|
Quotation of the Day…
Posted: 14 Aug 2019 02:51 AM PDT
(Don Boudreaux)
… is from page 258 of George Will’s 2019 book, The Conservative Sensibility:
Marx, a Victorian intellectual, predicted that capitalism would be undone by its immiseration of the proletariat. Actually, capitalism has done more to jeopardize itself by annoying intellectuals. Many of them look down their upturned noses at the marketplace, and therefore at those who thrive in it. The intellectuals’ disdain is a manifestation of resentment about the fact that markets generally function nicely without the supervision of intellectuals.

|
|
Bonus Quotation of the Day…
Posted: 13 Aug 2019 05:46 PM PDT
(Don Boudreaux)
… is from page 32 of my late Nobel-laureate colleague Jim Buchanan’s 1997 paper “There Is a Science of Economics,” as this paper is reprinted in Economic Inquiry and Its Logic (2000), which is volume 12 of the Collected Works of James M. Buchanan (original emphasis):
If economics is to be compared with natural science, economists should be able to define what can and cannot be done with the human materials and potential that exist. Economists, and economic science, should generate a feasibility space, fully analogous to that generated for the physical universe by natural science.
DBx: Yes. Indisputably so. Reality isn’t optional.
Yet how many are those who, proud of their respect for the natural sciences, never dream of denying the constraints identified by the natural sciences, but think nothing of denying the constraints identified by economic science?
People cheer when the likes of Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren announce schemes to generate outcomes the achievement of which are wholly inconsistent not only with human nature but, often, even with arithmetic. And the great irony is that these cheering deniers of reality are especially prone to fancy themselves as being unusually clear-eyed and objective disciples of science.
The main and seemingly endless task of good economists is to remind people that two plus two never equals any sum greater than four, that to transfer a loaf from somewhere to Sam’s plate means that there’s at least one less loaf for Jane or Joe or Junior who reside in somewhere, and that the same human imperfections that cause markets to operate in less-than-heavenly fashions do not disappear, or even diminish, when humans are given the power of the state to “correct” these market “imperfections.”

|
|
Fishy
Posted: 13 Aug 2019 02:25 PM PDT
(Don Boudreaux)
My long-time and very dear friend Kerry Dugas – we met in 1972 as freshmen at Archbishop Shaw High School – works at Sysco Foods in New Orleans. He just wrote to inform me of a new piece of protectionist legislation enacted by the solons of Louisiana. It sports the informal moniker “Crawfish and Shrimp Menu Labeling Act.”

Here’s the text of Kerry’s e-mail to me:
Up until now, patrons of Louisiana restaurants were ignorant victims of sinister imported seafood merchants.
A big thanks to the Louisiana Dept. of Health Information and Act 372, enforcing the labeling of Crawfish and Shrimp served in Louisiana restaurants as to their source.
This is, of course, the eventual outcome of local lobbies petitioning The State to protect the local fisherman, trawlers and Crawfish Farmers. What they choose NOT to recognize is that the influx of imported shrimp and crawfish into the market ENHANCED the use of these items in menus – shining new uses of crawfish and shrimp. In our day you wouldn’t see a dish of crawfish and grits. BBQ’d shrimp wasn’t a “thing”. And does the public care one way or the other? When I worked those two years at Wal Mart in the meat dept., we stocked frozen crawfish tails. Imports would fly off the shelves while the domestic product sat.
Is the local product better than imports? Chinese crawfish tend to be rubbery and fatless, too clean. Spanish packers produce crawfish tail with fat, protecting the flavor and providing less of a bouncy chew. Imports have gotten better. Yes, Louisiana crawfish are superior in quality and flavor, but depending on the application. That quality can get lost in the dish. Would be like using top shelf superior Tequila in a Margarita, the nuances of the fine tequila get lost with the lime juice.
Local seafood providers could and should promote, proclaim that theirs is better through public education and working a cooperative. Come up with a Local Seafood logo to be placed on menus, much like the Certified Angus Beef (CAB) label used by cattle farmers. Proclaim who THEY are, not who the other guys aren’t.
But no. We just pass a law.
Kerry
Well said, my wise and astute ami (except, stop calling legislation “law”!).
Despite being born and bred a city boy and having neither interest in, nor aptitude for, huntin’, trapin’, or fishin’, I’m rather proud of my cajun heritage. (My paternal grandfather, Adrian Boudreaux, born on a bayou in 1900, wasn’t fluent in English until after he ran away from home in 1915 to New Orleans.) But that pride dims more than modestly when I encounter this sort of greedy use of state power by my cajun cousins to gain an artificial competitive advantage in the market.
Down with protectionnisme glouton!

|
|
Some Links
Posted: 13 Aug 2019 05:04 AM PDT
(Don Boudreaux)
Citing the work of my Mercatus Center colleagues Adam Thierer and Andrea O’Sullivan, James Pethokoukis continues his valiant effort to expose the fallacies and dangers that lurk in today’s efforts by conservatives to have government censor on-line platforms. Here’s his concluding paragraph:
The big question: Do we really want a group of political appointees getting more involved in regulating internet speech? As former FTC Commissioner Joushua Wright tweeted about a bill from Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) that would have the agency certify social media companies as bias free if they wanted to keep their Section 230 shield: “ . . . the bill quite literally injects a board of bureaucrats into millions of decisions about internet content. This is central planning. Full stop.”
Several weeks ago, National Review‘s Charles Cooke ably defended classical liberalism against bogus charges leveled against it by many conservatives. (HT Dan Klein)
Alberto Mingardi laments – yet draws lessons from – the recent decline in conservatives’ commitment to freedom.
Kevin Williamson celebrates economic growth, dynamism, and creative destruction.
Jeffrey Tucker and Peter Earle celebrate the trade revolution that began in 1948 – and that might now, dangerously, be coming to a end. A slice:
It was through [U.S. Secretary of State Cordell] Hull’s efforts, backed by centuries of economic thought and a near consensus in the profession since the 19th century, that the United States led the world towards ever freer trade. It’s been this way for 85 years, beginning in 1934 and continuing through 2018 when the trade wars began. In all these years, hardly anyone imagined that it could go the other way. And yet presently, after nearly a century of experience, that precedent is rapidly swirling down the drain.
David Boaz celebrates the entrepreneurship that made Woodstock possible.
Richard Rahn rightly does not celebrate a slowing economy. A slice:
Mr. Trump’s tariffs and tariff threats have added to uncertainty and hence less investment. The president doesn’t like to acknowledge that a tariff is a tax — and like most tax increases is damaging. Much as he may wish that the Chinese and others “pay” the tariff, the reality is, over the longer run, it will be the U.S. consumer that will pay most of the tariff.
In the short run, countries, particularly those with many state-controlled industries, may choose to absorb the tariff; but in the long run, it is almost always passed along to the buyers. Even when a tariff is repealed, sellers in commodity oligopolistic industries may find they can continue to charge the higher price for the commodity for some period of time as though the tariff was never abolished.
Pierre Lemieux reflects on Bernie Sanders.

|