The Latest from the Prospect ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??
View this email in your browser [link removed]
**MAY 6, 2025**
On the Prospect website
How to Tie Up the Most Precious Resource in Washington
[link removed]
Democrats can use the Congressional Review Act to force votes on many Trump regulatory actions. A decision by Senate Republicans could widen the opportunity. BY TODD PHILLIPS
Did Trump Do Europe a Favor? [link removed]
The EU must now look to its own political and economic interests. That could be good for European values and European union. BY ROBERT KUTTNER
The Chickens and the Eggs [link removed]
Avian flu outbreaks are exacerbated by the consolidated structure of the poultry industry. BY JANELLE CARLSON
Kuttner on TAP
****
****
****
****
****
****
****
**** A Wake-Up Call to British Labour
As the West's only majority
left-of-center government dithers, the far-right Reform party makes big gains.
LONDON - American progressives have looked longingly at Britain as the one Western nation where a left-of-center government has a large working majority and a mandate for dramatic change. Under Prime Minister Keir Starmer, the Labour Party holds 403 seats in the 650 member House of Commons.
But that large representation is misleading. It's the quirky result of the collapse of the Conservative Party in the July 2024 elections, combined with Britain's "first past the post" electoral system, which gave Labour a huge parliamentary majority based on just 34 percent of the national popular vote [link removed].
Starmer needed to earn his mandate by channeling the popular desire for drastic change. Instead, he bungled it by excess caution on every major front, and a reversion to neoliberal
fiscal policies and small-bore policy adjustments that don't add to improved life conditions for ordinary Brits.
The result was a shocking set of gains last week for Nigel Farage's far-right Reform party. In last week's local elections, support for Labour cratered, the Tories collapsed, and the Reform Party surged.
Reform not only snatched a supposedly safe Labour seat in a House of Commons by-election. The party also gained 677 local council seats and now controls ten county councils, including large ones such as Kent.
For two decades, Britain has underperformed every other major economy in the West. Since 2008, its annual GDP growth rate has been less than 1 percent.
One consequence was a backlash against the EU, whose free-migration rules were blamed for taking local jobs. In a move that was too clever by half, Tory Prime Minister David Cameron tried to co-opt the far right in 2015 by sponsoring a plebiscite on Brexit, then opposing its passage.
The gambit
backfired. After Brexit narrowly passed in 2016, Cameron resigned, followed by a succession of clownish Tory prime ministers. Though the referendum was not binding, the Tories stalled for several years and finally led Britain out of the EU in 2020.
As most economic commentators had warned, the result was to weaken Britain's economy even further. Multinational corporations and banks that located in the U.K. for easy access to the continent suddenly faced all manner of barriers. Traditional British exports to Europe suffered as well.
[link removed]
In these circumstances, the Tories were thoroughly repudiated in the 2024 election. The British economy needed a massive overhaul, to move away from its excessive reliance on finance and toward its underdeveloped strengths in technology. Britain also needed major reinvestment in its public systems, from the National
Health Service to its crumbling public infrastructure and failed privatizations such as British Rail.
But this would require significant tax increases on capital to finance public needs. Despite having the world's second-largest capital markets, Britain has kept taxes on capital extremely low, and Labour does not propose to change that. Our friend Damon Silvers has calculated that if Britain had a tax system comparable to Canada's, it would have another 100 billion pounds to spend annually on public investments.
Instead, Starmer embraced a program that focused on budget balance at the expense of social supports. He began by cutting the winter fuel allowance. In March, the government unveiled sweeping cuts in Britain's social security system, including unpopular proposals to narrow criteria for disability support and other health benefits.
Starmer has also ducked the pressing issue of how to rejoin Europe, even if not as a formal member of the EU, on the model of Norway
and Switzerland. Recent polls show that about 55 percent of British voters now say that leaving the EU was a mistake [link removed], compared to just 30 percent who still support Brexit.
The swing to Farage doesn't mean Brexit is untouchable. It just means that large numbers of voters want transformative change, and they aren't getting it from Labour.
But if the results of last week's election were a painful wake-up call for Labour, they were catastrophic for the Tories. In last week's local elections, Reform captured 30 percent of the votes for local council seats, compared to the Tories' 15 percent. The Tories lost 676 council seats and lost control of all of the 16 councils where they had been the majority.
As the traditional center-right party, founded in 1834, the Tories are hemmed in from the center by the resurgent Liberal Democrats and from the right by the
Reform party. If anything like last week's results are repeated in the next general election, the Tories would be wiped out and Britain would have a four-party system, with Reform on the far right, the Liberal Democrats in the center, and Labour and the Greens as a divided left.
But the Tory collapse is small comfort for Starmer and Labour, which has until the next general election, which is not required until 2029, to find a more compelling set of policies. The early signs are not encouraging.
Once again, a feeble center-left party that delivers little for struggling citizens hemorrhages support to the far right. How many times, in how many countries, do we need to learn this lesson?
~ ROBERT KUTTNER
Follow Robert Kuttner on Twitter
[link removed]
[link removed]
To receive this newsletter directly in your inbox, click here to subscribe.?? [link removed]
Click to Share this Newsletter
[link removed]
??
[link removed]
??
[link removed]
??
[link removed]
??
[link removed]
The American Prospect, Inc., 1225 I Street NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC xxxxxx, United States
Copyright (c) 2025 The American Prospect. All rights reserved.
To opt out of American Prospect membership messaging, click here [link removed].
To manage your newsletter preferences, click here [link removed].
To unsubscribe from all American Prospect emails, including newsletters, click here [link removed].
