searchlight New Mexico, knew that, too, from reporting and personal experience.
The team started meeting weekly and was able to pool resources and skills while navigating cultural issues and a maze of systems.
“Something people don’t understand sometimes is how different it is to do reporting in Indian country,” Clahchischiligi said. “We understand how to be respectful in that sense and how to handle those kinds of things with care. It’s a challenge, but also, we were the right group to meet that challenge.”
Working with IIC harnessed the skills of Indigenous reporters and newsrooms already covering their communities, and it showed what can happen when newsrooms collaborate, said Jourdan Bennett-Begaye, managing editor at Indian Country Today.
“There’s so many Native reporters in mainstream and tribal media and intertribal independent media doing such great work and they have all their skills and resources and expertise,” she said. “We’re always looking at the same stories, but actually bringing all those together is really a neat way to collaborate. I think it’s really powerful to see that we’re all striving for the same thing.”
The IIC is already working on its next collaboration, she said. And its value isn’t just in the work, but in the people making it.
“I think that this is really showing that the importance of having Indigenous investigative journalists working on anything in any newsroom is just absolutely essential to reporting on America,” Trudeau said.
|