[link removed]
FAIR
View article on FAIR's website ([link removed])
Media Are Slowly Starting to Be Serious About Police Violence Bryce Greene ([link removed])
Homeless man Charf Lloyd being attacked by LAPD, in a photo taken and posted to Facebook by Kirk Tsonos
LAPD officers attack homeless man Charf Lloyd with projectiles, in a photo taken and posted to Facebook ([link removed]) by Kirk Tsonos.
As the George Floyd protests against police violence erupted around the nation, a massive amount of evidence of police brutality was widely captured through social media. Unfortunately, very little of it made it to mainstream outlets until much later.
For days, Twitter and Facebook were filled with videos of heavily armored police forces indiscriminately pepper-spraying marchers ([link removed]) , firing flashbangs ([link removed]) at crowds containing children and elderly, and shooting projectiles ([link removed]^tfw|twcamp^tweetembed|twterm^1266921821653385225&ref_url=[link removed]) at people standing outside their own homes. Marchers walked away from protests with all manner of bruises and bleeding wounds, and several lost teeth and even eyes to police projectiles. To many of those immersed in the social media environment, looted or burning buildings seemed relatively unimportant compared to the state violence meted out to the population.
Though the first weekend of the protests saw fires, looting and unruly activism, media coverage generally lacked any serious analysis of the abusive police conduct. Media coverage not only demonized legitimate outrage at a broken system, it whitewashed the role police played in spreading violence and chaos. Since some of the protesters committed destructive acts against property, the assumption seemed to be, none of the protesters had human rights.
USA Today: George Floyd death protesters spread violence, destruction across U.S. cities
USA Today (5/30/20 ([link removed]) ) put together a montage of fires and broken windows to explain the George Floyd protests to its audience.
USA Today (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) ran a piece, “Peaceful Protesters Lament Violence at George Floyd Demonstrations, but Understand the Rage Behind It.” The only violence discussed at length was the vandalism, looting and instances of fires set during protests. The piece briefly mentioned tear gas and arrests, but did not include them in its examination of how police “overreact” to peaceful protesters.
The Washington Post (6/1/20 ([link removed]) ) and Reuters (5/29/20 ([link removed]) ; republished by New York Times, 5/29/20 ([link removed]) ) followed similar patterns, as did a USA Today video (5/30/20 ([link removed]) ), titled “George Floyd Death Protesters Spread Violence, Destruction Across US Cities.”
A major New York Times article (5/28/20 ([link removed]) ) described “skirmishes” with police. The language implied a parity between unarmed protesters and heavily armed and armored militarized police. One of the most common terms ([link removed]) used to describe police violent incursions into protesters' space was the benign word “clashes.”
Even when outlets described the rampant police violence against protesters, the language used still protected police from scrutiny. Media Matters (6/2/20 ([link removed]) ), examining how media headlines sanitized police violence, found multiple uses of passive voice to avoid ascribing agency. For example, instead of declaring that police were targeting journalists, Reuters (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) merely wrote, “Journalists Targeted in Attacks.”
Reuters: Tear gas fired on protesters near White House as Trump speaks
Reuters (6/1/20 ([link removed]) ) reported that tear gas apparently fired itself at protesters while Trump coincidentally happened to be speaking.
Media Matters also found outlets describing inanimate objects committing violence instead of attributing actions to officers. For example, the Independent (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) ran the headline, “NYPD Vehicle Rams Crowd of Demonstrators in Brooklyn,” while Reuters (6/1/20 ([link removed]) ) had “Tear Gas Fired on Protesters Near White House as Trump Speaks.”
Even coverage of police abuses sometimes attempted to falsely equate these abuses to protesters’ actions. For example, a USA Today (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) story that showcased police attacks on journalists ([link removed]) tried to implicate protesters in attacks on journalists, writing, “Members of the news media appeared to be targeted, by police and protesters alike.”
The only case presented involving demonstrators was when protesters outside of the White House chased down ([link removed]) and yelled obscenities at a Fox News camera crew as they chased them away. No physical violence occurred other than someone throwing water on the crew. For some reason, this minor incident was included in a long list of police using rubber bullets and arbitrary arrest to subdue reporters.
The Intercept (6/4/20 ([link removed]) ) ran a piece by Trevor Timm of the Freedom of the Press Foundation, which noted that assaults on journalists have come overwhelmingly from police--83% of the time, according to the Foundation’s numbers, not counting dozens of arrests of journalists by police. At least some of the remaining assaults were not by protesters, Timm noted, citing an attack on Philadelphia TV reporter Jon Ehrens by “what appears to be police-aligned white nationalists ([link removed]) .”
Slate (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) was one of the first outlets to focus on police violence as its own phenomenon in a headline “Police Erupt in Violence Nationwide.” This article included some of the ample evidence of police violence widely distributed through social media.
Perhaps the increasingly overt abuses of journalists prompted outlets to be more critical of police. In one high-profile incident, CNN reporter Omar Jimenez and his crew were arrested on live TV ([link removed]) despite clearly identifying themselves as press. Another incident saw a local news crew clearly and deliberately targeted with pepper balls ([link removed]) by police. These incidents, along with days of massive social media backlash ([link removed]) against police violence, likely contributed to the broader refocus on law enforcement abuses over the course of several days.
NYT: Mayor de Blasio, Open Your Eyes. The Police Are Out of Control.
New York Times editorial (6/4/20 ([link removed]) ) on New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio: "As evidence of police abuse has mounted, he has averted his eyes."
By mid-week, outlets were starting to bring serious attention to police violence. The New York Times (6/4/20 ([link removed]) ) published an editorial headlined “"Mayor de Blasio, Open Your Eyes. The Police Are Out of Control,” with a subhead reading, “This Is Not What Serving and Protecting Should Look Like.” Newsweek (6/4/20 ([link removed]) ) ran a piece centering state violence, headlined “Protest Leaders Largely Calm Amid Unrest as Police Violence Tests Mayors and Governors.” Pieces from the Washington Post (e.g., 6/6/20 ([link removed]) ) also show increased scrutiny of police brutality.
Critical coverage of police tactics has an enormous effect on how elected officials and police officers view abuses by their forces. The threat of negative representation in the media puts pressure on them to seriously address abuses — at least the obvious abuses caught on camera. Even after many mayors indicated ([link removed]) that abuses wouldn’t be immediately dealt with early in the week, cracks in that facade are beginning to appear.
On Sunday, a veto-proof majority of the Minneapolis city council pledged ([link removed]) to disband the city's police department, asserting that it can not be reformed. House Democrats on Monday put forth a bill ([link removed]) to address (rather timidly ([link removed]) ) some complaints about police.
Two officers involved in forcefully knocking down and injuring a 75-year-old man, then lying about it, have been suspended ([link removed]) from the Buffalo Police Department. Six Atlanta police were booked on charges involving excessive force ([link removed]) after tasing and dragging two college students out of their car; a Philadelphia police commander was charged with aggravated assault ([link removed]) for bludgeoning another student in the head. Only sustained media attention to such abuses will create the conditions for ongoing calls for justice to be answered.
------------------------------------------------------------
Featured image: Slate photo depiction (5/31/20 ([link removed]) ) of police violence. (Photo: Jason Redmond/Getty Images)
Read more ([link removed])
© 2020 Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting. All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you signed up for email alerts from
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
Our mailing address is:
FAIRNESS & ACCURACY IN REPORTING
124 W. 30th Street, Suite 201
New York, NY 10001
FAIR's Website ([link removed])
FAIR counts on your support to do this work — please donate today ([link removed]) .
Follow us on Twitter ([link removed]) | Friend us on Facebook ([link removed])
change your preferences ([link removed])
Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp
[link removed]
unsubscribe ([link removed]) .
