[link removed]


** Daily Newsletter: DECEMBER 19, 2025
------------------------------------------------------------


** In today’s newsletter:
------------------------------------------------------------

PAUL P. MARIANI: Pope Leo’s China Dilemma ([link removed])

MILES SMITH: Restoring the Chaplain Corps’ Moral Backbone ([link removed])

PETER J. LEITHART: Liberalism Going in Circles ([link removed])

LIEL LEIBOVITZ: Just Stop It ([link removed])
[link removed]


** Pope Leo’s China Dilemma ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------


** Paul P. Mariani
------------------------------------------------------------

The Catholic Church in China is in an untenable position. The Vatican has tried appeasing the CCP by allowing the party to appoint bishops and not protesting when it cracks down on underground churches. Fr. Paul Mariani, S.J., who has traveled extensively in China, writes that the “appeasement policy is showing its limits.” Pope Leo needs to find a new way forward.

For further reading: Shortly before Pope Leo’s election, Nina Shea outlined the problems ([link removed]) with the current China policy and steps the next pope could take to restore justice and authority.
[link removed]


** Restoring the Chaplain Corps’ Moral Backbone ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------


** Miles Smith
------------------------------------------------------------

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth recently announced an overhaul of the military chaplain corps, which he says has become more about therapy and self-help than vigorous spiritual formation. Miles Smith writes that Hegseth, who belongs to a Reformed Protestant denomination that emphasizes the connection between Christianity and warfare, is “tossing nearly a century of fundamentalist evangelical spiritualism and mainline liberalism.” Good riddance.

For further reading: Smith also writes that Hegseth is not interested in denominational difference but rather a return to the Judeo-Christian mould that formed our nation. James A. Hamel, a Catholic priest and Air Force chaplain wrote about “Ecumenism in the Chaplaincy ([link removed]) " (2013): “Religious particularism, and especially Christian denominationalism, is generally not a wedge issue among the American warrior class. But is it a false kind of ecumenism, or worse yet, a form of syncretism proffering a new kind of state religion?”
[link removed]


** Liberalism Going in Circles ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------


** Peter J. Leithart
------------------------------------------------------------

Paul Kelly’s forthcoming book, Against Post-Liberalism, “cuts through the fog of battle” to accurately describe the “political movement he opposes,” Peter Leithart writes in his review. Kelly’s three faces of postliberalism—national populists, common-good communitarians, and common-good authoritarians—are true, but his analysis is occasionally tedious and contemptuous.

For further reading: Nathan Pinkoski embarked on a definitive survey of the postliberal trajectory of the west in “Actually Existing Postliberalism ([link removed]) ” (November 2024).
[link removed]


** Just Stop It ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------


** Liel Leibovitz
------------------------------------------------------------

From the January issue: Should the U.S. government “embark on a campaign to snuff out vice?” Perhaps not the government, but in a culture where vice has run amok, the direct approach might be the best. Leibovitz offers John Hughes, archbishop of New York from 1842 to 1864, as an example. Hughes “re-spiritualized” his flock of raucous Irish immigrants “with clear instruction: Do the right thing and shun the wrong. He instilled in his flock a moral purpose that allowed them to see themselves as something greater than the sum of their indignities.”

For further reading: Leibovitz makes the case that if messages of vice, such as the ones promulgated by provocateur Nick Fuentes, are popular, how much more popular could messages rooted in morality and God be? Kathleen Hull c ([link removed]) onsidered this question ([link removed]) in light of the 2015 live-action Cinderella movie, where critics noted that despite the sparkling and “vaudevillian antics” of the evil stepmother and her daughters, they “fail to steal the show.” Instead, Ella captures the audience with her “profound inner freedom,” which is rooted in her belief in goodness.

Upcoming Events
* February 1, 2026: Second Annual Neuhaus Lecture at the New College of Florida: “Recovering the University’s Soul ft. Bishop Robert Barron | Sarasota, FL. Register here ([link removed]) .

* March 5, 2026: Annual D.C. Lecture: “Our Crisis is Metaphysical” ft. Mary Harrington | Washington, D.C. Details coming soon.

Until next time,


** [link removed]

VIRGINIA AABRAM
------------------------------------------------------------
Newsletter Editor
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]

Copyright © 2025 First Things, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you opted in at firstthings.com.

============================================================
Our mailing address is:
First Things
9 East 40th St Fl 10
New York, NY 10016
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.