|
 |
Once again, Netflix turns a devout Christian legacy into a sermon about sexual identity — proving that in Hollywood, faith is always the villain, and sin is always the victim.
When Netflix released House of Guinness, it sold viewers another glossy “inspired by true events” saga — the kind it’s mastered. Period costumes, candlelit manors, slow-burn intrigue.
But beneath the polish lies a pattern: when Hollywood touches anything Christian, it can’t resist corrupting it.
This time, it’s the Guinness family — the proud Irish dynasty that built its empire on hard work, charity, and faith in God.
But Netflix saw something missing. A secret. A struggle. A sin to sympathize with.
So it invented one.
Enter Arthur Guinness — portrayed as a tormented homosexual forced to hide his desires beneath the weight of family piety.
The show’s emotional center isn’t the building of an empire or the power of faith — it’s the supposed suffering of a gay heir whose story is, according to historians, entirely unproven.
There are no letters. No records. No witnesses to this gay heir.
Just modern Hollywood, once again doing what it always does: injecting a same-sex subplot into a Christian story to make believers look like hypocrites and unbelievers look like heroes.
By becoming a paid subscriber to Majority Reports articles, your tax-deductible subscription to Christian Action Network unlocks access to every category of our work: Front Lines. Culture. Screened. Prophecy & AI. The Ledger and more.
Rewriting Faith Into Fiction
Arthur Guinness Sr. — the real founder — was a man of deep Protestant conviction. His descendants were known for philanthropy, missionary support, and moral reform.
The Guinness fortune wasn’t just built on stout — it was built on Scripture.
But that’s a problem for Netflix. In their world, devout Christians must always hide something. Their morality can’t be genuine; it must be repressed guilt. Their faith can’t be devotion; it must have hidden secrets to expose…and if not, invent one.
So they take one of Ireland’s most respected Christian families and twist their story into a morality play of forbidden desire and religious hypocrisy.
The goal isn’t accuracy. It’s empathy engineering.
The Family Calls Foul
Even the Guinness family is speaking out.
“Not all Guinness descendants are pleased with the result,” reported Esquire.
Molly Guinness, a great-great-granddaughter of Sir Benjamin Guinness, blasted the portrayal as “unjust,” saying its characters “come straight from a bingo card of modern clichés about rich people.”
She’s right. It’s not just about “rich people” — it’s about rewriting Christian families as frauds.
Netflix couldn’t let the Guinness name stand as an example of faith, discipline, and moral leadership.
It had to turn it into something dark, conflicted, and “relatable.” Because in Hollywood’s gospel, being devout is shameful — but sinning is brave.
The Real Message
Every time Netflix does this — and it happens constantly — the formula’s the same:
Find a Christian or historical icon.
Imply a hidden homosexuality or moral failing.
Rewrite the narrative so the “forbidden” becomes virtuous and the faithful become villains.
The result is always the same emotional manipulation: audiences are taught to sympathize with rebellion and despise conviction.
That’s not storytelling. That’s indoctrination.
The Truth They Erased
The real Guinness legacy is Christian to the core — they built hospitals, fed the poor, funded schools, and supported missionaries.
Their faith inspired an empire that still thrives today.
Netflix didn’t dramatize that. It replaced it. Because virtue without vice doesn’t sell — and Christianity without corruption doesn’t fit their script.
Bottom Line
House of Guinness isn’t a history lesson. It’s a sermon — not about God, but about Hollywood’s god: sexual identity.
It’s one more example of a streaming empire that takes stories of faith and family and rewrites them into fables of repression and victimhood.
The Guinness family deserved better. So did truth.
Martin Mawyer is the President of Christian Action Network, host of the “Shout Out Patriots” podcast, and author of When Evil Stops Hiding. Follow him on Substack for more action alerts, cultural commentary, and real-world campaigns defending faith, family, and freedom.
You're currently a free subscriber to Majority Report. For the full experience, upgrade your subscription.
| ||||||||||
