[[link removed]]

TRUMP VOWED TO CLEAN UP WASHINGTON, THEN HIS TEAM HIRED A MAN WHO
PUSHED A SCAM THE IRS CALLED THE “WORST OF THE WORST”  
[[link removed]]


 

Peter Elkind
February 18, 2025
ProPublica
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ Frank Schuler was a leading promoter of a tax deduction derided as
a scam by prosecutors, senators and the IRS. Now he’s a senior
adviser to the General Services Administration, which manages the
federal government’s property. _

The General Services Administration building, Caroline
Brehman/CQ-Roll Call/Getty Images

 

_ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom. Sign
up for The Big Story newsletter
[[link removed]]
to receive stories like this one in your inbox_.

Even as he has vowed
[[link removed]]
to eliminate “every dollar of waste, fraud, and abuse
[[link removed]]
across the federal budget and operations,” the new acting
administrator of the General Services Administration, Stephen Ehikian,
has appointed a senior adviser whose firm used to specialize in tax
transactions that a bipartisan Senate committee excoriated and that
the IRS branded as “abusive
[[link removed]]”
and among “the worst of the worst tax scams
[[link removed]].” The adviser has been
battling the tax agency in court over $4 billion in disallowed
deductions for thousands of his clients.

The GSA, the federal agency responsible for managing the
government’s land and property, will now be taking advice from Frank
Schuler IV, the 57-year-old co-founder and longtime president of
Ornstein-Schuler, an Atlanta-based real estate investment company.
Schuler’s firm was for years among the most prolific promoters
[[link removed]]
of tax-shelter deals known as “syndicated conservation easements.”

Schuler and his colleagues exploited a tax deduction that was created
to reward landowners who give up development rights for their acreage,
usually by donating those rights to a nonprofit land trust. When used
as intended, conservation easements can preserve pristine land,
sometimes as a park that the public can use, and reward the land donor
with a charitable tax deduction.

But middlemen like Schuler’s firm turned the tax provision into a
highly profitable business, packaging easements into what were
essentially outsized tax deductions for purchase. After snatching up a
cheap piece of vacant land, Schuler and others typically hired a
private appraiser willing to declare that the property had huge
untapped development value — that it was suited to become anything
from a gravel mine to a luxury resort — and was worth many times its
purchase price. They then sold stakes in the easement donation to rich
individuals, who claimed wildly inflated tax deductions based on the
appraisal, cutting their taxes by twice as much as they’d invested.
ProPublica first began investigating the syndicated easement business,
which has cost the government tens of billions in tax revenue
[[link removed]],
back in 2017.

The IRS, the Justice Department and Congress struggled for years,
through public warnings, hundreds of audits, tax court cases and
criminal prosecutions, to shut down the scheme. Those efforts were
countered by $11 million in lobbying expenditures from the promoters
and the creation of a Washington-based trade group, called Partnership
for Conservation, which Schuler founded. Syndication advocates pressed
Congress to defund the IRS crackdown
[[link removed]].

In 2020, the Senate Finance Committee released a bipartisan
investigative report
[[link removed]]
on the transactions. (Schuler was one of six people subpoenaed by the
committee
[[link removed]]
to provide information.) The report, which detailed
Ornstein-Schuler’s practices, described syndicated easements as a
“dollar machine” for wealthy taxpayers, saving them two dollars in
taxes for every dollar they put in, “with promoters pocketing
millions of dollars in fees for organizing the deals.” The practice
was finally curbed through legislation passed in late 2022, but it
remains on the IRS’ “Dirty Dozen” list
[[link removed]]
of “bogus tax avoidance strategies.”

“This is someone who made his money by ripping off American
taxpayers and who shouldn’t come anywhere near a position of
authority over tax dollars,” commented Sen. Ron Wyden, the Oregon
Democrat who helped oversee the Senate investigation, in a written
statement after being told about Schuler’s appointment. “He’ll
fit right in with the Trump administration.”

Schuler’s exact role in the government is unclear. A GSA staffer
said that he was present on a recent 15-minute video “check-in”
conducted by Nate Cavanaugh, a 28-year-old who ProPublica has
identified as being part of Elon Musk’s DOGE team
[[link removed]]. Cavanaugh
introduced Schuler, who said little, as “my colleague Frank.”

Schuler’s photo and contact information were also listed last week
in the agency’s internal staff directory shortly after his profile
disappeared from the Ornstein-Schuler website. But it’s unknown
whether he’s a paid government employee or a volunteer associated
with Elon Musk’s DOGE effort. Schuler and Matt Ornstein did not
respond to calls, messages and emails seeking comment. The GSA and
Ehikian did not respond to emails sent to the agency’s press office.

In the past, Schuler has described his tax transactions as legitimate
and well intentioned. In a 2017 interview with ProPublica, he said his
entry into the business of syndicating easements was the result of a
personal epiphany sparked when his toddler son compared the paving of
a residential development to pollution. As Schuler described it,
“The importance of conserving land for him and future generations
really pushed me to this point. … That’s why today I’m so
passionate about conservation.”

Ornstein-Schuler dropped out of the syndicated-easement business in
2019, citing “recent developments and the uncertainty related to the
conservation and gifting of property.” The firm turned to other real
estate and tax realms, including launching a new division to buy and
sell Georgia state film tax credits
[[link removed]].
Schuler also reportedly earned a credit as an executive producer on a
film in which Mira Sorvino played an AI home security system
[[link removed]].
(Ornstein, who’s still CEO of Ornstein-Schuler, also co-founded a
private equity firm, whose holdings include a chain of dental offices
[[link removed]] and a chain of car
washes.)

But the legal warfare over Ornstein-Schuler’s tax-avoidance business
continues today. According to a recent IRS filing, the firm has filed
more than 100 tax court cases involving its transactions, contesting
more than $4 billion in disallowed charitable deductions from some
2,000 investors. Many of the cases are still pending. Ornstein-Schuler
has made long-running efforts to reach a global settlement with the
IRS; another filing includes an August 2022 letter
[[link removed]]
from one of its law firms asserting that such an agreement would clear
the way for collection of $1.5 billion in taxes and would personally
cost Schuler and his partner approximately $150 million in additional
taxes, interest and penalties.

A tax court decision handed down last year resolved the first of
Schuler’s cases to actually go to trial, involving multiple
conservation easements from 2014 on 4,607 acres in rural Alabama. The
promoters claimed that the potential for sand and gravel mining
justified a total of $187 million in charitable deductions. Investor
promotional materials, evidence showed, projected $200,000 in tax
savings for every $100,000 invested. The decision, which resolved 13
linked cases involving the property, backed the IRS, disallowing about
$180 million of the $187 million in write-offs and imposing 40%
“gross valuation misstatement” penalties on most of the disallowed
amounts. The judge found that partnerships promoted by Schuler had
claimed deductions as high as $50,000 an acre on land that had been
purchased less than a year earlier for $2,200 an acre.

In his opinion
[[link removed]],
Albert Lauber, a senior judge in U.S. Tax Court, pointedly noted how
Ornstein-Schuler’s standard pitch of promising investors $2 in tax
savings for every $1 they invested assumed he’d obtain a sky-high
property appraisal, generating a profitable investor write-off.
“When asked at trial how he could have posited in advance a
deduction-to-investment ratio of $4.389 to $1, before any appraisals
had been performed, Mr. Schuler said that appraisals were basically
irrelevant to the tax write-off they were offering,” the judge
wrote. He called the land values Schuler’s firm had claimed
“wholly implausible.”

“We were making plenty of money,” Schuler testified during the
case. “The investors were doing well. And we felt that it was great
that land was being conserved.”

Ornstein-Schuler is also among the defendants in a federal
class-action suit in Georgia filed by three investors. The suit claims
Ornstein-Schuler collaborated with lawyers, accountants, appraisers
and others to collect millions in fees through a “fraudulent
scheme” that deployed “a mountain of misrepresentations and
omissions” to promote invalid easement deductions based on
“egregiously inflated appraisals.” Ornstein-Schuler and other
defendants have filed a joint motion to dismiss the case, asserting
that the risks of the easement investments were fully disclosed and
they misled no one.

Ornstein-Schuler has also gone on the attack. In December 2023, it
sued the IRS, claiming that the agency had failed to respond to a
Freedom of Information Act request for an array of agency documents.
The firm complained of “IRS abuses relating to its targeting of
conservation easement transactions,” which it said were part of a
“well-publicized campaign.” Among the requested documents: “all
records of communications between IRS employees and members of the
news media,” including ProPublica reporter Peter Elkind, Wall Street
Journal reporter Richard Rubin and Forbes reporter Peter Reilly,
regarding conservation easements. Rod Rosenstein, a deputy U.S.
attorney general during the first Trump administration, is
representing Ornstein-Schuler in the case.

Doris Burke [[link removed]]
contributed research. Avi Asher-Schapiro
[[link removed]] contributed
reporting.

* Donald Trump
[[link removed]]
* taxes
[[link removed]]
* #TaxScam
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]
Manage subscription
[[link removed]]
Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]