ATTENTION NEWSPAPER EDITORS:
This commentary is available online at www.rutherford.org.
Long Version ([link removed]) • Short Version ([link removed])
View this email in your browser ([link removed])
[link removed] Share ([link removed])
[link removed]: https%3A%2F%2Fmailchi.mp%2Frutherford%2Famericas-most-lawless-agency-ice-is-the-prototype-for-tyranny-by-john-nisha-whitehead Tweet ([link removed]: https%3A%2F%2Fmailchi.mp%2Frutherford%2Famericas-most-lawless-agency-ice-is-the-prototype-for-tyranny-by-john-nisha-whitehead)
[link removed] Forward ([link removed])
** America’s Most Lawless Agency: ICE Is the Prototype for Tyranny
By John & Nisha Whitehead
June 24, 2025
------------------------------------------------------------
“Experience should teach us to be most on our guard to protect liberty when the government's purposes are beneficent. Men born to freedom are naturally alert to repel invasion of their liberty by evil-minded rulers. The greatest dangers to liberty lurk in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but without understanding. ([link removed]) ”—Justice Louis D. Brandeis
While the U.S. wages war abroad—bombing Iran ([link removed]) , escalating conflict, and staging a spectacle of power for political gain ([link removed]) —a different kind of war is being waged here at home.
This war at home is quieter but no less destructive. The casualties are not in distant deserts or foreign cities. They are our freedoms, our communities, and the Constitution itself.
And the agents of this domestic war? Masked thugs. Unmarked vans. Raids. Roundups.
Detentions without due process. Retaliation against those who dare to question or challenge government authority. People made to disappear into bureaucratic black holes. Fear campaigns targeting immigrant communities and political dissenters alike. Surveillance weaponized to monitor and suppress lawful activity.
Packaged under the guise of national security—as all power grabs tend to be—this government-sanctioned thuggery masquerading as law-and-order is the face of the Trump Administration’s so-called war on illegal immigration.
Don’t fall for the propaganda that claims we’re being overrun by criminals ([link removed]) or driven into the poorhouse by undocumented immigrants living off welfare ([link removed]) .
The real threat to our way of life comes not from outside invaders, but from within: an unelected, unaccountable enforcement agency operating above the law.
MAKE THE GOVERNMENT PLAY BY THE RULES OF THE CONSTITUTION ([link removed])
President Trump insists that ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) is focused on violent criminals ([link removed]) , but the facts tell a different story ([link removed]) (non-criminal ICE arrests have surged 800% in six months)—and that myth is precisely what enables the erosion of rights for everyone.
By painting enforcement as narrowly targeted, the administration obscures a far broader dragnet that sweeps up legal residents, naturalized citizens, and native-born Americans alike.
What begins with immigrants rarely ends there.
According to the Cato Institute, 65 percent of people taken by ICE had no convictions, and 93 percent had no violent convictions at all ([link removed]) .
This isn’t targeted enforcement—it’s indiscriminate purging.
What ICE—an agency that increasingly resembles a modern-day Gestapo—is doing to immigrants today, it can and will do to citizens tomorrow: these are the early warning signs of a system already in motion.
The machinery is in place. The abuses are ongoing. And the constitutional safeguards we rely on are being ignored, dismantled, or bypassed entirely.
When legal residents, naturalized citizens, and native-born Americans are swept up in ICE’s raids, detained without cause, and subjected to treatment that defies every constitutional protection against government overreach, this isn’t about immigration.
It’s not about danger. It’s about power—unchecked and absolute.
This is authoritarianism by design.
Here are just a few examples of how ICE’s reach now extends far beyond a criminal class of undocumented immigrants:
* In Los Angeles, ICE agents detained U.S. citizens Jason Gavidia and Javier Ramirez ([link removed]) during mass raids at flea markets—actions condemned by local officials as racial profiling.
* In New York City, ICE arrested mayoral candidate Brad Lander at a courthouse ([link removed]) after he questioned the legitimacy of an enforcement action.
* In Arizona, a 19-year-old U.S. citizen with developmental disabilities was held for 10 days ([link removed]) without charges.
* In Virginia, naturalized citizen Jensy Machado was handcuffed at gunpoint ([link removed]) until officers reviewed his REAL ID.
* In Oregon, ICE agents arrested Moises Sotelo Casas—beloved vineyard manager and community member ([link removed]) —outside a church.
* In Tennessee, teen soccer player Emerson Colindres was deported without warning ([link removed]) , despite having no criminal background. His community was left reeling.
* ICE has even conducted raids at churches ([link removed]) —sanctuaries meant to offer refuge—violating not just constitutional rights but community trust and religious protections.
This pattern of abuse is not accidental.
It reflects a deliberate strategy of fear and domination by ICE agents acting like an occupying army, intent on intimidating the population into submission while the Trump Administration redraws the boundaries of the Constitution for all within America’s borders, citizen and immigrant alike.
This is how you dismantle a constitutional republic: not in one dramatic moment, but through the steady erosion of rights, accountability, and rule of law—first for the marginalized, then for everyone.
When constitutional guarantees become conditional and oversight is systematically evaded, all Americans—regardless of status—stand vulnerable to a regime that governs by fear rather than freedom.
We’ve seen this playbook before.
It’s the same strategy used by fascist regimes to consolidate power—using fear, force, and propaganda to turn public institutions into instruments of oppression.
ICE raids often occur without warrants. Agents frequently detain individuals not charged with any crime. Homes, schools, hospitals, workplaces, and courthouses have all become targets. Agents in plain clothes swarm unsuspecting individuals, arrest them without explanation, and separate families under the pretense of national security. In many cases, masked agents refuse to identify themselves at all—creating a climate of terror where the public cannot distinguish lawful enforcement from lawless abduction.
This is not justice. It is intimidation. And it has become business as usual.
ICE has even begun deputizing local police departments ([link removed]) to carry out these raids.
Through an expanded network of partnerships, ICE has turned routine traffic stops into pipelines for deportation ([link removed]) . According to The Washington Post ([link removed]) , immigrants stopped on the way to volleyball practice, picking up baby formula, or heading to job sites have been detained and, in some cases, sent to a notorious mega-prison in El Salvador.
This is what politicizing and weaponizing local police looks like.
Even members of Congress attempting to exercise constitutional oversight have been turned away from ICE facilities. As The New York Times reported ([link removed]) , ICE now claims the authority to “deny a request or otherwise cancel” congressional visits based on vague “operational concerns”—effectively placing its operations beyond democratic scrutiny.
Beyond the high-profile arrests, the abuse runs deeper.
Julio Noriega, a 54-year-old American citizen, was snatched up off the street and detained in Chicago for 10 hours ([link removed]) without explanation. Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S.-born citizen, was detained because ICE dismissed his REAL ID as fake ([link removed]) . Cary López Alvarado, a pregnant U.S. citizen, was handcuffed and arrested ([link removed]) for challenging ICE agents who had followed her fiancé to work. Children, veterans, and immunocompromised individuals have all suffered under ICE’s dragnet.
These are not outliers. They are the product of a system that operates without meaningful checks.
ICE agents are rarely held accountable. Internal investigations are ineffective. Congress has abdicated oversight. Directives from the Trump administration—including those authored by Stephen Miller—have turbocharged deportations and loosened any remaining restraints.
From boots on the ground to bytes in the cloud, ICE’s unchecked power reflects a broader shift toward authoritarianism, fueled by high-tech surveillance, public indifference and minimal judicial oversight. The agency operates a sprawling digital dragnet ([link removed]) : facial recognition, license plate readers, cellphone tracking, and partnerships with tech giants like Amazon and Palantir feed massive databases—often without warrants or oversight.
These same tools—hallmarks of a growing surveillance state—are now being quietly repurposed across other federal agencies, setting the stage for an integrated surveillance-policing regime that threatens the constitutional rights of every American.
YOUR SUPPORT HELPS THE RUTHERFORD INSTITUTE SOUND THE ALARM OVER THREATS TO OUR FREEDOMS: DONATE TODAY ([link removed])
This isn’t about safety. It’s about control.
These tools aren’t just targeting undocumented immigrants—they’re laying the digital scaffolding for a future in which everyone is watched, scored, and subject to state suspicion.
Quotas over justice. Algorithms over rights.
ICE’s operations have little to do with individualized threat assessments. What drives these raids is not public safety but bureaucratic performance. Field offices are under pressure to meet arrest quotas, creating a system that incentivizes indiscriminate sweeps over focused investigations.
As Jennie Taer writes for the NY Post:
“The Trump administration’s mandate to arrest 3,000 illegal migrants per day is forcing ICE agents to deprioritize going after dangerous criminals and targets with deportation orders ([link removed]) , insiders warn. Instead, federal immigration officers are spending more time rounding up people off the streets… Agents are desperate to meet the White House’s high expectations, leading them to leave some dangerous criminal illegal migrants on the streets, and instead look for anyone they can get their hands on at the local Home Depot or bus stop.”
Predictive algorithms and flawed databases replace constitutional suspicion with digital hunches, turning enforcement into a numbers game and transforming communities into statistical targets.
Constitutional safeguards are being replaced by digital suspicion.
We now live in a nation where lawful dissent—especially from immigrants or those perceived as outsiders—can place someone under state suspicion. The line between investigation and persecution has been erased.
Fear needs fuel.
And ICE finds it in propaganda: just as the Gestapo used propaganda to justify its cruelty, ICE relies on the language of fear and division. When the government labels people “invaders,” “animals,” or “thugs,” it strips them of humanity—and strips us of our conscience.
This rhetoric serves to distract and divide. It normalizes abuse. And it ensures that, once targeted, no one is safe.
The construction of a new ICE mega-prison in Florida—nicknamed “Alligator Alcatraz” for its proposed moat and remote location ([link removed]) —serves as a grotesque symbol of the Trump Administration’s mass deportation agenda: out of sight, beyond accountability, and surrounded by literal and bureaucratic barriers to due process.
And Trump’s shifting stance on industries that rely on migrant labor—one moment threatening crackdowns, the next signaling exemptions ([link removed]) for hotels, farms, and construction—reveals what this campaign is really about: not security, but political theater.
It’s not about danger; it’s about dominance.
But the crisis isn’t just rhetorical. It’s systemic. Agents are trained to obey, not to question. Immunity shields misconduct. Whistleblowers are punished. Watchdogs are ignored. Courts too often defer to executive power.
This is not law enforcement—it is authoritarian enforcement.
And it’s not limited to immigrants. It’s creeping into every corner of American life.
When a government can detain its own citizens without due process, punish political dissent, and target individuals for what they believe or how they look, it is no longer governed by law. It is governed by fear.
The Constitution was designed to prevent this. But rights are meaningless when no one is held accountable for violating them.
That is why the solution must go beyond the ballot box.
We must dismantle the machinery of oppression that enables ICE to act as judge, jury, and jailer.
Congress must ban warrantless raids, end predictive profiling, and prohibit mass surveillance. It must enforce real oversight and revoke the legal shields that insulate abusive agents from consequences.
We must reassert the rule of law, not just through legislation, but through a cultural recommitment to constitutional values. That includes transparency, demilitarization, and equal protection for all—citizens and non-citizens alike.
This is not just a fight over immigration policy. It’s a battle for the soul of our nation.
ICE is not the exception. It is the prototype.
As I make clear in my books Battlefield America: The War on the American People ([link removed]) and A Government of Wolves: The Emerging American Police State ([link removed]) , the same blueprint is being applied across the federal landscape: to protest monitoring, dissent suppression, and data-mined predictive policing.
If we fail to dismantle the ICE model, we normalize it—and risk reproducing it everywhere else.
ICE has become the beta test—perfecting the merger of technology, policing, and executive power that could soon define American governance as a whole.
Make no mistake: when fear becomes law, freedom is the casualty.
If we don’t act soon, we may find that the Constitution is the next to be detained.
James Madison warned that “the accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands… may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.”
When ICE acts as enforcer, jailer, and judge for the president, those fears are no longer theoretical—they are the daily reality for countless people within U.S. borders.
WC: 1974
Source: [link removed]
[link removed]
ABOUT JOHN & NISHA WHITEHEAD
Constitutional attorney and author John W. Whitehead is founder and president of The Rutherford Institute. His latest books The Erik Blair Diaries ([link removed]) and Battlefield America: The War on the American People ([link removed]) are available at www.amazon.com. Whitehead can be contacted at
[email protected] (mailto:
[email protected]) .
Nisha Whitehead is the Executive Director of The Rutherford Institute. Information about The Rutherford Institute is available at www.rutherford.org.
[link removed]
PUBLICATION GUIDELINES AND REPRINT PERMISSION
John W. Whitehead’s weekly commentaries are available for publication to newspapers and web publications at no charge. Please contact
[email protected] (mailto:
[email protected]) to obtain reprint permission. Click here ([link removed]) to download a print quality image of John W. Whitehead.
Click here ([link removed]) to read more of John & Nisha Whitehead's commentaries.
[link removed] PODCAST AVAILABLE
Freedom Under Fire, a weekly podcast of constitutional attorney John W. Whitehead's popular syndicated column, is available on SoundCloud and iTunes. Click here ([link removed]) to access the podcast.
============================================================
** KEEP FREEDOM ALIVE ([link removed])
To donate via PayPal, click on the link below:
** ([link removed])
** Twitter ([link removed])
** Twitter ([link removed])
** Facebook ([link removed])
** Facebook ([link removed])
** The Rutherford Institute ([link removed])
** The Rutherford Institute ([link removed])
Copyright © 2025 The Rutherford Institute, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because of your interest in the work of The Rutherford Institute. Founded in 1982 by constitutional attorney and author John W. Whitehead, The Rutherford Institute is a civil liberties organization that provides free legal services to people whose constitutional and human rights have been threatened or violated. To discontinue your membership electronically, or if you feel you are receiving this message in error, please follow the link below.
Our mailing address is:
The Rutherford Institute
Post Office Box 7482
Charlottesville, VA 22906
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.
Under the regulations of the United States Internal Revenue Service, The Rutherford Institute is incorporated as a 501(c)(3) tax exempt nonprofit organization. Donations to support The Rutherford Institute’s legal and educational work help to safeguard the constitutional rights of all Americans. Donations are tax-deductible. In compliance with general industry standards of a nonprofit organization, the Institute is audited annually by an independent accounting firm.