Poynter

The list analyzes the past year’s work of the Teen Fact-Checking Network

•

In this edition you will find:

•

Teen Fact-Checking Network analyzes the past year in misinformation

•

AFP reverses the polarity on a hoax about magnets

•

Graphika report details disinformation network

Teens’ Top 5

Photo courtesy of MediaWise

The MediaWise Teen Fact-Checking Network, a team of teenagers that use social media to debunk viral claims, recently concluded a 30-part fact-checking series on YouTube. The series, “Is This Legit?,” got started through a fact-checking development grant from the IFCN and was supported by YouTube as part of the Google News Initiative.

Billed as “for teens, by teens,” the media literacy YouTube series covered a little bit of everything — politics, pop culture, conspiracy theories and, of course, COVID-19. Looking back at the work from the TFCN from the past year, which involved fact-checking on a variety of platforms, here are five of the biggest misinformation trends tackled by students in the program.

1. How dangerous is COVID-19, really?
Claims questioning the severity of the coronavirus were a regular occurrence on students’ timelines. The TFCN debunked misinformation regarding the virus's mortality rate, as well as false claims comparing the virus to the common flu.

2. Cures that … aren’t really cures
In addition to debunking viral remedies, like injecting bleach or the use of hydroxychloroquine, students also debunked claims being spread on more teen-dominated platforms, like the claim that smoking weed can kill the coronavirus or that vaping is a good preventative measure. (Both not legit.)

3. “COVID-19 tests are dangerous”
COVID-19 conspiracy theories took over teens’ timelines, with many claims targeting the safety of the coronavirus test itself. Teen fact-checkers debunked the viral claim that getting tested for the coronavirus would actually give you the virus, and recently took on the claim that the tests contain nanoparticles that enter your brain and allow you to be tracked.

4. The “Big Lie” and Jan. 6 insurrection
Over the course of 2020, MediaWise Teen Fact-Checkers debunked countless claims about the integrity of the U.S. presidential election. What became known as the “Big Lie,” social media posts claiming the election was rigged started early with misinformation going viral about the safety of mail-in voting. As misinformation continued to escalate, MediaWise teenagers flagged multiple claims about the storming of the U.S. Capitol that went viral on YouTube.

5. Social justice issues
Following the murder of George Floyd, teenagers were exposed to hundreds of viral claims on social media about the resulting protests against police brutality. Teen fact-checkers debunked multiple claims, including the false claim that a “mall train” driving through protests was stolen, and that a children’s hospital was set on fire by protesters.

MediaWise will continue the “Is This Legit?” YouTube series, and is currently accepting applications from teenagers for the program’s summer session. The deadline to apply is May 31.

For college-aged students interested in media literacy, the MediaWise Campus Correspondents project is back for another year. Campus correspondents will learn how to spot misinformation online, then train their peers on these important skills during virtual trainings at schools across the country. Campus correspondents also produce a range of social media content and are paid per training. The deadline to apply is May 31.

— Alexa Volland, TFCN editor

Interesting fact checks

Screenshot by AFP of Instagram post

•

Agence France-Presse "Covid-19 vaccines do not contain magnetic microchips" (in English)

•

In debunking the latest iteration of the “secret microchip” conspiracy, AFP pointed to public information about the various vaccines to show that none of them contain metallic ingredients. It also noted that the amount of metallic material needed to make a household magnet stick is much greater than the standard syringe could hold.

•

Dubawa "Photos of unmarked helicopters purportedly flying over Maiduguri forests from the US, not Nigeria" (in English)

•

A Twitter thread used photos of unmarked helicopters to bolster a false claim that the French government was supporting rebel groups in an attempt to overthrow the Nigerian government. Dubawa used reverse image search to find these photos were taken from three separate news articles about low-flying helicopters in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Medina County, Ohio; and Charleston, South Carolina.

•

NOTE: Last week’s newsletter had a bad link for Lead Stories’ fact check about a fake gas station sign. We apologize for the mistake and you can read the fact check here.

Quick hits

AP Photo/Andy Wong, File

From the news:

•

"Chinese businessman with links to Steve Bannon is driving force for a sprawling disinformation network, researchers say," from The Washington Post. A report by research firm Graphika detailed the myriad ways the network linked to exiled Chinese businessman Guo Wengui pushed out disinformation about COVID-19, the 2020 election, and critics of the Chinese Communist Party.

•

"Fact-checking Modi’s India," from Rest of World. This looks at the ways associates and supporters of the Modi government have used falsehoods to gain political power, and the efforts of fact-checking organization Alt News to fight back.

•

"The disinformation threat from text-generating AI," from Axios. A report by the Center for Security and Emerging Technology looks at the ways artificial intelligence could be used to generate human-like text message conversations for use in disinformation campaigns.

From/for the community:

•

"NBC spotlights MediaWise’s efforts to arm the public against misinformation," from Poynter. The impact of media literacy training was on full display last week as NBC News’ Savannah Sellers and Lester Holt shined a spotlight on the Teen Fact-Checking Network and MediaWise for Seniors.

•

"Disinformation about COVID-19 in Brazillian social media,” from MIDIARS Laboratory. This report looks at the ways political polarization led to the proliferation of COVID-19 falsehoods in Brazil and worsened the country’s efforts to fight the pandemic.

•

"The Arrival of Jewish Refugees in Palestine": How Historical Photographs Are Used to Fuel Conflict," from Factcheck.kz After seeing several examples of a 1947 photo of the Jewish refugee ship Theodor Herzl being used to equate Israeli treatment of Palestinians to the British treatment of Jewish refugees, Factcheck.kz offered this explainer to put both situations in context.

If you are a fact-checker and you’d like your work/projects/achievements highlighted in the next edition, send us an email at [email protected] by next Tuesday.

Any corrections? Tips? We’d love to hear from you: [email protected].

Thanks for reading Factually, and a special thanks to Alexa for joining us this week.

Harrison Mantas
Reporter, IFCN
@HarrisonMantas

The Craig Newmark Center For Ethics and Leadership

© All rights reserved Poynter Institute 2021
801 Third Street South, St. Petersburg, FL 33701

If you don't want to receive email updates from Poynter, we understand.
You can update your subscription preferences here or unsubscribe.