Index on Censorship weekly round-up

[link removed]
Latest ([link removed]) Subscribe ([link removed]) About Index ([link removed]) Donate ([link removed])
Friday, 06 December 2024
[link removed]
People blocking military vehicles in front of the National Assembly in Seoul after South Korea's President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law. Photo by SOPA Images Limited/Alamy Live News

Protests have the power to rally people, express objection to political decisions, and in the most successful cases, elicit change. They are a fundamental form of self expression, and a crucial mechanism of any democracy. This week, we saw South Koreans take to the streets to protest President Yoon Suk Yeol’s shock move to impose martial law, which temporarily placed the military in charge and suspended many civilian rights, including the right to protest.

The move was immediately declared illegal and unconstitutional. The leader of the country’s largest opposition party was able to rally MPs to vote down the declaration in parliament, and ordinary citizens to protest against it, despite the ruling that they couldn’t. Within 24 hours, Yeol’s attempt was toppled and he now faces impeachment charges.

South Korea’s bizarre turn of events shows the potential effectiveness of collective action against authoritarianism. The power of persistent campaigning was also brought to light in Iran this week, when the jailed rapper and activist Toomaj Salehi (a former winner in the arts category of Index’s Freedom of Expression Awards ([link removed]) ) was released from prison. He had previously been sentenced to death (later overturned) for voicing support for anti-government protests, including the Woman, Life, Freedom movement in 2022. Tireless international protest from campaign groups – jointly led by Index, the Human Rights Foundation and Doughty Street Chambers – undoubtedly put pressure on Iranian authorities to permit his release.

But of course, attempts to congregate against injustice are not always successful, or accepted. In Georgia this week, where we have seen a degradation of democracy under the Georgian Dream party, there was a horrendous crackdown on peaceful protesters.

Since the country’s contested election in October, where the party secured a fourth term, citizens have come out in droves and have been met with state violence, including being physically assaulted, and attacked with water cannon and tear gas. You can read more about the steady decline towards autocracy in Georgia ([link removed]) in this piece by Index CEO Jemimah Steinfeld, who visited Tbilisi in October.

This response is just one example of how peaceful protest is being eroded, despite it being protected as a human right under international law. We’re seeing examples of this all over the world. Last month, Clemence Manyukwe reported ([link removed]) for Index on how anti-government protesters in Mozambique were injured and even killed following the country’s disputed presidential election.

And even when violence isn’t used, legal mechanisms can be utilised to undermine people’s right to show dissent. On our own shores, the previous government introduced the Public Order Act, which has substantially restricted people’s ability to protest freely, and has made it easier to criminalise protesters by lowering the threshold at which police can arrest them. The result has been hundreds of activists being arrested and prosecuted, including the climate activist Greta Thunberg.

Earlier this year, the High Court found that the former home secretary Suella Braverman had acted unlawfully in introducing this legislation, but the Home Office appealed the ruling. The new Labour government has continued the appeal, which has spurred criticism from human rights organisations. Katy Watts, lawyer at Liberty, said ([link removed]) : “For the countless people currently in the over-stretched criminal justice system because of these unlawful regulations, we must see the law quashed and the government respecting our fundamental right to protest.”

Protest movements are not always against governments. Also in the UK this week, we saw a large media workers’ strike from staff at The Guardian and The Observer over the sale of The Observer to Tortoise Media, an acquisition which has proved controversial.

Whilst the sale of a business does not, on its own, represent a risk to free expression, concerns have been raised over whether there are safeguards in place to protect the newspaper’s editorial independence, as one of the few remaining liberal news outlets in the UK. There have also been concerns over the ability of company staff to speak out publicly against the deal without fear of punishment or recrimination, with some employees reporting being warned against voicing their opinions freely.

Index was one of many signatories of a letter addressed to The Scott Trust ([link removed]) – which owns the Guardian Media Group – and Tortoise raising concerns about the risks to free expression from the mechanisms of the sale. Despite the 48-hour strike, the sale went ahead this morning, indicating that protest is not always an effective mechanism for change.

But whilst it may not always result in the desired outcome, it sends a message – whether to governments or private businesses – about individuals’ rights to express their disapproval or outrage. The ability to do so without fear of criminal reprisal or violence is a fundamental right and must be protected at all costs.
Sarah Dawood is editor of Index


** Iranian rapper Toomaj Salehi released from prison
------------------------------------------------------------
[link removed] In April 2024, Iranian rapper Toomaj Salehi was sentenced to death for crimes including “corruption on earth”. He had used his music and activism to support Iranian women and human rights in Iran. In July 2024, following the launch of a campaign by Index on Censorship, Doughty Street Chambers and Human Rights Foundation, the sentence was overturned by Iran’s Supreme Court, although he remained in custody.

We are delighted that he was finally released earlier this week, after 753 days in prison – but he should have never been there in the first place.

Read our joint statement here ([link removed]) .

Photo: instagram.com/ToomajOfficial ([link removed])
Donate to Index on Censorship ([link removed])


** Index launches year-end banned books competition: Win a magazine subscription
------------------------------------------------------------
[link removed]
Can you work out the titles of these banned books from our mind-bending clues? Illustration by ImageFX

It’s that time of year again when the team at Index on Censorship brings a little light into a dark world. This year, we have delved into the mind of author Marc Nash to come up with our banned books holiday quiz. He has taken the titles of 20 books that have been banned around the world and created fiendish cryptic clues for each of the titles.

Enter the competition here. ([link removed])


** Science in Iran: A catalyst for corruption
------------------------------------------------------------
[link removed]
Iranian supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei receives the second dose of locally made Covid-19 vaccine COVIRAN Barekat. Photo by Iranian Supreme Leader's Office via ZUMA Press Wire/Alamy

Iran, a country that in its distant past played a significant role in the development of knowledge and laid the foundations upon which modern science now stands, has experienced a tremendous urge for scientific rebirth over the past century.

But Iranian scientists are facing a government that considers itself the manifestation of God’s will on Earth, that has no qualms about intimidation and oppression, and whose daily rhetoric revolves around the word “enemy”.

Read Pouria Nazemi's article here ([link removed]) .


** SLAPPs and the rule of law
------------------------------------------------------------
[link removed]
A seminar in Madrid discussing the weaponisation of the legal system by private powers. Photo by CEPC

Last week, Index on Censorship participated in the international seminar "Private Powers and Rule of Law", which was organised by the Venice Commission and the Centre for Constitutional and Political Studies (CEPC) in Madrid. Index was speaking about the weaponisation of the legal system by private powers, specifically strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs). To read more about Index's work on SLAPPs, visit: [link removed]


** The Observer: strikes as sale confirmed
------------------------------------------------------------
[link removed]
Sir Grayson Perry joins a protest about the sale of the 233-year-old Observer (Britain's oldest newspaper title) by the Scott Trust to Tortoise Media. Photo by RichardBaker / Alamy

Journalists, production staff and supporters joined an NUJ-organised 48-hour strike this week at the offices of the Observer, Britain's oldest newspaper title. The paper's owners, the Scott Trust, have just agreed to sell off the 233-year-old publication to Tortoise Media. Read what we wrote when news of the sale first emerged in September. ([link removed])


** From the Index archives
------------------------------------------------------------


** Afghan heartland
------------------------------------------------------------


** by Charlotte Cross and Banu Khetab
Autumn 2013
------------------------------------------------------------

[link removed]

This week The Afghan Times reported ([link removed]) that women in the country are no longer allowed to train to become midwives, yet another erosion of education possibilities under the Taliban.

Back in 2013, we published an article by Charlotte Cross, who was serving with the British Army in Helmand, about the opportunities and challenges for women and contrasted this with an account of Banu Khetab's life under the Taliban.

Read their article here ([link removed]) .


Help support Index on Censorship ([link removed])
Index on Censorship defends people's freedom to express themselves without fear of harm or persecution. We publish censored writers and artists, monitor and campaign against censorship, and encourage debate.

We rely on donations from readers and supporters. By donating ([link removed]) to Index you help us to protect freedom of expression and to support those who are denied that right.
[link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] ([link removed])

============================================================

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])

INDEX ON CENSORSHIP © COPYRIGHT 2024
** Privacy and Cookie Policy ([link removed])