In a significant defeat for the assisted suicide movement, the Welsh Assembly (Senedd) decisively voted (26 to 19) against a motion urging Westminster to legalise assisted suicide. This decision underscores the Senedd's clear stance against allowing MPs to impose assisted suicide on Wales when the British Parliament votes next month (29 November) on the Assisted Suicide Bill introduced by Kim Leadbeater MP.
Both the Welsh First Minister, Eluned Morgan, and the Secretary for Health and Social Care, Jeremy Miles, opposed the motion. Members from all major partiesāincluding Labour, the Liberal Democrats, Plaid Cymru, and the Conservativesāexpressed their opposition during the vote.
Numerous members voiced their concerns against the introduction of assisted suicide during the debate. Delyth Jewell, a Plaid Cymru member for South Wales East, expressed her fears, stating, "My terror regarding this motion lies not in how it starts, but in how it ends." She noted that while there are purported safeguards in Westminster's proposal, historical precedents from countries like Canada, the Netherlands, and Belgium reveal that no safeguard is truly secure. "Laws are initially aimed at the terminally ill, but over time, those safeguards erode, leading to individuals with treatable conditions being eligibleālives that might improve instead being lost."
Indeed, the Canadian example highlights how an initially limited regime can rapidly expand.
Already in 2022, 9% of those who were euthanised in Canada had dementia. On 30 October, Quebec removed the requirement for informed consent immediately prior to the lethal injection which will drastically increase the premature deaths of those with dementia.
The DĆ”il recently voted in 23 October to ānoteā the Report of the Joint Committee on Assisted Dying, which may be interpreted as adding momentum to the reportās pro-assisted dying proposals.
The Welsh vote was a major setback to the momentum of the pro-assisted dying movement in advance of the upcoming Westminster vote.