Forwarded this email? Subscribe here
[[link removed]]
for more

[ACT For America]
[[link removed]]


[Share]
[FB]
[[link removed]]
[TW]
[[link removed]]
[IN]
[[link removed]]
[LI]
[[link removed]]
[YT]
[[link removed]]
[RU]
[[link removed]]
[CO]
[[link removed]]
[Browser]
[[link removed]]

The Uncomfortable Truth About Islam
Islam is the only major religion on earth that claims the right to
govern people who never chose it.

By: A.C. Rosenthal
[[link removed]]

I am going to say plainly what almost no one in public life will say:
Islam is the only major religion on earth that claims the right to
govern people who never chose it.

This is not fringe opinion or “Islamophobia.” IT IS THE
MAINSTREAM, DOCUMENTED POSITION OF CLASSICAL ISLAMIC JURISPRUDENCE FOR
MORE THAN A THOUSAND YEARS. The tradition’s greatest scholars —
Al-Shafi’i, Al-Suyuti, Ibn Kathir — said it in Arabic, wrote it in
their legal texts, and built an entire system of law around it. That
architecture still governs the major schools of Sunni and Shia fiqh
today.

They divide the world into Dar al-Islam (the house of Islam) and Dar
al-Harb (the house of war). The legal obligation to bring the second
into the first never expires. It spells out the special tax
non-Muslims must pay (jizya), the restrictions they must accept, the
legal inferiority they must endure, and the conditions under which
they are permitted to keep living as non-Muslims. Classical Islamic
law also includes a death penalty for leaving the faith and explicitly
promises Paradise to those who die killing non-believers in jihad
(Quran 9:111).

I am not saying every Muslim believes or practices these things. Many
Muslims are good neighbors. The key distinction is
between _orthodox_ Muslims who take the full tradition seriously
and _cultural_ Muslims who inherited the identity without the
theology. The orthodox are, by Islamic standards, faithful Muslims. By
Western standards, they represent a genuine problem. The cultural
Muslim who quietly walks away after reading the actual sources is, by
Islamic standards, a bad Muslim. By Western standards, he is simply a
normal neighbor.

None of this is hidden in dusty manuscripts. It sits in plain Arabic
in the most widely studied commentaries and hadith collections. Yet
what THE WEST IS SOLD IS A CAREFULLY PACKAGED ISLAM FOR WESTERN
CONSUMPTION — A SOFT, WESTERNIZED, ACCEPTABLE VERSION THAT PUTS
PEOPLE AT EASE. We are shown only the earlier, abrogated Meccan
verses about tolerance and coexistence. The later, governing Medinan
verses — the ones that actually shaped Islamic law — are quietly
set aside. This sanitized presentation is not accidental. IT IS
PRECISELY THE VERSION ISLAMISTS COUNT ON: COMFORTING ENOUGH TO LOWER
DEFENSES, VAGUE ENOUGH TO AVOID SCRUTINY, AND EFFECTIVE ENOUGH TO
HASTEN THE DEMISE OF THE WEST BY DELAYING ANY SERIOUS RECKONING WITH
THE TRADITION’S REAL DEMANDS.

That brings us to abrogation (naskh). The Quran was revealed over
twenty-three years. The tolerant verses came first, when Muhammad was
powerless in Mecca. The commanding verses about warfare, subjugation,
and the terms for non-Muslims came later, after he had an army and a
state in Medina. The tradition is clear: the later verses supersede
the earlier ones. One single verse in Surah 9 cancelled more than a
hundred peaceful verses. The “peaceful Quran” quoted at interfaith
events is almost entirely the early, superseded material. The
governing Quran is the later material.

The paradise guarantee is equally direct. Surah 9:111 states that
Allah has “purchased” the believer’s life and property in
exchange for Paradise. The price is paid when the believer kills and
is killed in jihad. This is not cultural accretion. It is in the text
and the most authoritative hadith collections. It explains why reform
is structurally harder in Islam than in Christianity: the contract
cannot be renegotiated without dismantling the authority of the Quran
and the Prophet.

History records what happens when this system gains unchecked
political power. Every place now majority-Muslim was once
majority-Christian or other: Syria, Egypt, North Africa,
Constantinople. The Christian populations were not wiped out
overnight; they were steadily reduced by the legal, fiscal, and social
architecture the tradition itself designed. THE DIRECTION OF FLIGHT
HAS NEVER REVERSED. THERE IS NO COUNTER-EXAMPLE IN FOURTEEN CENTURIES.

The West keeps treating Islam as “a religion like any other.” It
is not. CHRISTIANITY, BUDDHISM, HINDUISM, AND JUDAISM DO NOT CONTAIN
A CLASSICAL LEGAL OBLIGATION TO GOVERN OUTSIDERS ON EXPLICITLY UNEQUAL
TERMS. ISLAM DOES.

Understanding this from the tradition’s own authoritative sources is
not Islamophobia. It is literacy. And in the world we actually live
in, literacy is no longer optional.

_This is a summarized version of a much longer essay. To read the full
article __CLICK HERE._
[[link removed]]

Dame Brigitte Gabriel | Bio
[[link removed]]
Chair & CEO _| __ACT For America
[[link removed]]_

 

[Contribute]
[[link removed]]


_ACT for America Education, a 501(c)(3) organization._
_All donations are tax-deductible._

1083 Independence Blvd, STE 806
Virginia Beach, VA 23455 USA

Contribute
[[link removed]]
| Charity Navigator
[[link removed]]
| Unsubscribe
[[link removed]]
 

[Share]
[FB]
[[link removed]]
[TW]
[[link removed]]
[IN]
[[link removed]]
[LI]
[[link removed]]
[YT]
[[link removed]]
[RU]
[[link removed]]
[CO]
[[link removed]]
[Browser]
[[link removed]]