Forward this email. ([link removed])
[link removed]


** The Danger of a New Manifest Destiny
------------------------------------------------------------

How the Trump Doctrine hurts our friends, vindicates our enemies, and undermines the liberal international order.

January 23, 2025
[link removed]

By Christopher Schaefer and Sohan Mewada

On Monday, Donald Trump started his second term as President of the United States. Without wasting any time, Trump withdrew from a number of America’s international commitments. America said goodbye to the World Health Organization ([link removed]) and the Paris Agreement ([link removed]) on climate change. We may not be far from asking: is NATO next ([link removed]) ?

None of this should come as a surprise. After all, an extreme go-it-alone mentality is central to Trump’s America First foreign policy—during his first term in office, on the campaign trail, and now in the presidential transition to his second term.

But Trump’s undisciplined instincts have now coalesced into something stronger and scarier: the Trump Doctrine. His America First foreign policy now includes brazen calls for territorial expansion. Last week ([link removed]) , our colleague Evan Gottesman wrote about the true cost of Trump’s rhetoric about cajoling Denmark into ceding Greenland to the US. The key point was that if we force our allies to hand over territory, then we risk destroying America’s exceptional ability to maintain influence through partnerships rooted in mutual consent and interest. The waves caused by Trump’s Greenland gambit ([link removed]) give us a glimpse of the world in Trump’s second term.

During his inaugural address this week ([link removed]) , Trump gave us a fuller picture of his intentions, as he doubled down on taking back the Panama Canal. He also returned to outdated notions of American manifest destiny, linking a supposedly coming “golden era” with territorial expansion. “The United States will once again consider itself a growing nation, one that increases our wealth, expands our territory, builds our cities, raises our expectations and carries our flag into new and beautiful horizons,” he said. “And we will pursue our manifest destiny into the stars, launching American astronauts to plant the Stars and Stripes on the planet Mars.”

Usually we think of America First as an isolationist movement, but this is only half true. While Trump’s foreign policy abandons America’s commitments to international institutions, talk of a new manifest destiny ensures we will be more involved in the world than ever. But in perverse ways that hurt our friends and vindicate our enemies.

Cracks in the Old World Order

Under Trump, America First doesn't mean we aren’t playing the game of international relations. It means we just won't follow the rules we agreed upon with our allies nearly eighty years ago.

In 1945, the Allied nations marked the end of the Second World War by establishing a set of institutions where the behavior of nations was guided by a shared set of rules and norms rather than the threat of violence. In cooperation with our allies, the US led the construction of a better world that would attempt, as the historian Max Boot has put it ([link removed]) , to “defend and extend the sphere of liberal democracies around the world and to build a world where disputes are resolved peacefully and amicably and not at gunpoint.”

Territorial expansion fundamentally undermines the liberal system. Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014 and its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 are the greatest examples of this challenge to the liberal order.

As Martin Kimani, the Kenyan UN ambassador at the time, noted in his country’s opposition to Russian aggression in 2022, many countries have good reasons to seek different borders, especially in post-colonial Africa. But, in order to avoid unnecessary conflict, his country chose instead to accept the borders that they inherited while seeking cooperation with other countries where possible.

What was true for Kenya after independence was also true for Russia three years ago, and it is still true for the United States under Donald Trump now. Trump, who now openly advocates for territorial expansion, is running roughshod over this shared consensus of how nations ought to behave. He is embracing a certain relativism in international affairs, accepting in principle a division of the world into spheres of influence.

“Beyond stimulating anti-American nationalism in the hemisphere, such a throwback policy would legitimate efforts by China, Russia, and potentially other regional powers to pursue spheres of influence in their own neighborhoods,” writes ([link removed]) Stewart Patrick, a senior fellow and director of the Global Order and Institutions Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

The Cost of Just Doing it for the Deal

In response to these criticisms of territorial expansion, Trump’s allies may retort, “Well, he won’t actually annex any countries; it’s all a negotiation ploy.” And to be fair, it is possible Trump won’t carry through on his threats, either because it is just a ploy or perhaps because he lacks the capacity to carry through.

But President Trump is playing with fire. Even if the United States doesn't gain more territory but uses the threat to gain an extra base on Greenland, trade concessions from Denmark, and greater influence over the Panama Canal, Trump will have further normalized bad behavior for authoritarians and wannabe dictators.

The threat of territorial expansion will compel even our allies with a show of raw power.

It is not clear where that conflagration may end or what it means for the liberal international order. But when we dispense with the rules that guide international relations, our destiny is no longer in our own hands.




** The Bottom Line
------------------------------------------------------------

1. What’s different this time?

Unlike eight years ago, this time Donald Trump knows how to get sh** done ([link removed]) , substantively and symbolically, observes David Sanger in the New York Times.

Four years ago, many Republicans found the events of January 6, 2021, to be tragic; now they uniformly toe Trump’s line. Even Republicans who said the violent January 6th protesters should stay behind bars are now mum on Trump’s blanket pardon—a huge blow to the rule of law ([link removed]) in the United States, according to the editors at The Free Press.

MAGA doesn’t actually value law enforcement ([link removed]) , writes Tom Nichols in The Atlantic, especially when it comes to rule of law regarding January 6.

Trump has surrounded himself with a team of billionaires, but, according to Francis Fukuyama, one merits particular attention: Elon Musk is turning into a full-fledged oligarch ([link removed]) , the sage of liberal politics opines. Musk mixes wealth and power in a way that resembles Silvio Berlusconi or any number of Russian oligarchs.

2. The view from the frontlines

Eight years ago, Donald Trump’s arrival in the White House was met globally with a heavy dose of doom, gloom, and opposition. This time around, the international response is more mixed. This time around, he is a known quantity.

French President Emmanuel Macron has encouraged European countries to “wake up” and spend more money on defense ([link removed]) .

Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the President of Ukraine, similarly told the crowd at the World Economic Forum in Davos that Europe “needs to step up” ([link removed]) and take care of their own in a world where they can’t depend on the United States.

Taiwan’s President Lai Ching-te congratulated Donald Trump on his inauguration even as he fought the opposition-controlled parliament over dangerous cuts to Taiwan’s defense budget ([link removed]) .

In Israel, President Binyamin Netanyahu congratulated Trump, saying the “Best days of our alliance yet to come” while even anti-Trump voices welcomed his role in securing the recent ceasefire and hostage deal ([link removed]) .

3. What to watch for

From a plethora of executive orders to territorial expansionist rhetoric to TikTok-DNI connections ([link removed]) to unqualified and allegedly abusive nominees to potentially fascistic salutes, there was plenty of sound and fury in the first days of Trump’s second term. It’s hard to know how to separate the signal from the noise, exhausted as we all are after the past decade.

Writing in Persuasion, Damon Linker notes that the most dangerous thing to watch for during Trump 2.0 will be signs that the president or his appointees are going to actively defy a judge’s orders ([link removed]) .

Writing from Denmark, RDI Advisory Board member Anne Applebaum observes that Trump has already caused a crisis ([link removed]) in their internal politics. Will the United States further undermine our allies in Denmark and elsewhere?

Will Trump’s team double down on their claims about the insignificance of the Russian invasion of Ukraine ([link removed]) ? In short, will Trump capitulate to Putin?

At RDI, we’ll be watching all these key dynamics as they develop. We’ll continue to share our perspectives on the struggle for democracy in the months and years ahead. Please consider forwarding The Democracy Brief to a friend or family member. Or subscribe here ([link removed]) !



** ASK Garry Kasparov Anything
------------------------------------------------------------

Ask any question to Garry Kasparov ([link removed]) , RDI's founder and chairman, former world chess champion, and Russian dissident!

From his takes on the state of global democracy to his critiques of American foreign policy, Garry's analysis is always in high demand. Don’t miss this unique opportunity ([link removed]) to engage with one of the world's most sought-after thought leaders.

The answers to your questions may appear in a future edition of RDI's Democracy Brief!
Submit your question here! ([link removed])
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]

Copyright (C) 2025 Renew Democracy Initiative. All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you opted in via our website.
Our mailing address is:
Renew Democracy Initiative
1230 6th Ave
Floor 16
New York, NY 10020
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?

You can update your preferences ([link removed]) or unsubscribe ([link removed])
Logo