In this week's Action Update, we breakdown the implications (or lack
thereof) of the Biden administration's decision to re-engage the UN
Human Rights Council. We also break down the implications (or lack
thereof) of the International Criminal Court's decision that they can
sit in judgement of Israel. Finally, we'll give an update on the Biden
team's announcement concerning sanctions relief and the Iran nuclear
accord.
He Who is Without Sin
Pardon us if you've heard this before, but the US has decided to
re-engage with the UN Human Rights Council (HRC) as an observer.
As a reminder, the HRC has several "agenda items," and only one
country is given the high honor of having an agenda item all to
themselves: Israel. In addition, it's worth recalling that despite the
astounding volume of real and gross human rights violations around the
world, Israel has been condemned by this body exponentially more times
than any other country. Finally, the HRC's 47 member states currently
include such paragons of virtue as China, Libya, Pakistan, Russia, and
Venezuela.
Given that past remains prologue, we're going to depart from our
regularly scheduled programing and offer predictions:
First, team Biden will seek to try to change the UN HRC's appalling
anti-Israel bias. While the desire to do so is admirable, it will
unfortunately fail as have successive administrations before.
Second, the HRC will continue to single out Israel for unfair
condemnation and parrot the talking points of Israel's most disgusting
detractors. At the same time, the HRC will continue to gloss over and in
some cases help instigate some of the worst human rights abuses on
earth.
Finally, eventually an American administration will look at the HRC's
record, realize they are a corrupt entity that no amount of engagement
will ever reform, and remove the US from this den of duplicity and
hypocrisy. Rinse, repeat.Â
He Who is Without Jurisdiction
The International Criminal Court (ICC), to which Israel is not a member
state, has decided that it has jurisdiction to sit in judgement of
Israel's actions to defend themselves against Palestinian terror.
Understandably, several ICC member states, namely Germany, Austria, the
Czech Republic, Australia, Brazil, and Uganda, opposed the ICC's
controversial decision. The Biden administration, through the State
Department, noted that it had "serious concerns" about the ICC's
pre-trial decision and re-emphasized that "The United States has
always taken the position that the court's jurisdiction should be
reserved for countries that consent to it."
It should be noted that last year 69 Senators sent a letter to the Trump
administration calling the ICC's focus on Israel "dangerous" and
that "the US should stand in full force against any biased
investigation of Israel." Then Senator, and now Vice President, Kamala
Harris was one of the signatories. While administrations have changed,
we urge the Biden administration to continue to stand against the
ICC's unjust and illegitimate focus on Israel.Â
At this point, while Israel has reacted strongly to the decision, there
is no investigation yet in place. Moreover, the consequences of such an
investigation, which would likely take years, are not likely to have a
tangible impact on Israel - though some Israeli military leaders might
find their international travel options limited. The truth is that this
is yet another attempt by Israel-haters to delegitimize the very
existence of the state of Israel. If Jerusalem's defense of its
citizens from terrorism is deemed illegitimate by the international
court, this is another talking point for those who wish Israel to be
wiped off the map.
That said, as we've seen with various other efforts by international
institutions to jump on the 'we hate Israel' bandwagon, the most
predictable outcome of this charade is that the ICC's own legitimacy,
already hampered by the same type of mismanagement we've come to
expect similarly illustrious international bodies, will take yet another
blow. Despite the hopes of anti-Semites around the world, a handful of
judges in Europe will not stop Israel from defending its citizens.
He Who is not to be Trusted (Ever)
Over the weekend, President Biden said that his administration would not
lift sanctions against Iran until the Iranians comply with the Iran
nuclear accord. This is an important and welcome announcement. We
don't think much of 2015 Iran nuclear deal, but we think even less of
any proposal that would enable Iran to receive sanctions relief by
continuing to destabilize the Middle East.
In recent weeks we've discussed the disconnect between statements made
by the Biden administration's top officials (including the President
himself) that advocate a "longer and stronger" agreement with Iran,
and the decision to appoint serial appeaser Robert Malley as US envoy to
the Islamic Republic. Hopefully, this latest statement from the
President indicates that a stronger approach to Iran is in the making.
In related news, just a few days ago UN inspectors discovered more
evidence of undeclared Iranian nuclear activities at two sites recently
visited by the International Atomic Energy Agency. The type of
radioactive material the inspectors found potentially indicates nuclear
weapons development took place at the sites in question.
We didn't need more evidence that Iran has never been in compliance
with the nuclear accord, but we hope this latest development makes the
Biden administration rethink reentering the failed 2015 nuclear accord
as is but instead brings Iran to the negotiating table to discuss a
longer, stronger and comprehensive agreement with Tehran.
We know we threw a lot at you this week, but as always, we thank you for
taking the time to stay up to date on the most important issues facing
Israel and the Middle East. Next week we'll be back with, among other
items, an in-depth look at a key Biden administration nominee you may
not yet have heard of.
Sincerely,
CUFI Action Fund Team
SUPPORT CUFI ACTION FUND
_________________
Sent to
[email protected]
Unsubscribe:
[link removed]
CUFI Action Fund, 300 Independence Ave SE, Washington, DC 20003, United States