The nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court on Saturday launched a series of arguments related to her qualifications, her interpretation of the Constitution, and her religion—and intensified the ongoing dispute over whether it's appropriate for her to be nominated this close to the election in the first place. There are good-faith arguments to be made from different perspectives, but I suggest that we keep in mind who made the nomination and why. Donald Trump's view of justice has little to do with fitness for office, impartiality, or respect for precedent. It has everything to do with self-interest. He has said openly that he expects the presidential election will be settled in the Supreme Court. To that end, his goal is to install a justice he believes is partisan enough to decide in his favor, regardless of the facts or the law. By necessity and by tradition, the Supreme Court is the least political branch of government. We should endeavor to keep it that way. —Evan McMullin

Welcome to all of our new readers. We're glad you're here! Please help us spread the word about THE TOPLINE by sharing it here.
Shareable version

Is this why he's been hiding his taxes?

How much did you pay in federal income taxes in 2016? Donald Trump paid $750. He paid another $750 in his first year as president. He paid no income taxes at all in 10 of the previous 15 years—largely because he reported losing much more money than he made. Whether he's just a lousy businessman or exploited loopholes in the tax system generally unavailable to average Americans, there's a lot to be concerned about in Trump's taxes. No wonder he has fought so hard to keep the American people from seeing them.

MORE: O'Brien: Trump's taxes show he's a national security threat —Bloomberg

Cardillo: 'Tragically short' on national security

"While it is natural for there to be tension between the intelligence community and senior policymakers, President Donald Trump's decision to rely upon the word of dictators like Vladimir Putin is an unprecedented betrayal of his oath to the Constitution. Our current president bases his decisions on his instincts, and his instincts are based upon a personal value proposition—what's in it for me?" —The Denver Post

Ed. Note: Robert Cardillo retired as the director of the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency after 36 years of public service.

MORE: Trump's former Coast Guard chief: 'Our constitutional rights are being infringed upon' —The Hill

Amy Coney Barrett nominated for SCOTUS

Despite some late speculation that he might pick Barbara Lagoa, or a number of other Federalist Society-approved judges to fill the Supreme Court seat of the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg, President Trump went with the obvious choice—nominating Amy Coney Barrett during a Rose Garden event on Saturday.

MORE: Voters believe winner of election should fill court vacancy, poll shows —The New York Times

Russia knows him so well

Last week, President Trump publicly refused to commit to a peaceful transfer of power if he loses the November presidential election, and during a meeting with Republican attorneys general on Wednesday, he said the Supreme Court would likely decide the outcome of the election. He wasn't the first to make the prediction. Serendipitously, Russian state media publicly concluded that the Supreme Court—including Trump's nominee—would decide the outcome of the upcoming presidential election, three days before Trump made his ominous pronouncements. Always on message. —The Daily Beast

MORE: The Kremlin's plot against democracy: How Russia updated its 2016 playbook for 2020 —Foreign Affairs

SHARE TOPLINE ON TWITTER SHARE TOPLINE ON TWITTER

Wright: Unrest? Maybe. Color revolution? No

"The United States is not an autocracy, but Trump has embraced this paranoia. As [Alexander Cooley, the director of the Harriman Institute at Columbia University] noted, fears of unrest are borrowed from the Russian hymnbook: 'Fear of the street protests, never spontaneous, never motivated by a sense of injustice, activists always paid, always a nefarious agenda—it is straight from the Kremlin's talking points.' Accusing an opponent of what he is accusing you of—in this case, stealing the election—is a tactic [Russian President Vladimir] Putin routinely uses to muddy the waters." —The Atlantic

Ed. Note: Thomas Wright is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and the author of "All Measures Short of War: The Contest for the 21st Century and the Future of American Power."

MORE: Pelosi begins mustering Democrats for possible House decision on presidency —Politico

ICYMI: Quick takes from the weekend

If you were too busy with early autumn activities this weekend to check on the news, good for you. Here's a roundup of stories you may have missed...

Ridge: Vote for decency and rule of law

"With just about one month until Election Day, President Trump continues to claim the only way he can possibly be defeated is a rigged election. Can you imagine the hubris? Can you imagine any other president in our lifetime—or ever—saying something so dangerous and un-American? We are in the midst of a health crisis, when we should be doing all we can to help citizens vote safely, yet he continues to cast doubt on the sanctity of the vote." —The Philadelphia Inquirer

Ed. Note: Tom Ridge is a former Republican governor of Pennsylvania and the first U.S. secretary of Homeland Security.


MORE: Darby: 'It's the corruption, stupid' —The Montana Standard

A place to learn

James Ortega started his seventh-grade school year with a Zoom class from his bed in Gaithersburg, Md. He didn't have much of a choice—he didn't have a desk. Online learning is challenging enough for everyone, but not having a dedicated workspace makes it even harder to be focused and organized. Fortunately, James and his younger brother, Steven, got a special delivery a few days ago.

Ed. Note: Would you like to suggest "An American Story" from your local news? If so, please forward a link to the story to [email protected]. Thank you!

The United States is home to a little over 4% of the world's population. So far, it has seen more than 20% of all cases and deaths from COVID-19. A little math tells us that most of the world has weathered this pandemic five times better than the U.S., a country with arguably superior medical technology and expertise.

Why has our "great" country faired so poorly? Look around you, and you see people who don't just ignore, but defiantly reject the guidelines that experts have recommended to protect themselves from the spread of disease. Talk to these people, and they tell you that mask-wearing and social distancing don't help. Some even argue that they exacerbate the problem. These notions reflect the baseless disinformation being pushed on social media and even on network news.

So why do people favor wild conspiracy theories over expert advice, even at such a cost? Mixed messages from top officials, which sometimes even agrees with the drivel being fed to the public by the likes of QAnon, have spawned a deep distrust in institutions like the CDC or WHO. Afraid, confused, and misled, people make poor choices over who to believe, and it is literally killing us. In the U.S., disinformation has become a worse epidemic than the novel coronavirus.

Our president has proven he stands behind any message that supports his intentions, baseless deceptions and conspiracy theories included. He would have us believe we should thank him for keeping the death toll in America at a "mere" 200,000+. I am compelled to oblige:

Thank you, Mr. President, for discrediting and sowing seeds of distrust in our governing institutions, inspiring so many to recklessly endanger themselves and others close to them. Perhaps someday those who remain will take that lesson to its extent, and learn to distrust you as well.

Spoiler alert: many of us already have. —Brian S., Illinois

The views expressed in "What's Your Take?" are submitted by readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial staff or the Stand Up Republic Foundation.

Got feedback about THE TOPLINE? Send it to Melissa Amour, Managing Editor, at [email protected].

Did you receive this email from a friend? Sign up at www.thetopline.com.
CARE ABOUT DEMOCRACY? SHARE SOME DEMOCRACY.

If you love THE TOPLINE, share it with your friends and reap the rewards—from a shoutout in an issue of TL, to exclusive swag, to a call with Evan and Mindy.

Your Dashboard has everything you need to easily share THE TOPLINE
and track your progress.
VISIT YOUR DASHBOARD NOW
TO GET STARTED!
The Topline is a project of the Stand Up Republic Foundation.
 
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

700 Pennsylvania Ave SE · Washington, DC 20003-2493 · USA