Explore Today's Market News from Behind the Markets:

Kroger cut its sales forecast by two-thirds. The stock closed up 2.7%.

Kroger told investors on Friday morning that American shoppers are buying less than it expected, and then watched its stock finish the day as one of the better performers in the S&P 500.

The grocer reported results for its fiscal second quarter, which ended August 15, and the headline number was the one management could not spin. Identical sales excluding fuel — the industry's core measure of whether existing stores are selling more — rose 0.2%. A year ago, the same figure was 3.4%. Kroger had told Wall Street in June to expect 1.0% to 2.0% for the full year. On Friday it cut that range to 0.2% to 0.8%.

Shares opened lower on the news, fell as much as 1.95% in premarket trading to $55.27, and then reversed. Kroger closed at $58.49, up $1.54 or 2.70%, with 11.6 million shares changing hands.

What the market chose to look at instead

The sales line was weak. Almost everything below it was not.

• Adjusted earnings per share of $1.09 beat the $1.06 consensus. On a GAAP basis, EPS was $1.05 versus $0.91 a year earlier.
• Revenue of $34.6 billion rose from $33.9 billion a year ago, narrowly missing the $34.65 billion estimate.
• Operating profit was $971 million; adjusted FIFO operating profit came in at $1.076 billion.
• Gross margin was 22.4% of sales, with management citing higher shrink, higher transportation costs and a richer mix of lower-margin sales, partly offset by pharmacy mix, sourcing initiatives, tariff refunds and a smaller LIFO charge.
• Adjusted eCommerce sales grew 20%, and profit at Kroger Precision Marketing, the company's retail advertising arm, grew 24%.
• Kroger repurchased $1.0 billion of stock during the quarter, after raising its dividend earlier in the summer.

Most important for the reaction: Kroger left its full-year adjusted EPS guidance untouched at $5.10 to $5.30, held adjusted FIFO operating profit at $5.0 to $5.2 billion, free cash flow at $2.7 to $2.9 billion, capital expenditures at $3.8 to $4.0 billion, and its tax rate at 23%. The company cut the sales forecast and reaffirmed the profit forecast in the same press release.

"Our second quarter results demonstrate the resiliency of Kroger's business model and the discipline with which our teams are executing," said chief financial officer David Kennerley. "Adjusted earnings per diluted share grew 5%, driven by cost savings, strong pharmacy and fuel performance, and improvement in the profitability of our eCommerce business."

The asterisks on that 0.2%

Two items inside the quarter were not about consumer demand at all. Kroger said Medicare drug-pricing changes under the Inflation Reduction Act created roughly a 138-basis-point headwind to identical sales — a pharmacy revenue effect, not a lost customer. It also said the lingering effects of a cyclospora outbreak in its produce department cut identical sales excluding fuel by about 35 basis points.

Strip both out and the underlying number looks materially better than 0.2%. That is the argument the buyers made on Friday. The argument on the other side is simpler: the company still could not hold its own full-year sales range, and it had only set that range in June.

Investors have been unusually willing to punish good operating results this year, which makes Friday's reaction the more interesting data point. It was the opposite of the pattern that hit Adobe this week, where a tripling AI business sat under a stock still far below its high — and a reminder that the market's reaction function is rarely as mechanical as the investors who chase headlines assume.

Kroger entered Friday roughly 2% above its 52-week low of $54.15 and trading at a price-to-earnings ratio of about 34.7 — a premium multiple for a grocer. The 52-week high is $76.58. Wall Street's mean price target sits near $69.77, from a group split roughly 11 buy ratings to 13 holds.

The consumer number nobody wanted to see

Ninety minutes after Kroger's release, the University of Michigan published its preliminary September consumer survey, and it was worse than the grocery data implied.

The headline sentiment index fell to 47.8 from 51.7 in August, against a consensus of 51.0. That is a 7.5% monthly decline, 13.2% below a year ago, and the second-lowest reading in the survey's history going back to 1952. The low came in May.

The damage was concentrated in what consumers expect rather than what they are experiencing. Current conditions slipped to 50.9 from 51.9, a 1.9% decline. Expectations collapsed to 45.8 from 51.5, down 11.1% in a month.

Inflation expectations moved the wrong way at the same time. The one-year outlook jumped to 4.6% from 4.0%, matching June's level as the highest of the cycle. Before the U.S.-led war with Iran began, that figure was 3.4% in February. Five-year expectations ticked up to 3.4% from 3.3%, ending three straight months at 3.3%.

"Year-ahead expectations for both personal finances and business conditions plunged," said Joanne Hsu, director of the Surveys of Consumers. "With a resurgence in fuel prices and trade tensions, consumers anticipate greater pressures on their pocketbooks to come."

Sentiment fell among consumers identifying as Democrats and Republicans alike, and was little changed among independents. Kroger cut its sales outlook citing slower consumer spending; the Michigan survey supplies the reason why.

The inflation print underneath all of it

Friday began with the August consumer price index. Headline CPI rose 0.4% for the month and 3.4% over twelve months, both matching the Dow Jones consensus. Core CPI, which strips out food and energy, rose 0.3% — a tenth of a point above forecast, and above the 0.2% median in Bloomberg's survey. The core annual rate was 2.4%, in line.

Traders read the core miss as decisive. Odds of a quarter-point Federal Reserve rate increase at next week's meeting jumped to roughly 86%, from 72% on Thursday and about 67% before the data, according to CME Group's FedWatch tool.

"Overall, the report clears the path for the FOMC to hike next week — a move that we expect will be followed by at least an additional quarter-point by year end," wrote Ian Lyngen, head of U.S. rates at BMO Capital Markets.

"This means the Fed should go with hiking rates next week and the yield curve, swaps and fed fund futures are all confirming the same," said Darrell Cronk, chief investment officer for wealth and