Courts Temporarily Put Hold on the ED’s “Dear Colleague” Letter
On April 24, two federal judges in New Hampshire and Maryland
ruled against the Department of Education’s (ED) Feb. 14 “Dear Colleague” letter, which declared all race-based programming
and activities illegal. Both courts found that plaintiffs in separate lawsuits
were likely to prove that the letter violated procedural standards and the First
and Fifth Amendments, due to the overreach of the Department’s statutory authority.
Before these rulings, schools that did not comply with the guidance risked losing their federal funding.
Initially, in New Hampshire, U.S. District Judge Landya McCafferty
issued a limited preliminary injunction protecting only members of the plaintiff
in that case, whose primary plaintiff was the National Education Association (NEA).
However, later that same day, in Maryland in a case filed by the American Federation
of Teachers (AFT), U.S. District Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher expanded protections
by issuing an order that blocks the letter nationwide until the cases are fully
resolved. This means that in addition to K-12, institutions of higher education
would also be covered by Judge Gallagher’s preliminary injunction.
The plaintiffs, primarily unions, argued that the ED’s letter
used vague language that violated both the First and Fifth Amendments and exceeded
the Department’s legal authority. In response, the Department argued the letter
merely reminded schools that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act protects all students,
including white students, from discrimination. They maintained that the letter
simply clarified existing legal obligations and did not introduce new policies.
In her ruling, Judge McCafferty emphasized that the letter’s failure to clearly
define terms like "DEI" could dangerously erode fundamental rights in
education. Meanwhile, Judge Gallagher focused on the letter’s procedural and substantive constitutional flaws.
The rulings currently place only temporary holds on enforcement. ED will likely appeal the rulings.