The Topline

Warnings from our retired military leaders this week are a signal of how dangerous the situation in our country has become, with the prospects growing for escalated government abuses of power against the people. The stunningly direct rebuke of Donald Trump by his former Secretary of Defense, Gen. James Mattis, is especially striking, given the high esteem in which Mattis is held not only within the military community but also among the general public, both at home and abroad. Military leaders are notoriously reticent, and they rarely, if ever, comment on political matters. That they are speaking out now should alert us to the real peril facing our democracy. We ought to listen. —Evan McMullin

Top Ten

Click here for shareable version


1. When Mattis talks, people listen

And did he ever talk last night. The former defense secretary has kept studiously silent since he resigned in December 2018 over President Trump's Syria policy. Until last night, this is. In an extraordinary broadside, he defended the Americans protesting the mistreatment of African Americans by law enforcement, and excoriated the use of the military against them. He also wrote, "Donald Trump is the first president in my lifetime who does not try to unite the American people—does not even pretend to try. Instead he tries to divide us. We are witnessing the consequences of three years of this deliberate effort. We are witnessing the consequences of three years without mature leadership. We can unite without him, drawing on the strengths inherent in our civil society. This will not be easy, as the past few days have shown, but we owe it to our fellow citizens; to past generations that bled to defend our promise; and to our children." Preach, General. —The Atlantic
More: Ahmaud Arbery was hit with a truck before he died, and his killer allegedly used a racial slur, investigator testifies (CNN)

3. Qualified immunity comes under fire

In 1982, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that government officials were entitled to "qualified immunity" from civil rights lawsuits if their actions didn't violate "clearly established" rights. Holding police officers accountable for fatal actions has proven difficult due to this narrow legal rule. But on Sunday, Rep. Justin Amash proposed the End Qualified Immunity Act, which would eliminate a "permanent procedural roadblock for plaintiffs" that thwarts them from "obtaining damages for having their rights violated." —Forbes

4. Press freedoms under attack

Attacks on journalists and other violations of press freedom have been on the rise in recent weeks, according to the Freedom of the Press Foundation. The uptick in violations comes as more reporters cover the growing number of protests nationwide over the murder of George Floyd.
More: Graham: I am a journalist who was arrested for doing my job (Richmond County Daily Journal)

"Blaming 'the media' is...sloppy thinking. Which media entity do you mean? What are you blaming them for? Why do you think it's their fault? If someone can answer those questions, then a sensible conversation can ensue. Indeed, we should have informed debates about whether a particular broadcast was biased or a specific article was accurate. But when we descend to generalized accusations against the media, we no longer have any idea what we're talking about.

The bigger problem, though, is that talking about the media makes scapegoating extremely easy. Precisely because we don't know who 'the media' are, we can blame them for everything, like a child who attributes anything that goes wrong to his imaginary friend. And that's dangerous because real human beings pay the cost for that fantasy." —The Detroit News


Ed. Note: Len Niehoff is a professor at the University of Michigan Law School.
Share Topline

6. Remember the coronavirus? It hasn't gone away

Though the nation's attention has been diverted by protests and unrest over the past week, the coronavirus hasn't gone anywhere. As of last night, there were 1,851,520 cases of COVID-19 in the U.S. (an increase of 19,699 from Tuesday) and 107,175 deaths attributed to the virus (an increase of 995 from Tuesday). Health experts worry our collective distraction could make it worse. —Johns Hopkins University COVID-19 Dashboard
More: Man behind Sweden's controversial virus strategy admits mistakes (Bloomberg)

8. Senate holds hearing on Trump-Russia probe

The Senate Judiciary Committee held its first hearing yesterday in its investigation of the FBI probe targeting links between the Trump campaign and Russia. During his testimony, former Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein defended his decision to appoint Robert Mueller as special counsel, but testified that he would not have signed an application to renew a wiretap on former Trump adviser Carter Page if he had known that it contained factual errors and omissions.
More: Senate panel approves legislation requiring campaigns to report foreign election help (CNN)

9. Applebaum: History will judge the complicit

"In due course, historians will write the story of our era and draw lessons from it, just as we write the history of the 1930s, or of the 1940s. The Miłoszes and the Hoffmanns of the future will make their judgments with the clarity of hindsight. They will see, more clearly than we can, the path that led the U.S. into a historic loss of international influence, into economic catastrophe, into political chaos of a kind we haven’t experienced since the years leading up to the Civil War. Then maybe [Sen. Lindsey] Graham—along with Pence, Pompeo, McConnell, and a whole host of lesser figures—will understand what he has enabled." —The Atlantic


More: Boot: The entire Republican Party is complicit in the assault on Lafayette Square (The Washington Post)

10. An American Story: The cure for a ruff day

Ezra, a four-year-old Golden Retriever, works as a comfort dog at Lutheran Church Charities in Toledo, Ohio, to help victims of crime. While the pandemic has hindered Ezra's work, he is still finding ways to virtually connect with people all over the country, including many working on the frontlines.
Ed. Note: We are spotlighting ways that Americans are helping each other through the coronavirus crisis and recent unrest. Would you like to suggest an "American Story" from your local news? If so, please forward a link to the story to [email protected]. Thank you!
What's Your Take?

I witnessed firsthand yesterday evening the density and diversity of security personnel stationed throughout our nation's capital in support of the president's vow to "dominate" protesters. The only consistent element was the National Guard units in regular uniforms with ID patches, rank indicators, and unit insignia. Capitol Police were easily identified as well, but there were enormous numbers of "irregulars" wearing combat helmets and body armor but with no visible identifying markings. It looked like a mall ninja convention.

For reference, see here:
News outlets say that President Trump has pulled in law enforcement officers from across the spectrum of federal agencies, so presumably that's who I saw, but we should all be deeply alarmed by this because it has the potential to go disastrously wrong.

On the one hand: with no way to identify individual officers, accountability is severely limited. If a BOP officer accustomed to handling hardened convicts beats up my 120-lb. daughter, how are we to identify who he was and prosecute him?

On the other hand: since they have no official identifiers proclaiming them to be law enforcement officers, anyone can dress up in combat gear and pass themselves off as a federal officer. If you don't have a badge or patch claiming you're an officer, and don't say you're an officer, it's not a crime.

We've already got a multitude of documented incidents of violent agitators infiltrating peaceful protests to create chaos. We've seen "protesters" turn out with guns and body armor to oppose COVID-19 restrictions. Now Trump has set the stage for anyone in combat gear to be able to blend in with law enforcement officers and turn peaceful protests violent.

There's a small but determined minority of modern anarchists and other self-styled revolutionaries lurking in the dark corners of the Internet (search for "boogaloo"/"big Igloo"/"Big Luau" to learn more) who are looking for an opportunity to start a civil war. I fear that the president has just served one up on a golden platter.

I urge all of us to contact our elected representatives and demand emergency legislation requiring that federal officers on-duty in public bear conspicuous identification of their agency and badge number. —Mike A., Maryland

Click here to tell us what you think about today's stories.

Got feedback about THE TOPLINE? Send it to Melissa Amour, Managing Editor, at [email protected].

Donate

Did you receive this email from a friend? Subscribe here.







This email was sent to [email protected]
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
The Topline · 700 Pennsylvania Ave SE · Washington, DC 20003-2493 · USA