Conservatism’s Sharpest Voices, Curated Weekly | ISI’s Intercollegiate Review brings you the best in serious conservative thought.
Email not displaying correctly?
View it in your browser.


 

​​​Note from the Editor: The Intercollegiate Review will be moving to Substack this Summer. 

Substack offers a more convenient and accessible experience to you as the reader and will allow us to reach a wider audience.

We are grateful for your support of the
Intercollegiate Review and are committed to keeping your subscription completely free as we move to Substack. 


CATEGORY: CULTURE (7 MIN)

Fidelity Month and the "Classic, American Virtues"

You’ve probably been able to quickly tell that June has begun—major companies, sports teams, and even restaurants have donned rainbows (the biblical reminder of God’s promise not to flood the earth again) to proclaim the start of Pride Month. With so many mainstream organizations in lockstep, even after the political change of the past year, one might wonder if resistance is still acceptable.

Enter Fidelity Month. Jacob Ogan, writing in National Review, tells the story of Prof. Robert P. George’s brainchild, which was launched two years ago to oppose the dominance of Pride Month. Its symbol is a myrtle wreath, and its goal is to “celebrate the classic, American virtues that have long made this nation great.”

Despite the overall decline in religious attendance and moral values for the past few decades, Ogan shines the light on “pockets of hope.” He notes the increase in religious dedication in young men, and he points to those who continue to resist the “rampant secularism” that otherwise has reigned supreme.

Ogan links the concept of “fidelity” to a moral order centered around God, which leads to an overflowing love to our families, our neighbors, and our country. He calls this vision “more noble” than a mere counter-cultural effort; as Prof. George put it, Fidelity Month is a “positive and uplifting project." Ogan then urges individual, communal, and national commitment to such fidelity.

Read more of Ogan’s piece here.


Weekly Poll

Have you heard of Fidelity Month before reading this piece?

[A] Yes
[B] No

[C] Unsure
 

RESULTS: 6/5/2025

How familiar are you with the work of Alasdair MacIntyre?

[A] Somewhat familiar - 45.3%
​​​​​[B] Unfamiliar - 41.5%
[C] Very familiar - 13.2%

CATEGORY: CULTURE (4 MIN)

"Pleasing and True:" Reclaiming Conservative Art

What are other aspects of this concept of fidelity? If it’s centered around God, it likely also involves admiration for the good, the true, and the beautiful. Such concepts are often repressed and unpopular today, even in the conservative movement itself. So some organizations, including ISI, are stepping into the gap to honor artistic creativity that reflects the divine.

For First Things, Micah Mattix highlights these organizations’ efforts and urges the importance of placing excellent art and literature into a respected place in American culture. Mattix notes ISI’s inaugural Linda L. Bean Prize for Advancing American Art & Culture, which went to artist Jamie Wyeth at ISI’s 2025 Gala for Western Civilization last month. Mattix describes the award as “the only overtly conservative prize I am aware of that has honored a painter in the past fifty years.”

Mattix also discusses other recent developments in conservative art too. He cites the First Things Poetry Prize, which honors poems with “a high view of form.” Poet Dana Gioia, who spoke at ISI’s 2025 Gala, will judge this year’s edition of that prize. Mattix also mentions St. Thomas University (Houston, TX), which launched a new Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing program that focuses on creating excellent literature.

Mattix then references several conservative publications that include good artistic work. (ISI’s own Modern Age has a poetry section for just this purpose.) And he concludes with a warning: don’t make great art just to shape morals or politics. Create great art that reflects the “pleasing and true” image of God, and it will do the job itself.

Read Mattix’s article here.

CATEGORY: VIDEO

Jamie Wyeth & Dana Gioia Live Q&A

Tune in for a special Q&A session featuring renowned painter Jamie Wyeth and award-winning poet Dana Gioia, recorded at ISI's 18th Annual Gala for Western Civilization. Moderated by ISI President Johnny Burtka, this conversation offers a rare opportunity to hear two of America's leading cultural figures respond to questions and reflect on their work, lives, and ideas.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel here.

Because our student editors and writers are bravely bringing conservative ideas to their campuses, we’re highlighting their efforts here.

Protestors Demand More, Gain Little via The Dartmouth Review
“On the recent anniversary of the infamous May 1st pro-Palestinian encampment arrests, the Palestinian Solidarity Coalition (PSC) organized a protest at Parkhurst Hall. They boast what they see as a successful win, particularly in advancing immigration protections. In reality, recent pro-Palestinian efforts have changed virtually nothing in terms of college policy, while they have completely changed the campus’s sympathy toward the protestors and their movement as a whole...The “win” that they supposedly acquired through all these actions was not even related to their movement. Two things took place. First, it is now codified in college policy that ICE may not enter private spaces without a warrant. Second, the College’s immigration legal fund had its upper limit (for special cases) raised to $5,000. The standard amount of funding per person, $2,000, did not change. ”

Are We Next? Stanford’s Position in the Federal Funding Cut Lineup via The Stanford Review
“On Wednesday, April 9th, President Trump froze $790 million in federal funding to Northwestern and over $1 billion to Cornell. The sequence of funding halts, which began in early March, is in response to university administrations’ handling of pro-Palestine demonstrations, allowance of antisemitic activity on campus, and lack of protection for Jewish students since the fall of last academic year. These hefty cuts have grabbed the attention of students, staff, and academic administrators across the country as they all wonder: Who will be next?”

Harvard's 374th Commencement via The Harvard Salient
“Since September 1642, when President Henry Dunster conferred degrees on nine candidates, Harvard University has hosted a commencement ceremony. After nearly four centuries, Harvard continues this tradition, now one of “largest and oldest academic ceremonies” on the continent. Thursday morning, graduates and their families filed through the gates of Harvard Yard, as did generations before them, to celebrate the Class of 2025. Unsurprisingly, current events made their way into many of the day's speeches. However, there was a notable lack of protests or demonstrations, and the focus remained, for the most part, on the gravity of the moment.”

American Identity Summit’s Opening Panel Discusses the Limits of Free Speech and the Role of Major Institutions in Upholding Its Principles via The Chicago Thinker
“The Chicago Thinker’s inaugural 2025 American Identity Summit launched with a powerful opening panel titled “The Fight Against Censorship & the Future of American Journalism,” featuring Cenk Uygur, Nadine Strossen, Clay Travis, and Jonathan Turley. Moderated by the Thinker’s publisher and editor-in-chief, Christopher Phillips, the panel explored growing threats to free expression, the evolving media landscape, and the responsibilities of governmental institutions and citizens in defending free discourse. Despite ideological differences, the panelists brought unique perspectives and substantive experiences to a debate on one of the most critical modern issues.”

Journalism Faces a Credibility Crisis. Gerard Baker Charts a Path Forward. via The Michigan Review
“American trust in traditional media is at an all-time low. As public support for mainstream journalism has fallen from 72 percent in 1976 to just 31 percent in 2024, major news organizations face shrinking audiences, falling profit margins, and declining recruitment numbers. While the future of journalism remains uncertain, The Wall Street Journal’s Gerard Baker holds hope that the next generation of journalists can learn from the industry’s mistakes and regroup. During a press conference hosted by the Fund for American Studies, Gerard Baker addressed journalism’s current credibility crisis and assessed how future journalists must restore journalism’s traditional values to reverse its decline.“

CATEGORY: LITERATURE (10 MIN)

Coming of Age for Caulfield and Copperfield

For evidence that literature based in truth and virtue affects society, you don’t have to look far. The assigned reading lists of an average American student in 2025 look very different from those in past years. Perhaps some classics have survived, but many have been replaced with more modern work that carries a starkly different message.

For this week’s article from the Modern Age website, Robert Whaples contrasts J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye with the classic Dickens novel David Copperfield. Whaples uses the two books to highlight a change in the view of virtue in America, especially noting that students are often not assigned David Copperfield today but are often assigned The Catcher in the Rye.

Whaples describes the similarities between the two books: they are both coming-of-age stories for a young man who faces great difficulty. But the two protagonists respond in vastly different ways. Whaples says Holden Caulfield, the main character of Salinger’s novel, “abuses every opportunity that’s handed to him” and mocks the good in the world. In contrast, Copperfield works diligently through every phase of his childhood and young adulthood, overcoming tremendous adversity with the aid of close-knit friends (and learning from his own mistakes).

“Copperfield is everything Holden could be and should be but refuses to be,” Whaples writes.

The virtues Copperfield represents, according to Whaples, could shape American children into more engaging people with “more fulfilling lives.”

Read more about these books in Whaples’s essay on the Modern Age website.


Thought of the Day:
 
“Men cannot improve a society by setting fire to it: they must seek out its old virtues, and bring them back into the light.”
​​​​​​
- Russell Kirk

​​​

Join ISI’s new Alumni Giving Club

It’s never been easier for you to support our mission—and stay part of our community—with ISI’s new Alumni Giving Club! 

For just $19.53 a month, you can join the fight and “pay it forward” by educating the next generation for ordered liberty. 

Join the Club

 

Follow on Twitter   Friend on Facebook   Forward to Friend 
Copyright © 2025, All rights reserved.

Our mailing address is:

Intercollegiate Studies Institute
3901 Centerville Road
Wilmington, DE 19807
unsubscribe from all emails   update subscription preferences