Good morning and welcome to Broad + Liberty's Weekly Reads.

Stay up to date on all of this and more when yousubscribe to our daily email list ([link removed]) and get the best of Broad + Liberty delivered straight to your inbox.


** 1. After two years in office, Shapiro fails to fill key vacancies on state commission ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------


By Beth Ann Rosica

When Josh Shapiro was sworn in as governor in 2023, there were four commissioner vacancies on the eleven-person Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC). Over two years later, the four vacancies remain unfilled.

Shapiro, who likes toboast ([link removed]) about “getting s*** done,” has not appointed a single person to fill those vacancies.

While it’s certainly possible the governor’s failure to make any appointments is just laziness or a matter of priorities, there’s a good argument to be made that the seats are empty as part of a political strategy.

Why It Matters. Our analysis reveals six of the commissioners are registered Democrats and one is a registered Republican.

Under the leadership of these same commissioners in 2023, the PHRC enacted newregulations ([link removed]) changing the definition of sex to include gender identity and gender expression.

Is it conceivable Shapiro wanted to keep the commission unbalanced with only one Republican commissioner? Perhaps, a heavily Democratic commission would be more likely to push through the 2023 regulation changes?

Continue Reading ([link removed])


** 2. Are Pennsylvania’s Democratic Supreme Court Justices acting like politicians? ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------

By Stephen Eustis, Jr.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court wields significant authority over the state’s legal framework, shaping policies on election laws, emergency powers, and more. Since 2015, its 5-2 Democratic majority, including Justices Christine Donohue, Kevin Dougherty, and David Wecht, has driven decisions that, while often legally defensible, frequently align with one political perspective.

An examination of three pivotal 2020 rulings — on Covid-19 emergency powers, mail-in ballot deadlines, and the exclusion of the Green Party from the presidential ballot — reveals a concerning pattern. These decisions raise questions about whether Democratic justices are acting more like politicians than impartial arbiters, a trend that risks undermining public trust in the judiciary.

Why It Matters. When a court’s rulings consistently produce outcomes that benefit one political perspective, it risks being seen as an extension of that agenda rather than a fair interpreter of the law.

Public trust in the judiciary hinges on its ability to remain above partisan fray, serving as a check on governmental power without appearing to favor one side. The current 5-2 Democratic majority, with its history of rulings that align with one party’s interests, risks undermining that trust, creating a perception of bias that could have lasting consequences for the court’s legitimacy.

A judiciary that reflects a broader range of perspectives is better equipped to interpret the Constitution and laws in a way that serves all Pennsylvanians, not just one segment of the political spectrum. Achieving this balance doesn’t necessarily mean rejecting qualified justices, but it does require acknowledging when a court’s trajectory seems to mirror political priorities rather than impartial justice.

Continue Reading ([link removed])


** 3. Lightning Round
------------------------------------------------------------
* Simon Webber: The case for abolishing zoning ([link removed])
* Stu Bykofsky: Predictably, the soda tax failed to deliver ([link removed])
* Conservative group files suit over Biden-era documents related to Franklin County project ([link removed])
* Thom Nickels: 19th-century Philadelphia’s macabre, union-organizing novelist ([link removed])
* Kyle Sammin: Could we just be normal? ([link removed])
* Beth Ann Rosica: The inevitable federal-state showdown on education ([link removed])
* Jonathan Russell: Hubris is not a leadership virtue ([link removed])
* Michael Thomas Leibrandt: Philadelphia’s college basketball team that might have won it all ([link removed])

[link removed]


** 4. New Podcast
------------------------------------------------------------

[link removed]

Your guide to A.I.'s surprising impacts in PA | Voices of Reason – PA Sen. Tracy Pennycuick [Watch ([link removed]) ]


** 5. What we're reading
------------------------------------------------------------

A new report this week from BlueStateRed ([link removed]) breaks down the 2024 election in Pennsylvania and makes for fascinating reading for anyone interested in the massive shifts in voter sentiment and the emerging party realignment. BlueStateRed principal (and Broad + Liberty co-founder) Albert Eisenberg breaks it all down, showing how racial, religious, and ethnic minority voters shifted rightward like never before, delivering the presidency and Congress to Republicans in 2024.

Broad + Liberty is funded by readers like you.

Your generous support ensures that Broad + Liberty can bring you stories and opinions that Pennsylvania’s mainstream media would rather leave unheard. Please consider making a contribution today. If you would like your gift to be used to help us cover a specific story or subject, please let us know in the contribution form or at [email protected] (mailto:[email protected]) .

As always, gifts made to Broad + Liberty are 100% tax deductible!

Thank you, dear reader, for your steadfast support of our independent, broad-minded brand of local journalism. We could not do this without you.

With gratitude,

— The Editors at Broad + Liberty
Support Broad + Liberty ([link removed])
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]

============================================================
Copyright © 2025 Broad + Liberty, All rights reserved.
You're getting Broad + Liberty updates due to your interest in our site – and local stories for free thinkers in the Philly region and beyond.

Our mailing address is:
Broad + Liberty
323 West Front Street
Suite 200
Media, PA 19063
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.

Broad and Liberty, Inc. is a Pennsylvania Domestic Nonprofit Corporation classifed as a public charity under Internal Revenue Code Section 501 (c) (3).
Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp
[link removed]