[[link removed]]

STANDARDIZED TESTS AND THE EUGENICS MOVEMENT  
[[link removed]]


 

Doug Selwyn
November 1, 2024
Greenfield Recorder
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ A brief reflection on standardized testing: And how it is a direct
outgrowth of the early 20th-century eugenics movement _

Doug Selwyn, Contributed photo/Trish Crapo

 

Most of the children in my fourth/fifth grade class came from homes in
which they did not speak English and came from cultures foreign to the
one in which they were now living.

We had spent the year in our classroom focused on what we collectively
valued most: pursuing our questions, concerns, and interests; learning
how to work together and to communicate as speakers and listeners;
learning how to carry out research and how to make use of the skills
we learned, to make things better for ourselves and for our learning
community. We addressed the academic basics through projects, topics
that were of interest and relevance for the children, and which
allowed them to communicate what they knew and had learned through a
range of modalities. They did not bubble in any circles.

I did offer them a two-week course, “testing as a foreign
language,” in hopes of helping them learn how tests work, to become
familiar with the kinds of questions they were likely to encounter,
and to acquire some test-taking strategies. They created tests about
Pokémon, which was popular at the time, and the students
“administered” their tests to the adults in the school. The
students enjoyed the experience and truly enjoyed that we adults
failed miserably. But that did not fully prepare them (or me) for what
was to come.

These children, who had demonstrated their intelligence, their skills,
their compassion, their problem-solving abilities, their caring and
respect for themselves and others, their critical thinking, their
resilience in dealing with the extraordinary ups and downs that many
families of recent immigrant as well as many non-immigrant families
face, hit an impenetrable wall with the tests, which many were taking
in their second or third language.

Just that fact alone, that children who could speak two or three
languages were more likely to fail or struggle than children who only
spoke English, made clear how wrong these tests were.

Watching the students dissolve into tears and sink into their chairs
in utter frustration as they tried to negotiate page after page of
contextless test questions broke my heart, and made me wonder why
these harmful, destructive tests existed at all. I decided to look
into the history of standardized tests and how they came to be as they
are.

It turns out that standardized testing actually began in France.
Alfred Binet, a psychologist, devised the Binet scale of intelligence
that would help educators to identify how best to serve very young
children from impoverished homes who were coming to school in Paris.
He designed his test to help assess the current intellectual abilities
of those young children as they entered school and he believed that
their intellectual abilities could be improved with good teaching and
support.

U.S. cognitive psychologists Henry Goddard, Lewis Terman, and Robert
Yerkes had a very different agenda as they transformed Binet’s work
to fit their race and class politics at the turn of the 20th century.
They were a part of the eugenicist movement, a movement that believed
intelligence was fixed for life and was a result of heredity.
Eugenicists were convinced that the human race would be improved if
those with good genes (white Anglo-Saxon Protestants, like themselves)
would reproduce more, and those with inferior genes (people from
southern Europe, African Americans, Jews, other people of color) would
reproduce less.

In 1917, Yerkes worked with Goddard, Terman, and others to develop the
Alpha and Beta Army tests to sort incoming soldiers and to determine
their “mental fitness.” Yerkes drew several dubious conclusions,
including that the intelligence of European immigrants could be judged
according to their country of origin. He “found” that peoples of
eastern and southern Europe were less intelligent than their white,
western and northern European counterparts, and that African Americans
were the least intelligent of all people, and they ended up being
sorted onto the front lines as cannon fodder during World War I. Those
from northern and western backgrounds were more often sorted into the
officer corps.

The test that Terman designed produced the same results as the army
tests, identifying people of eastern and southern Europe descent and
African Americans into the least intelligent category. These tests led
to the belief that it was possible to measure intelligence and reduce
it to a single number and that this intelligence measure was fixed,
unchangeable, and based on heredity. This testing led to the tracking
of large numbers of students into an educational sequence that
prepared them for low level work, while advanced classes were reserved
for students from white, western and northern European backgrounds. It
also led to 30 states making forced sterilization legal. More than
70,000 women and men from those “inferior” groups were the victims
of forced sterilization in the first half of the 20th century,
legitimized by the Supreme Court in its 1927 Buck v. Bell decision.

What makes a test a standardized test?

Standardized testing is a direct outgrowth of the eugenics movement
and its assumptions that intelligence can be reduced to a number, that
there is one way to be intelligent, and that the purpose of testing is
to sort and rank students. A test is considered a standardized test if
it offers the test to all in exactly the same way: same questions,
same instructions (including what to do when students throw up on the
test), same time constraints, and same scoring routines, so that the
results can be compared. The questions are mostly multiple choice so
that they can be scored easily and quickly, and they are mostly
comprised of questions that have one right answer, which discourages
complexity or multiple points of view or ways of understanding.

There is a direct contradiction between high stakes testing and state
standards. If everyone passes the test or the tests don’t provide
the desired scores, the tests are revised until they “perform” as
they should, with the right number of students passing and the right
number failing. In Massachusetts, those students who fail the MCAS
(our standardized test) do not receive their diplomas, even if they
have met the state’s educational standards. Does this make sense?

I also note that private schools are not required to administer
standardized tests. If the tests truly enhanced the learning of their
students, these private, well-endowed schools would surely offer the
opportunity to their children.

The evidence is clear: those who struggle most on these tests are
students like mine — second, or third language learners, students of
color, students with learning challenges, and students living in
poverty — the very categories that Terman, Yerkes, and their
eugenicist colleagues designed their tests to identify as inferior
more than 100 years ago.

While the eugenics movement continues to cast a long shadow over
public education, significant steps have been taken over the years to
bring greater equity and justice to all students. Clearly there is
more work to be done, beginning with reducing the power and impact
that standardized testing plays in education. One way to do that is to
remove standardized tests as a high school graduation requirement, an
act that Massachusetts voters are seeking to do this year.

_Doug Selwyn taught at K-12 public schools from 1985 until 2000 and
then at university as a professor of education until he retired in
2017. He is the chair of the Franklin County Continuing the Political
Revolution education task force. You can reach him at
[email protected]._

* Education
[[link removed]]
* Standardized Tests
[[link removed]]
* Racism
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]
Manage subscription
[[link removed]]
Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]