From Jon Fleischman - So, Does It Matter? <[email protected]>
Subject *Breaking* New CBS/YouGov Survey: Do California Voters Back Prop 50? Is Newsom’s Anti-Trump Bet Paying Off?
Date October 23, 2025 12:05 PM
  Links have been removed from this email. Learn more in the FAQ.
  Links have been removed from this email. Learn more in the FAQ.
View this post on the web at [link removed]

Our morning posts are for all subscribers, but at the bottom of this post is some “bonus content” as a thank you to our paid subscribers!
⏱️ 4.5 min read time
A High-Stakes Power Play
Proposition 50, Governor Gavin Newsom’s bold vision, is rewriting California’s political map — in every sense. Designed to promote Newsom (as he prepares a formal run for the White House) and he views as federal (Trump) overreach, this redistricting initiative redraws congressional lines to grow California’s influence in Washington. Its passage will flip five Republican House Seats to Democratic, and lock up the handful of competitive districts for Democrats as well. This latest CBS/YouGov opinion survey shows Newsom’s gamble appears to be working — largely due to the blue-ness of the state, and the apparently decision by monied GOP interests to hold back on needed major spending.
The Poll Numbers Tell the Story - A 24% Lead
A recent CBS News poll finds a health majority support for Prop 50 — 62% yes versus 38% no — unsurprising in a state dominated by Democrats. Voters inclined to say “yes” frame the measure as a statement against federal policies that sideline California, but you know it’s also a vote of dissatisfaction with President Trump. That is born out by a survey question (see a graphic further down).
Support cuts across groups, but it spikes among voters who see Prop 50 as a way to stick it to Washington. Even those worried about costs still support it—choosing symbolism over fiscal restraint.
Why Voters Are Split: National vs. Local Stakes
To many voters, this isn’t about district lines — it’s about plain and simple Washington. Opposition to the Trump administration is a significant support driver, with many viewing the measure as a way to send a political message. Only a small share of Californians believe Washington treats their state fairly, and that resentment is helping power the “yes” vote.
But opponents are focused closer to home. They worry that this redistricting will cement urban dominance and drown out suburban and rural voices. Newsom himself is a defining factor: his strong approval ratings with Democrats boost support, while many Republican opponents cite him personally as their reason for voting no.
Fights over things like deportations and federal crackdowns only widen the gap. Many Californians, particularly Hispanics, say those policies hurt local communities and the economy, fueling even more support for Prop 50 as a symbolic rebuke.
Campaign Cash Tips the Scales
Prop 50 backers are winning the argument, especially they’re buying the airtime to do it. Newsom, public-sector unions, and progressive political groups have poured over a hundred million dollars into committees advertising a “yes” vote as defending California from national interference, and really focused on Trump as the antagonist. The result is energized Democratic turnout in an otherwise low-profile election.
Republicans, on the other hand, are largely absent. National GOP organizations are apparently ready to focus their money on competitive races elsewhere, leaving local opponents massively outspent without the resources to counter the pro-50 narrative. Unless there’s a late surge of Republican money or high-profile intervention, the spending imbalance will likely cement the outcome. I talk about this in my podcast yesterday [ [link removed] ].
The poll, conducted by CBS News and YouGov from October 16 to 21, 2025, surveyed 1,504 registered California voters. It was weighted for demographics like gender, age, race, education, and region using voter files, Census data, and 2024 vote patterns, with a margin of error around ±3.8 points for registered voters and ±3.6 for likely ones
So, Does It Matter?
Proposition 50 is a power play to show that California is firmly in the Democratic column. If it passes, California could see congressional power consolidated in its cities, while rural and suburban communities lose representation. The big winners will be the political insiders — Newsom, of course. But the legislative leaders were able to have sweetheart empty Democratic Congressional seats drawn for them [ [link removed] ] to run in.
If Prop 50 passes, Newsom emerges even stronger—maintaining his strong position as a contender for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination. But here’s the twist that no one’s saying (except me): if the measure helps Democrats capture the House, it won’t be Newsom who becomes the face of the national “anti-Trump” movement. [ [link removed] ] It would more likely be Speaker Hakeem Jeffries—or Congressman Robert Garcia of Long Beach, who would become the Chairman of a House Oversight Committee primed to start conducting investigations of the Trump Administration, with subpoena power and all of that.
Below the paywall below are some other interesting results from this CBS/YouGov survey, straight from their polling deck… Also the partisan breaks, and a link to the survey top lines.
Every week 60% of so of our site’s content is for our free subscribers. But the other part is for those who choose to upgrade. It doesn’t cost much, but it is a great way to help support my independent work here, where I am beholding to nobody but the readers! Try a free upgrade now…...

Unsubscribe [link removed]?
Screenshot of the email generated on import

Message Analysis

  • Sender: n/a
  • Political Party: n/a
  • Country: n/a
  • State/Locality: n/a
  • Office: n/a