[[link removed]]

PORTSIDE CULTURE

THE PITT CONTINUES TO SHINE A LIGHT ON THE HORRORS OF THE US
HEALTHCARE SYSTEM  
[[link removed]]


 

Adrian Horton
January 16, 2026
The Guardian
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ In its second season, the award-winning medical drama is a scarily
reflective show for the many Americans who watch it _

Noah Wyle in The Pitt., Photograph: Warrick Page/HBO Max

 

If you were stuck in the waiting room at the fictional Pittsburgh
trauma medical center (PTMC) – and, as is the case with most real
emergency rooms, to be at “the Pitt” almost certainly means
waiting for hours (unless you’re imminently dying, but even then
…) – you would at least have a lot to read. Paperwork and entry
forms, for one. Signs warning that “aggressive behavior will not be
tolerated”, a response to the real uptick in violence against
healthcare workers [[link removed]]. A memorial
plaque to the victims of the mass shooting at PittFest, which drenched
the back half of the acclaimed HBO Max show’s first season in
unbelievably harrowing, bloody, very American trauma. Labels on the
many homeopathic remedies carried, in Ziploc bags, by a prospective
patient deeply skeptical of western medicine and big pharma.
Promotional literature on the larger hospital system, for which The
Pitt is its cash-strapped, paint-stripped, constantly beleaguered
front door.

And, in its second season, which premiered earlier this month,
so-called “patient passports” that supposedly help you understand
the procedures and expected wait times at an urban emergency room. The
leaflets are the brainchild of Dr Baran Al-Hashimi (Sepideh Moafi),
the tech-affectionate, norms-challenging attending physician
introduced this season as a foil to the more by-the-books Dr Michael
“Robby” Robinavitch, the series anchor played by recent Golden
Globe winner Noah Wyle. Dr Robby, the show’s raison d’être and
the core of viewer sentiment, is skeptical of the patient passports,
as he seems to be of most change at the Pitt; their introduction is
one of many seeds planted in what will surely become a larger thematic
battle between tradition and innovation, emotion and rationality, old,
haunted attending physician and his upstart replacement.

But I took to the risible passports, as somewhat of a metaphor for why
the medical drama, with its jam-packed plots and real-time pacing and
occasional didacticism, feels somehow fresher in its second season
than its Emmy-winning first – as a viewer passport, of sorts, to the
combustible, confounding world of US healthcare. A window into a
constellation of work and care that is constantly in the news and yet
difficult to understand, beyond personal contact with a system that
will charge you an arm and a leg for even a brief visit.

The Pitt has rightly been heralded
[[link removed]]
as the most medically accurate drama ever developed for US television
(though the bar is low), a show that largely does not sacrifice
scientific realism for entertainment. Created by R Scott Gemmill and
executive produced by ER showrunner John Wells, The Pitt finally
cracked the code of a medical drama for the streaming era, seasoning
the old recipe of network TV procedural with HBO-standard nudity,
swearing and graphic detail; the recently aired second episode
included the syringe drainage of a (visible!) eight-hour erection, the
discovery of (real!) maggots living under an unhoused man’s cast and
the relocation of a protruding arm bone that I watched through my
fingers.

But the show earned its following less for the copious (and
convincing) fake blood than its attention to the mundane details and
challenges usually cut for time, with a wider scope of the healthcare
ecosystem than television usually allows – the traditionally
glorified doctors, of course, but also nurses, administrative staff,
custodians, EMS drivers and social workers. What other medical drama
has devoted time to explaining, with compassion, the process of
draining fluid from an alcoholic’s distended abdomen?

Even in such quiet moments, the Pitt simmers with combustible anxiety:
at any moment, something could go catastrophically awry, and it often
does. Such is the nature of procedural entertainment, which even when
striving for accuracy demands contrived stakes, juiced timelines and
routine drama. But the makers of The Pitt, which openly advertises
said accuracy, know that such also is the state of US healthcare, a
perilously tenuous system where individual heroism and systemic
cruelty exist side by side, whose inherent capriciousness has been
supercharged by the current administration.

The Pitt depicts realities of healthcare work that transcend
nationality – the psychological weight of caring for another person,
the routine presence of death – but it is, at its core, a show about
the United States, where healthcare remains a for-profit system. The
most medicalized country on Earth, which spends roughly twice per
capita on healthcare than comparable countries, while excluding
millions from it and suffering, across all income levels
[[link removed]],
from higher rates of disease and death. A country where tech companies
and ungodly wealthy CEOs like OpenAI’s Sam Altman pour money into
life-extension technology – some $12.5bn over the last 25 years
[[link removed]]
– while the vast majority of Americans cannot afford an ER visit. A
place where average life expectancy is shorter now than it was in
2010. A country facing an impending wave of hospital closures
[[link removed]]
in rural areas, and financial distress for urban “safety-net” ones
[[link removed]].
The Pitt’s second season premiered just as insurance premiums soared
[[link removed]]
for about 20 million people, following the Trump administration’s
decision to end federal subsidies. US patients and providers endure,
on a near daily basis, absolute chaos
[[link removed]],
with billions of critical funding – for mental healthcare, substance
use programs and more – now political footballs subject to swift
cancellation
[[link removed]].

All of this is largely outside the scope of The Pitt, which maintains
focus on the steadily dropping
[[link removed]]
bottom floor of the system (literally – the Pitt’s affectionate
moniker refers to its location in the basement of the larger hospital)
and primarily serves as agitprop for the healthcare profession. But it
very much informs the show’s overarching tension and larger project.
After playing Whac-A-Mole with US societal issues in season one –
state-level abortion restrictions, gun violence, medical racism and
anti-vaxxers, to name a few – season two has settled two looming,
long-term bogeymen: insurance and the rapid adoption of generative AI
[[link removed]]
in healthcare. The former, represented by Nurse Noelle Hastings (Meta
Golding), a case manager at PTMC who navigates the distinctly American
problem of finding patients a hospital that accepts their coverage;
the latter, by Dr Al-Hashimi, who is bullish on AI transcription
services’ potential to help with physician burnout
[[link removed]],
liberate them from documentation drudgery (the dreaded “charting”)
and provide more face time with patients. (Or, as Robby points out, a
reason for hospital administrators to demand doctors see even _more
_patients.)

There’s something cathartic about seeing a TV show even attempt to
address this colossal mess, ham-fisted as the AI conversation may feel
(to be fair, that’s how any AI conversation feels). Like most
Americans, I have friends and family in healthcare. I keep up with the
news. I stress about the costs of routine checkups, medications and
procedures, and endure the intentional frustration of insurance
claims. I care deeply about the availability and affordability of
healthcare in my country and about those who work in it. Yet there is
so much I do not understand, on every level. So much is infuriating.
It touches every facet of our lives – it is, literally, our lives
– and still remains largely invisible, seemingly impossible. So I
tune into The Pitt, as a passport to a million grittier and more
complicated daily realities, a safe window into a strained system
dressed up as entertainment. The simulation may be simplified,
turbo-charged, glossy, but the anxiety coursing through it is
hyper-real.

* the pitt
[[link removed]]
* HBO
[[link removed]]
* Healthcare
[[link removed]]
* health care industry
[[link removed]]
* doctors
[[link removed]]
* Residents physicians
[[link removed]]
* Nurses
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]
Manage subscription
[[link removed]]
Visit portside.org
[[link removed]]

Bluesky [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 



########################################################################

[link removed]

To unsubscribe from the xxxxxx list, click the following link:
[link removed]