John,
With all the focus on the incoming Trump administration this past week, it’s easy to forget something basic but important about how our government works: It’s made up of three co-equal branches.
We’re about to see that in action as the Senate takes on its job to review President-elect Trump’s cabinet picks in the months ahead.
The President gets to nominate whoever he wants, but it’s the Senate’s job to give advice and consent. That’s not just a rubber stamp—it’s a constitutional check.
As Alexander Hamilton explained in Federalist 76, the Senate’s role in confirming presidential nominees is to stop “unfit characters” from taking on roles they’re not suited for.
This week, we saw exactly the kind of person Hamilton warned about: Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz, who’s being put forth as the potential next Attorney General.
Make no mistake—Matt Gaetz shouldn’t be anywhere near the Attorney General job especially not at a moment when Americans have so little trust in the integrity and fairness of our justice system.
The Attorney General is America’s top law enforcement officer, in charge of everything from prosecuting crimes to protecting civil rights and safeguarding national security. The person in this job must have an unmatched understanding and respect for the law. Their character must be beyond reproach and they need to convince Americans across the political spectrum they will administer justice fairly and without the influence of politics.
Yet Matt Gaetz has built his entire public career and political persona around demonizing his political opponents. He only practiced law for two years and has never argued a federal case, led a major legal team, or been involved in complex constitutional or civil rights issues.
He is not fit to be Attorney General of the United States.
The good news is that some senators still take their advice and consent responsibility seriously. Amid rumors that Gaetz could somehow bypass Senate confirmation, Senators like Susan Collins, Thom Tillis and John Cornyn made clear they expect him to go through the same rigorous vetting as any other nominee.
They’re right to demand answers, and more Senators should speak up about any concerns they have.
What do you think?