YouTube Still Connecting Underage Users to Videos of Automatic Weapons, Homemade Firearms
On Wednesday, CfA’s Tech Transparency Project (TTP) published a new
report revealing that YouTube is still failing to enforce its
policies regarding firearms, allowing underage users to view content featuring fully automatic weapons and 3D printed guns. These findings build on earlier
research by TTP, which found that YouTube was recommending real-life firearm content to boys interested in video games. That research prompted a
letter to YouTube from Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg; a month later, YouTube quietly
tightened its firearm policies, noting that some content “may not be appropriate for viewers under 18.”
To test YouTube’s restrictions, TTP created an account and registered it as a 14-year-old. That account was then used to search YouTube for the names of common weapons manufactures. Immediately, YouTube returned videos that showed 3D printed guns being handled and fired.
TTP’s research was covered by both
Bloomberg and
The New York Post. YouTube spokesperson Javier Hernandez told Bloomberg that the company had a “a robust set of policies” governing firearms content, and would review the findings of TTP’s report. Of course, enforcement is the problem – not the policies themselves. When it comes to removing licensed music, for instance, YouTube has a “
Content ID” tool that scans videos for copyright violations. Many of the firearm videos identified by TTP made no secret of their content, and could easily be flagged for containing terms like “fully automatic” and “3D printed glock” in their titles. Instead of investing in better systems or hiring more human reviewers, YouTube appears to have simply changed its policies without a reliable means of implementing them.