Talking turkey about the death penalty: outgoing governors and the president must use their clemency power now

President Biden and three governors should use their clemency powers before they leave office to save the lives of people facing the death penalty, our nation’s cruelest punishment.

by Leah Wang

Every November, it has become a light-hearted tradition for the president and some governors to “pardon” turkeys before the Thanksgiving holiday, sparing them from the dinner table. But when the nation’s political leaders take part in an annual turkey pardon, it’s hard not to think about the chronic underuse of clemency powers across the U.S., especially for people on death row.

If turkey pardons are about choosing life over death, using clemency powers to empty remaining death rows is a straightforward way for elected leaders to act on those values and reject a horrific practice. President Biden and the outgoing governors of North Carolina, Indiana, and Missouri in particular can use clemency for those facing a state-sanctioned death before they leave office early next year. More than a dozen other governors can stop executions in their states, too, by exercising their unilateral power to modify or reduce criminal convictions and sentences at any time.

In this briefing, we show that the outgoing president and some governors’ tactless traditions of granting relief to turkeys casts a harsh light on their records of granting relief to people condemned to die. Ultimately, their legacies won’t be shaped by crass Thanksgiving rituals, but by how they tapped their power to intervene in the moral atrocity that is the death penalty.

A national patchwork of policy and practice leads to a geography-based punishment system for people convicted of the most serious crimes.

Outgoing political leaders can turn the page on the death penalty

In addition to being the only irreversible punishment, the death penalty — a sentencing option still on the books in 27 states and at the federal level — is widely understood as the most cruel, discriminatory, and corrupt punishment, rife with due process and human rights violations. From deep racial injustice and legal misconduct, to horrific botched executions and shadowy methods of acquiring lethal drugs, to wide public opposition to many executions, the death penalty is an unpopular and grotesque public experiment. Almost half of U.S. states have already abolished the death penalty, and many victims’ families oppose it, helping to lead the way in repeal efforts.

While the following leaders have no record of sparing anyone from the death penalty, they still have several weeks to change course; it’s customary to wait to use clemency powers until the end of a political term, as a final boost to one’s legacy without the risk of political blowback. (And former leaders following custom have used clemency for people on death row, sometimes with a blanket commutation, converting all death sentences to life in prison.) But as the holiday and family-gathering season kicks off, the choice to ignore death row and spare a turkey instead is no act of festive good will.

President Joe Biden

Although he’s extended pardons and commutations during his term, President Joe Biden has yet to use his clemency powers for a person facing the federal death penalty, despite openly opposing capital punishment at one time. Biden can still heed increasing calls from advocates to improve his minimal clemency record and clear federal death row of all 40 current death sentences.

But Biden does pardon condemned turkeys, issuing a pair of pardons each year he’s been President. These fowl, by the names of Peanut Butter and Jelly (2021), Chocolate and Chip (2022), and Liberty and Bell (2023), are greeted in Washington with pomp and circumstance, and are returned to their home pastures under the care of animal experts.

Given that president-elect Donald Trump enthusiastically supports the death penalty — and has historically abused the pardon power — President Biden could spare 40 lives immediately and reclaim the true function of clemency by commuting all federal death sentences.

Governor Roy Cooper, North Carolina

Governor Roy Cooper has only used clemency sparingly throughout his eight-year term. But even after issuing relief to several people just before Thanksgiving — including five people convicted of murder — the outgoing governor has withheld clemency from everyone on North Carolina’s death row, which has the fifth-highest death row population as of January 2024 with 138 people condemned to die.

Governor Cooper has, however, consistently pardoned turkeys, showing mercy toward at least eight birds since he took office. During the most recent pardoning event in 2022, Gov. Cooper told spectators that “Thanksgiving is a time to come together and appreciate the many blessings our families, friends and communities have to offer.” These words would be just as appropriate for sparing human life.

The North Carolina Coalition for Alternatives to the Death Penalty has been in Governor Cooper’s ear since 2022, when they launched a campaign calling on him to empty the state’s death row, commuting all sentences to prison terms before his term is over. He still has time to heed their advice.

Governor Eric Holcomb, Indiana

Indiana’s Governor Holcomb has a weak record for granting clemency, but could spare the eight individuals on Indiana’s death row with the stroke of a pen, including one man scheduled to be put to death in December — resuming executions in the state after more than a decade.

Notably, Holcomb governs a state with a legacy of rethinking death sentences: According to the Indiana Public Defender Council, more than half of all death sentences handed down in the Hoosier State since 1977 have been commuted, reversed, or dismissed, with Indiana governors taking clemency action as recently as 2005. And between 2000 and 2015, few cases that initially sought the death penalty actually resulted in a death sentence.

We couldn’t find evidence of Gov. Holcomb participating in a turkey pardon during his time in office. If he refrains this year, he should have plenty of time to acknowledge Indiana’s de facto moratorium on death sentences and extend clemency to the eight people on Indiana’s “X Row.”

Governor Mike Parson, Missouri

Governor Mike Parson of Missouri is leaving office after nearly seven years with a decent clemency record, having cleared a backlog of over 3,500 clemency applications. It’s unclear, though unlikely, whether Gov. Parson has ever commuted a death sentence; the clemency data produced by the governor’s office do not include crime or sentencing information. Nor could we find evidence of Parson participating in a Thanksgiving turkey pardon.

Considering Gov. Parson’s record of harmful policies, like bans on nearly all abortions and on gender-affirming care for minors, it seems unlikely that he would consider saving the lives of the dozen men on Missouri’s death row. Parson has overseen the executions of 12 people during his tenure as governor, including the execution of Johnny Johnson, a man with serious mental illness whose clemency was supported by his victim’s own father, and Marcellus Williams, whose advocates included prosecutors and the victim’s family.

As Parson considers his gubernatorial legacy, he should continue to use his unilateral clemency power for the Missourians who deserve better than the abhorrent practice of taxpayer-funded executions.

We applaud elected leaders when they use clemency to relieve people of excessive or unnecessary criminal sentences. But too often, they overlook those given the most draconian punishment on the books. Only a consistent practice of commuting death sentences and issuing pardons can combat the horrifying persistence of the death penalty. With Thanksgiving right around the corner, and their days in office numbered, outgoing leaders can spare human beings, rather than just birds.

***

For more information, including detailed footnotes, see the full version of this briefing on our website.